Z. S.
There is a lot happening in many parts of the world which is
wrong and misguided. You have mentioned Yazidis, Mozambique
militants etc. However, there is little that we can do about
what is going on in other far-off countries --- except sympa-
thising with the oppressed.........
But this particular incident (the young Muslim boy) happened
in our own country. And that is why it is so sickening and
despicable.
When I was in India --- and here I am talking about a period
some 65-70 years ago --- I had a few friends from the Sikh
community too. One such family was in Sambhalpur, in Orissa
(now Odisha). I happened to visit Sambhalpur once. Though it
was for a single day, but that Sikh family compelled me to stay
with them for four days........
And, yes, I am not only aware of the "langar" tradition but have
had an opportunity to partake of the same. It was in Bombay,
very near the Alankar Cinema House.
****************
However, I am afraid one will hardly find many people today who
subscribe to what Sahir has said in the above song, which is from
the film "Dhool Ka Phool".
I remember seeing the film in Bombay's Minerva Cinema --- the
old Cinema Hall built by Sohrab Modi, much before it was torn
down and replaced by a magnificent new structure.....
But, do pardon me for believing that the sentiments expressed in
the song are a bit of a sham. The song is lip-synched by noted
character actor Manmohan Krishn, who finds an abandoned young
boy and decides to bring him up as "an insaan", rather than as
a hindu or Muslim. But he himself is a devout Muslim (in the
film) and shown as performing Namaaz studiously.
I believe I have written about this many years ago, either in
ALUP or the music group RMIM.
BTW, I don't know if you are aware that Manmohan Krishn was
a Professor of Physics in a Bombay College. But acting was his
passion.
****************
Writing lyrics in films is a profession, a means of livelihood.
One cannot define or determine a poet's religion through any of
his songs. For instance, Shakeel Badayuni wrote quite a few
bhajans. That did not mean that he was a hindu. The late
actress Sadhana essayed a Muslim character (Husna ?) in the film
"Mere Mehboob". But can we call her a Muslim on that account ?
Afzal