On Wed, 29 May 2013 13:21:46 -0700 (PDT),
lucky...@hotmail.com
wrote:
> Okay, I have to call B.S. on: "people that say they hear all these
> differences are home wankers and have no clue what the amp sounds
> like in an actual live band."
If someone says that they can't hear differences in [whatever], then
I'll believe them: they can't hear differences. God bless 'em.
I can easily hear differences in power tubes at low level and they're
often not so subtle. There are big differences between models (within
a given category): 6L6 vs 6V6 vs KT66, all beam tubes, will have
different signatures. And there's a day and night difference between
those and true pentodes like EL34's. Anyone who can't hear that is a
bedroom wanker! (just kidding)
There are also differences between brands, even within the same tube
model. I'm not sure how someone could plug in a Sylvania 6L6 and then
an RCA blackplate 6L6 and not hear the difference, at whatever level.
> That might be true for somebody who
> has NEVER been in a band. But I'm betting that there are plenty of
> guys here who played in bands in their teens and 20's, who now play
> for fun (or a church band, or infrequent jams...).
There was some guy here years ago that claimed that everything was
pretty much the same in guitars, so you should just grab whatever
cheap hunk o wood and the cheapest Ebay pickups you could find, and it
would make no difference. The best part though--he insisted that you
needed an aluminum nut on the guitar, and that made a big difference
even with fretted notes. There are various degrees of that going
around.
Someone insists that different types of guitar woods (or picks or
speakers) don't make a difference -to them-, then no problem. It's the
insistence that everyone else must be FOS that gets to me.
I think of it like perfect pitch. most people can't discern absolute
pitch, so someone could insist that it's BS. Yet there is a segment of
the populace with the ability.
Still, more power to anyone who can't discern. Less expensive gear
habits than mine. Conversely, I'd probably be OK drinking wine that
would send a connoisseur running for a spitoon. An insensitive nose
would be a benefit on 42nd and 9th in NYC. etc
> Nuances can get "lost in the mix." But I know for damn sure that I
> could tell the difference in my guitar tones IN THE MIX when I used
> different amps. For example, I preferred a Bandmaster over a
> Bassman. SAME power tubes. Very similar circuit. Biggest
> difference is the output transformer. And I COULD hear the
> difference.
Bassman is a great guitar amp. Showman is a great bass amp.
I used a Bassman on stage for many years. Punchy SOB! You're exactly
right--the transformer was huge compared to their guitar amps.
> So could the rest of the band. It not only affected my
> tone, but the way I played.
There you go, THAT is the biggest difference. Even the most tin-eared
audience member can tell when your playing is inspired. So do whatever
you need to get there.