In San Francisco, How 'Gangs' Are Defined Is Up for Debate

[Leroy N. Soetoro]

https://sfstandard.com/criminal-justice/in-san-francisco-how-gangs-are-
defined-is-up-for-debate/

In the early hours of New Year’s Day 2017, a group of men rushed from a
corner store called Rubin’s to confront a trio of rivals.

One of the men from the shop pulled out a weapon and was pistol whipped by
someone from the other group. Another threw a bag of glass bottles, which
shattered on the sidewalk. Then Thomas Ortiz, another one of the men from
the store, fatally shot Ernesto Rosales.

None of that is under dispute.

Whether Ortiz acted on behalf of a gang against long-standing Norteño
adversaries of the Army Street gang was put in the hands of a jury that on
Thursday found him not guilty on all counts.

Prosecutors had argued that the killing was revenge for the 2014 killing
of 14-year-old Rashawn Williams, which happened in front of the same
market and led to a spiral of retaliation.

Ortiz was put on trial for his alleged actions. But so, too, was the idea
of what even constitutes a gang in San Francisco.

The issue was raised in court after former District Attorney Chesa Boudin
ordered staff to stop charging defendants with gang enhancements, special
charges that can add years to a sentence. And it came up months after the
San Francisco Police Department overhauled its Gang Task Force,
rechristening the unit as the Community Violence Reduction Team.

Similar backlash against law enforcement characterizations of gang
violence has also recently gone to the wayside after a court struck down
longstanding restrictions the City Attorney’s Office imposed on the way
SFPD addresses criminal street groups.

The case has also reignited debate over how police and prosecutors should
handle gang violence in the city.

District Attorney Brooke Jenkins—who critiqued Boudin for the way he
handled another allegedly gang-related murder trial involving one of her
relatives, and was the initally prosecutor handling the Ortiz case—sat in
the audience as the jury read its verdict last week.

What Makes a Gang?
Unlike many other major cities, San Francisco has few gangs linked to
larger criminal enterprises like the Norteños and Sureños, law enforcement
experts say. Most are parochial, often linked to just a few blocks.

The exceptions being Sureños and Norteños, which both have hierarchical
structures that exist beyond San Francisco and operate as larger criminal
enterprises. Whereas most other groups in San Francisco that police have
identified as gangs have much less rigid structures. Public defenders have
argued that they are simply neighborhood groups whose members break the
law from time to time.

In the course of their investigations, police use a number of tools to
prove gang affiliation. In the Ortiz case, the testimony of Sgt. Robert
Trujillo illustrated the multifaceted process police use.

SFPD’s gang designation can include a person’s social media posts, their
tattoos, who they hang out with, the clothes they wear, who they associate
with in jail and what graffiti they scrawl on the urban landscape,
Trujillo testified.

Social media, Trujillo said, is often where police find people who “self
identify” as gang members by wearing certain colors or flashing hand signs
or writing posts alluding to a specific group.

As an indication of the level of continued criminal activity linked to
gangs, at least in terms of how the police see it, 318 incidents since
2018 were gang related, according to Data SF. Still, in the past year the
number of such incidents has been a small fraction of those cases with
only 27 being gang related.

As far as affiliation, police said Ortiz is an Army Street gang member.

In the case of the Army Street gang that means donning camo, writing or
wearing the number 26 for 26th Street near the Bernal Dwellings, which
used to be called the Army Street Projects and is where most of the
alleged members are from. Cesar Chavez Street, which the Bernal Dwellings
are located, used to be called Army Street.

In a report on the Army Street Gang in 2018, another officer who
testified, Sgt. Scott Lau, wrote that the group has been around since the
1990s and its territory has centered on Bernal Dwellings. The group, he
wrote, uses a number of symbols such at A+, Army St, 26 Mob and ASG and
has been involved in robberies, battery and even murder.

“The primary activity of the Army St. gang is crime,” Trujillo wrote.

