Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Attaching a hose holder to a house with vinyl siding

1,040 views
Skip to first unread message

Mike

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 1:15:23 PM6/1/07
to
My wife wants to attach a cheapo garden hose holder to the side of our
house near the hose spigot. The house has vinyl siding. Should I
just drill a small hole and then screw the hose holder on?

Thanks...

Mike

Edwin Pawlowski

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 2:25:18 PM6/1/07
to

"Mike" <tetr...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1180718123.8...@m36g2000hse.googlegroups.com...

> My wife wants to attach a cheapo garden hose holder to the side of our
> house near the hose spigot. The house has vinyl siding. Should I
> just drill a small hole and then screw the hose holder on?
>

If you hit a stud, no problem. If you don't his a stud, it will eventually
pull out of the sheathing and then you have holes left in the siding. Get a
hose reel that sits on the ground. Get a good one as the cheap ones are
frustrating to use and a waste of money. Triton makes the absolute best, but
are pricey.


Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 2:41:35 PM6/1/07
to
Nothing is easy in home repair!!!
We tried to replace the packing washer in our outside hose bib and that
seemed to go OK, but we removed the screw securing the handle and that
screw seemed to plug a hole in the hollow stem which now leaks.

What is the purpose of a hole in the hollow stem and how do you stop THAT
from from leaking?

The guys at Lowes never heard of such a thing.

Here is a picture to help you understand what I have...
http://mysite.verizon.net/bjkass123/bibhole.jpg

Thanks for any ideas of what it's for and how to fix.

Joy

Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 2:55:31 PM6/1/07
to
(I'm SO sorry. I'm learning a new browser and I managed to post this as a
reply for someone else instead of a new post.)

betsyb

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 2:58:33 PM6/1/07
to
Maybe like a prevention for a frozen pipe. Blows out if under pressure?
Could be.

--

BetsyB

"Joy" <Mycr...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:op.ts9at...@user-47b243c432.myhome.westell.com...

Roger

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 3:01:18 PM6/1/07
to

"Mike" <tetr...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1180718123.8...@m36g2000hse.googlegroups.com...
> My wife wants to attach a cheapo garden hose holder to the side of our
> house near the hose spigot. The house has vinyl siding. Should I
> just drill a small hole and then screw the hose holder on?"

Hose reels that attach to the side of the house work fine, and don't pull
all over the place like bulky stand-alone reels. I've had 10-20 dollar ones
that last many years.
Use a stud finder to locate the 2x4's, mark with pencil, then do a 1/16th"
test drill to see if you get wood. If the pilot hole shows shavings, make
the hole the final size, and mount reel. Sometimes, if you are lucky,
mounting holes are spaced to fit typical stud spacing.
Roger


Roger

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 3:07:20 PM6/1/07
to

" Nothing is easy in home repair!!!
> We tried to replace the packing washer in our outside hose bib and that
> seemed to go OK, but we removed the screw securing the handle and that
> screw seemed to plug a hole in the hollow stem which now leaks.> What is
> the purpose of a hole in the hollow stem and how do you stop THAT from
> from leaking?> The guys at Lowes never heard of such a thing.> Here is a
> picture to help you understand what I have...
> http://mysite.verizon.net/bjkass123/bibhole.jpg> Thanks for any ideas of
> what it's for and how to fix.> Joy"

I've also never heard of a completely hollow valve stem. Usually, the hole
is tapped only deep enough to take the handle mounting screw. Are you sure
it is leaking through the hole, and not from the base of the stem where it
goes into the valve nut? May be easiest just to replace the hose bib valve,
if replacing the packing and replacing the handle does not do the trick.
Bib valves are fairly cheap.


Grandpa

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 3:26:21 PM6/1/07
to
Replace it. That is a boiler drain valve, not a true hosebib.
You can't stop it from leaking, because it looks like its been
modified to use the screw instead of the nut to hold the handle on.
Since it is a boiler valve, you can replace the whole stem and
washer from another 3/4 inch boiler valve. The guys at Lowes ought
to be able to sell you on of those for less than $10.
--
Grandpa

Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 3:33:10 PM6/1/07
to
On Fri, 01 Jun 2007 15:07:20 -0400, Roger <sherryrogeratcomcastdotnet>
wrote:

Replacing would probably be difficult. It might be welded on the pipe. Do
any of these things get screwed on??? I don't want to risk making things
worse.

