Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Mike Portnoy vs Lars Ulrich read this everyone

59 views
Skip to first unread message

Steve Sheckells

unread,
Jan 15, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/15/99
to
Hi, Korn fans! I'm not a Korn fan nor will I ever be, not because as
others say,"there music sucks!!!", or anything related to that but because
in my opinion the music doesn't suck, and anyone that thinks this is a fool.
The music is fine it's just that the vocalist has no emotion or energy in
his music at all. The message isn't about Korn though, it's for those Korn
fans who are Metallica fans too, and feel that Lars Ulrich is the best
drummer there is. For you people who love great music listen to Dream
Theater. Listen to the albums by order of release to get the best of the
music. DT is Progressive Metal, and frankly is THEE only band keeping the
genre alive and even popular. They're music is so good that they're
officially in the status of rock gods like Rush, Yes, The Beatles, Pink
Floyd, Genesis, etc. I don't care much for Rush, The Beatles though. If you
want DT pics let me know I'll be glad to send them. Now to the point.

Here's the message.


Hi, I'm Jon. I'm posting this message not to bash Ulrich or Metallica but
to further expand on the concept of what makes great drummer, and other
interesting stuff. I'm not denying Ulrich or Portnoy any greatness on
anything I say, so don't think I'm bashing or critisizing. No to the point.
I'm a Dream Theater fan and they hold THEE best songs and music I've heard
to date. Mike Portnoy in my opinion is THEE best drummer for you drum
fanatics to listen to, the reason I say this isn't because he can play
very,VERY fast on drum solos, but because his musical style unlike any other
I've ever heard, and his rythems are complex to the fullest. He has the
biggest drum set I've ever seen, yes much bigger than Ulrich's. I hear very
commonly that Ulrich is the best drummer from Metallica fans, and when I
tell the that there's better drummers like Mike Portnoy, they argue, say
this and that and that about him, and they say he's better because he's got
21 years of drumming experience,or how fast he can drum. Portnoy has 23
years drumming experience but you know what? Experience doesn't make a
drummer good, nor how fast he can drum, it's how
talented he is and how smart and technical, and how complex is beats are,
and his song writing, etc. Not experience or speed. That's like saying
George Lucas is a better director than Steven Speilburg, just because he's
been around longer. And another thing I wish the Met fans I meet would stop
wanting to argue so much because arguing is a fat waste of breathe, and
doesn't acomplish anything. If your going to compare drummers let his
drumming do the talking, especially drum solos, alright? I'm simply saying
that Ulrich isn't THEE best as Met fans are suggesting. I'm not saying that
Portnoy is THEE best either.
I just want this subject to end about drummers. I would like all feeback on
questions, suggestions, opinions, and everything that you'd like to say to
ME. stev...@pacbell.net

-Jon

I'm 16 and DT is much better than Metallica and Korn. Dream Theater's been
around for 9 years and they've sold over 250 million records! 8 million in
Asia alone for the second time! And for the fourth time the sold 4 million
at least since 1994! Tell me has Korn done that?

-Jon

BoReDChIc3

unread,
Jan 16, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/16/99
to
what the fuck? the singer has no emotion? have you ever listed to daddy or kill
you or faget or my gift to you? he like fucking crys he screams all that shit
now thats fucking emoiton.korn is one of the most emo bands that i know of.
learn more about the band man,before you start saying shit like that. sorry for
sounding like a bitch but i totally diagree with you.


KoRndogg

unread,
Jan 17, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/17/99
to
the only feedback i can give you is that you are too one eyed,
you find something that you love & you think this is tha shit for everybody
else too,
Not necessarily.
you sound like a manic street preacher (no reference to the band).

I aint here too hang shit ok, but that bit about Jon's vocals is
the mosst fucked up part of your message
it's really stupid, ok i read it again & your just being sarcastic right?
u must be...

dAVe.........>-|-|-)'<

Steve Sheckells wrote in message ...

John Stafford

unread,
Jan 17, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/17/99
to
>
> I'm 16 and DT is much better than Metallica and Korn. Dream Theater's been
> around for 9 years and they've sold over 250 million records! 8 million in
> Asia alone for the second time! And for the fourth time the sold 4 million
> at least since 1994! Tell me has Korn done that?
>
> -Jon

Umm 250 million records, Yeah right. The Beatles have sold the most records to
date, some where over 100 million, and Garth Brooks is second and climbing. go
check out www.riaa.com, and look up how many albums they have sold. Also I
haven't heard dream theater so I can't compare drummer's, but my favorite
drummer is Chad Sexton from 311.
-John


Pat

unread,
Jan 17, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/17/99
to
Ok, let's look at this carefully now. This newsgroup is a Korn group,
therefore it has nothing to do with..
1)Metallica
2)Dream Theater
3)Drummers

There are specific newsgroups for those things. Why is this message here?
I'm not even going to get into how wrong he is about Jonathan and just about
everything else...
( ■@Жо|в\Л )

Jonathan LePera

unread,
Jan 29, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/29/99
to
This is a Korn newsgroup. Not Dream Theater, not Metallica....that's right
Korn. Please take up this conversation in the appropriate newsgroup. BTW
Dream Theatre might be talented but their music is downright annoying!!!


Steve Sheckells <stev...@pacbell.net> wrote in message
news:SeXn2.5153$yt4....@typhoon-sf.pbi.net...

Emre Özdiyar

unread,
Mar 11, 2023, 1:03:41 PM3/11/23
to
0 new messages