Thanks,
Todd Killian
I have had the same experience when I tried to replace one hinge on a cabinet
door, because... it seems even if they are the same supplier and style they
vary slightly apparently from changes in tolerances in manufacturing.
Changing hinges in pairs is more reliable. I have also had new hinges that
simply would not work even though it looked the same in every respect... and I
had to clean up the old hinges and re-use them
In your case, I would drill the holes that mount the hinges in the door....
with a 1/8" drill... and then glue 1/8" dowels in to fill the hole and trim
them flush. Let the glue dry.
Then.... hold the cabinet door in the proper place for it to hang and then
drill the new holes in the proper position. If you have spring loaded hinges,
be sure to have the hinges down tight on the case in what would be the closed
position.
When the doors were hung new; the hinges were installed on the doors, the door
is placed into position and one screw went into the upper and one into the
lower hinge. Then the door is "tweaked" into the propper position and the other
screws installed. When you replaced the hinges, you returned the doors to the
"unadjusted" positions. Try removing one upper and lower screw and
repositioning the doors. Tooth picks may be needed to fill the old holes if
there is significant movement. Don't try to bend or move anything with a door
open, always do it in the closed position.
J.P.