Retired Gang Task Force member Leonard Broburg said that often when
members of any of these groups moved out of the county and committed a
crime, SFPD gang experts were summoned as experts in their prosecution.

While there are more organized gangs in San Francisco, like the Norteños,
the murky definitions of gangs and their members is hard to dispute
because the expertise is so specialized, San Francisco deputy public
defender Yali Corea-Levy argued.

“How do you impeach them, prove that they are wrong?” he asked in court.

There is no textbook, no outside expert to refute the gang designations
made by the police department, he added.

“All I can do is call other cops and demonstrate they can’t agree,” Corea-
Levy said. “It’s not a real area of expertise.”

In the Ortiz trial, Corea-Levy asked three officers to identify Army
Street Gang members—and all three officers disagreed but for one name.

In a picture shown to the jury, Corea-Levy noted that a Bernal Dwelling
resident, who was involved in the fight that led to the killing, was shown
beside his mother, who wore a camouflage sweatshirt with the word “army”
emblazoned across it—one of many clues police would say indicate gang
affiliation.

Gang Task Force?
SFPD’s Gang Task Force was born more than four decades ago, in 1977, after
a bloody Chinatown shooting known as the Golden Dragon massacre in which
convicted gang boss Raymond “Shrimpboy” Chow was present. The gunfire left
five dead and 11 injured. Initially focused on Asian gangs, the unit began
to investigate Latino and Black gangs in the 1980s, according to the SFPD.

Last year, however, the Gang Task Force was “disbanded” and rebranded with
the department adding 10 officers and rechristening the unit as the
Community Violence Reduction Team.

“There is no more Gang Task Force,” Chief Bill Scott said to the San
Francisco Police Commision in May of 2021 year, adding that it was a total
restructuring.

The new unit is meant to work with civilian groups to end gun violence and
the Gun Crime Intelligence Center, to try and understand the complicated
causes of such violence.

But even though its name has been softened, how it operates when it comes
to identifying gangs remains fairly unchanged, Corea-Levy said.

“‘Gang’ is a label put on by law enforcement,” he said, “which is
something the unit, whatever you call it, continues to do.”

As if to affirm as much, an April memo that Sgt. Trujillo wrote in the
Ortiz case notes that the unit is no longer the Gang Task Force—but it was
penned on stationary still marked with the Gang Task Force letterhead. The
department’s website also still lists the task force under its old name.

The Violence Continues
Regardless of whether a group fits the police definition of gangs, there’s
no denying that rivalries among various factions have led to killings in
San Francisco.

A 2021 analysis found that 12 groups were responsible for the majority of
violence committed in the city. Those cliques—in the Bayview, Visitacion
Valley, the Fillmore and the Mission—were responsible for most shootings
from 2017 to mid-2020, according to police data. All told, the analysis
noted, roughly 200 people are responsible for most gun violence in San
Francisco.

But groups come and go, making it all the more complicated to identify
hierarchies and affiliations. In the case of the so-called Army Street
Gang, it has all but dissipated since the 2017 killing, as police say its
more active members have either been murdered, moved or gotten out of the
game.

As for Ortiz, who was released last week after a four-year jail stint, he
is simply happy the jury agreed with his version of events, Corea-Levy
said: that is, that he was acting in self-defense.


--
"LOCKDOWN", left-wing COVID fearmongering. 95% of COVID infections
recover with no after effects.

No collusion - Special Counsel Robert Swan Mueller III, March 2019.
Officially made Nancy Pelosi a two-time impeachment loser.

Donald J. Trump, cheated out of a second term by fraudulent "mail-in"
ballots. Report voter fraud: sf.n...@mail.house.gov

Thank you for cleaning up the disaster of the 2008-2017 Obama / Biden
fiasco, President Trump.

Under Barack Obama's leadership, the United States of America became the
The World According To Garp. Obama sold out heterosexuals for Hollywood
queer liberal democrat donors.

President Trump boosted the economy, reduced illegal invasions, appointed
dozens of judges and three SCOTUS justices.