I can SEE the lower part of the screw through the hole in the stem and I'm
sure the water is leaking from this hole (probably squeezing past the
screw threads). WITHOUT the screw, the water squirts from the hole under
pressure. Caught me by surprise, it did.

I don't believe the hole is to relieve pressure since you can just open
the bib valve and do the same thing.

Joy

Grandpa

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 3:46:59 PM6/1/07
to
Joy wrote:
> On Fri, 01 Jun 2007 15:07:20 -0400, Roger <sherryrogeratcomcastdotnet>
> wrote:
>>> We tried to replace the packing washer in our outside hose bib and that
>>> seemed to go OK, but we removed the screw securing the handle and that
>>> screw seemed to plug a hole in the hollow stem which now leaks.> What is
>>> the purpose of a hole in the hollow stem and how do you stop THAT from
>>> from leaking?> The guys at Lowes never heard of such a thing.> Here is a
>>> picture to help you understand what I have...
>>> http://mysite.verizon.net/bjkass123/bibhole.jpg> Thanks for any ideas of
>>> what it's for and how to fix.> Joy"
>>
>> I've also never heard of a completely hollow valve stem. Usually, the
>> hole is tapped only deep enough to take the handle mounting screw. Are
>> you sure it is leaking through the hole, and not from the base of the
>> stem where it goes into the valve nut? May be easiest just to replace
>> the hose bib valve, if replacing the packing and replacing the handle
>> does not do the trick.
>> Bib valves are fairly cheap.
>
> Replacing would probably be difficult. It might be welded on the pipe.
> Do any of these things get screwed on??? I don't want to risk making
> things worse.
>

Boiler valves are NOT welded. They screw on. Yours looks like a 3/4
FIP valve. Depending upon what the attaching pipe is, you may or may
not be able to wrench it off. If its old galvanized pipe, you're
probably better off replacing the guts of the valve.
--
Grandpa

Message has been deleted

Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 4:00:39 PM6/1/07
to

AAhhh. I tried my best to be clear. I'm afraid you assumed the picture is
of my actual bib... It's not. It's just a picture I found so I could
illustrate.

The bib does not appear to be modified and I doubt it was leaking from
that hole until I removed the screw holding the handle on. Hmmmm. Maybe
some loc-tite or something to seal the threads and block the water?
Anyway, still want to know why the hollow stem and how it should REALLY be
repaired.

Joy

Mike

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 4:05:28 PM6/1/07
to
On Jun 1, 2:55 pm, Joy <Mycrof...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> (I'm SO sorry. I'm learning a new browser and I managed to post this as a
> reply for someone else instead of a new post.)
>
> Joy

I make 2 or 3 posts to alt.home.repair per year, and one of 'em gets
hi-jacked??

Message has been deleted

Grandpa

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 4:34:16 PM6/1/07
to
Post a real picture then if you real help. Still might be able to
fix it for less than $10.
--
Grandpa

tn...@mucks.net

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 4:48:39 PM6/1/07
to

>I can SEE the lower part of the screw through the hole in the stem and I'm
>sure the water is leaking from this hole (probably squeezing past the
>screw threads). WITHOUT the screw, the water squirts from the hole under
>pressure. Caught me by surprise, it did.

This hole that leaks......are you saying it is the same hole as
the screw screws into, or are you saying that it is a hole that goes
through the side of the stem?

Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 5:29:05 PM6/1/07
to

On Fri, 01 Jun 2007 16:24:05 -0400, Meat Plow <me...@meatplow.local> wrote:

> Take a picture of it if you can and put it up so we can see it.
>
>


Ok. If nobody figures this out I will take actual photos.
It will have to wait until my camera is repaired so it may be a while but
I'll do it first thing when it returns.

Joy

Joy

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 5:31:36 PM6/1/07
to

It is leaking from the hole in the side of the stem through which you can
see the side of the screw that holds the handle on.

Joy

Message has been deleted

Jeff Wisnia

unread,
Jun 1, 2007, 7:48:09 PM6/1/07
to
Joy wrote:


I'll make a WAG that maybe the other end of that valve stem is pretty
conventionally shaped and has a rubber washer on it which should be held
in place by a screw. Maybe THAT screw has loosened (or even fallen out)
so that the rubber washer is no longer compressed under the screw's head
to keep water from entering the screw hole at that point.

