Has anyone successfully taken thompson's off before? I hear it's as
crappy a product as you can imagine.
--
Uno
IIRC, it's wax disolved in solvents, so methods for removing wax might be
helpful.
Take it to one of those furniture stripping services. They ought to be
able to get that miserable Thompsons off. Failing that, inform the
client that his bad choice will mean a door replacement. Its a tough
one, good luck with making anything on the job.
Joe
Since it soaks into the wood well, probably only sanding or planing will do
any kind of reasonable job. Or, use something non-transparent.
I find it quite odd that a product that has been around so long and does
such a good job of waterproofing gets such bad reviews in this group.
Did someone get fucked by thompsons at one time, or what???
--
Steve Barker
remove the "not" from my address to email
Consumer's Reports was generally not positive compared to other
products IIRC.
If you look at most factual comparisons like consumer reports you'll
find that it does poorly compared to almost all the other products.
The only thing they do well is advertise.
People may be thinking about the "old" oil-based Thompson's. A few
years ago it became unavailable in California, and the water-based
version deserves every epithet directed at it.
HB
Perhaps that's the reason for my confusion. I haven't used the stuff
for about 15 years.
> I have used it on wood, brick, and a canvas painters tarp that I made
> into a tent. It sealed the wood very well, it stopped the brick from
> chipping when water froze on it in winter, and that tarp never leaked
> a drop as a tent. I have been perfectly happy with the product. I
> should mention that the building I put it on the brick was an entire
> large church, and we used many 5 gallon buckets of it.
>
> I also have their semi transparent oil stain on my garage. The garage
> was only sides with plain 1/2" plywood. It's 8 years since it was
> stained and there is no water damaged plywood. I am seeing where it
> could use another coat though since its beginning to look thin in
> spots.
>
> The "water seal" IS a wax. I think the stain contains it too, but I'm
> not positive.
>
> To the OP.
> Why remove it from that door? Get some of their semi-transparent OR
> solid stain and paint the door with it. There is no need to remove
> it.
>
Thanks all for comments. I've got a vision for this door now, to bring
it to the end of its rehabilition.
I had to scrub off huge mildewy parts of this door. The suggestion that
I tell this client to abandon this door is, with consideration, rejected
absolutely.
In what temperature zone was this church?
--
Uno