To the OP, disassemble the hose bib further and let us know what you
find on the business end of the stem.

What that cross hole in the stem is for is a question I'd like to hear
the answer to. <G>

Jeff

--
Jeffry Wisnia
(W1BSV + Brass Rat '57 EE)
The speed of light is 1.8*10^12 furlongs per fortnight.

Bob M.

unread,
Jun 2, 2007, 2:12:04 AM6/2/07
to

"Joy" <Mycr...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:op.ts9at...@user-47b243c432.myhome.westell.com...
> (I'm SO sorry. I'm learning a new browser and I managed to post this as a
> reply for someone else instead of a new post.)
>
> Nothing is easy in home repair!!!
> We tried to replace the packing washer in our outside hose bib and that
> seemed to go OK, but we removed the screw securing the handle and that
> screw seemed to plug a hole in the hollow stem which now leaks.

Could that be a "freeze-proof" spigot? It's a little unlikely based on the
picture but you said it's a generic picture, not one of the actual item.

Freeze-proof spigots have a long (6+ inches) stem that _is_ hollow (mine
are, anyhow), and the actual water-stopping valve portion of it is at the
far end of that stem.

Freeze proof spigots are great since you don't have to go around the house
in November turning off the outside water. That's not hard, but here in
Montana where it can freeze in September the freeze proof spigots are nice
to have.

busin...@nomail.com

unread,
Jun 2, 2007, 8:43:03 AM6/2/07
to

Or just get a 5 or 6 ft piece of treated 4x4 or 4x6 and put it in the
ground about 3 feet, then attach your reel to it. That way you wont
ruin your sideing for a hose reel that will likely fall apart in a
year. If you need more width to the post, just get a 4x8 or nail a
cross piece of 2x6 to it before you hang the reel. I have aluminum
siding and I wanted to attach a drinking fountain. Rather than wreck
the siding, and plus I needed a 6 inch wide bolt pattern, which no
stud would allow, I got a 4x6 post and used that. I did not use
cement on the post, although a hose reel has is being pulled, so it
depends on the soil. In hard clay, you probably dont need cement once
the fill hardens good. If you want to get real fancy put the post
elsewhere in the yard and run a hose to the reel and put a spigot on
the post to connect the reel. That way you can put it where its most
handy.

Joy

unread,
Jun 2, 2007, 2:24:19 PM6/2/07
to
I can't see how a freeze-proof spigot is relevant. After shutting water
supply to the bib, the water would drain from the bib. Why have to remove
the handle screw to let it dribble out the side????

Joy

Grandpa

unread,
Jun 2, 2007, 2:50:03 PM6/2/07
to
Joy wrote:
> I can't see how a freeze-proof spigot is relevant. After shutting water
> supply to the bib, the water would drain from the bib. Why have to
> remove the handle screw to let it dribble out the side????
>
> Joy
>

Until you can show us a picture of what you really have, everything
that goes on in the thread is conjecture. I'd really like to help,
but I need a little more information. KTHNXBY

--
Grandpa

mm

unread,
Jun 4, 2007, 2:08:52 AM6/4/07
to

I wouldn't drill a hole in vinyl siding, or aluminum siding, or
stucco, or stone, or bricks, etc. He's right, the thing will break
or rip out, and then you'll have a hole, bigger than the one you
drilled. OK in wood that can be repaired and painted to match, or the
mortar between bricks. (even then, I wonder how hard to match the
color of the mortar, and how long it takes before it's weathered
enough to match.

>Thanks...
>
>Mike

Marilyn Dollinger

unread,
May 1, 2020, 1:44:05 PM5/1/20
to
replying to mm, Marilyn Dollinger wrote:
> hose reel
I lived in an all brick house for 33 years and it had a hose hanger attached
by the spigot in the back yard. It was there when I moved in and it was still
there when I moved out and showed no signs of coming loose from the brick.

--
for full context, visit https://www.homeownershub.com/maintenance/attaching-a-hose-holder-to-a-house-with-vinyl-siding-221649-.htm


0 new messages