Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Recommendations for a good under eye concealer...

2 views
Skip to first unread message

sjko...@yahoo.com

unread,
May 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/25/00
to
I am looking for a good under eye concealor for fair skin. What comes
to mind at first thought... Benefit Boing, Laura Mercier Secret
Concealer, NARS Concealer. What do you recommend?

AnaisMorr

unread,
May 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/27/00
to
I used to swear by Benefit's Bo-ing until I tried Laura Mercier.

LM all the way! No need to even set it with powder and it is so moisturizing!

Tess

Celeste

unread,
May 28, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/28/00
to
I like Stila's under eye concealer. Smooth, efficiant, lasts forever.
doesn't cake either.

Celeste

Danielle

unread,
May 28, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/28/00
to
but doesn't come pale enough for some of us :(

In article <NndY4.4979$%11.39858@news02>, Celeste says...
*I like Stila's under eye concealer. Smooth, efficiant, lasts forever.
*doesn't cake either.
*
*Celeste
*
*
*

--
Danielle
--
"I may disagree with what you say, but I will fight to the death for your right
to say it." --Voltaire

HMatz88888

unread,
May 28, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/28/00
to
Aveda's is FANtastic!!!!! Like Stila's in texture but more long lasting and not
as yellow. And probably cheaper.

*************************
Exclusiv...@ExclusivelyHmatz.com
*************************

Daphne Liew

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
Oh, concealers, the bane, yet love of my life.....have found a few
really nice ones, yet the quest for smoother, better coverage ones
goes on......

Ones that I *approve* of right now :

-Ben Nye Red Neutralizer in #1 ( slight dry texture that doesn't budge
once on skin, yet surprisingly doesn't emphasize the fine lines under
my eye area too)

-YSL Touche Eclat ( yesh, it's pink! Horrors! who'd have thought pink
toned anything would work on my pale very yellow skin, but
mystifiyingly, it does work to brighten up the eye area, perhaps due
to the overall sheerness of the prdt, the pink doesn't quite scream
out.)

-Keromask by Christy ( A rather new aquisition, relatively hard to
find and imo damn expensive for the tiny tube but what a gem! Covers
flawlessly w/o sinking into fine lines and just a smidgen, as in a
tiny dot will be enough for both eyes. Make sure to moisturise the
undereye area well first as it's super-pigmented and needs a moist
surface to blend perfectly. Anyone who knows me, would know that I
rarely if ever rave about any product, but this is one concealer that
everyone should try)

regards
Daphne

yz...@my-deja.com

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
The absolute best concealer I've used (and I've tried tons!) is Mary
Kay in "beige." Unfortunately, it's not easily obtained if you prefer
department store shopping. However, people are dealing it on eBay
all the time.

In article <392c71b...@news.doit.wisc.edu>,


sjko...@yahoo.com wrote:
> I am looking for a good under eye concealor for fair skin. What comes
> to mind at first thought... Benefit Boing, Laura Mercier Secret
> Concealer, NARS Concealer. What do you recommend?
>


Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.

J NIL

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
Daphne, Where did you find this product? It sounds good.
jnil

Daphne Liew wrote:
>
>
> out.)
>
> -Keromask by Christy ( A rather new aquisition, relatively hard to
> find and imo damn expensive for the tiny tube but what a gem! Covers
> flawlessly w/o sinking into fine lines and just a smidgen, as in a
> tiny dot will be enough for both eyes. Make sure to moisturise the
> undereye area well first as it's super-pigmented and needs a moist
> surface to blend perfectly. Anyone who knows me, would know that I
> rarely if ever rave about any product, but this is one concealer that
> everyone should try)
>
> regards
> Daphne

MakeupGrrl

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
I love Benefit's Bo-oing! The texture is a bit thick, so I mix it
with the God of All Amazing Products, RCMA Foundation Thinner. If I
need to lighten it, I mix in a little Max Factor Erace (another
awesome and handy product). Ben Nye's Mellow Yellow is great to mix
in if you've got a lot of purple/darkness going on.

MG

H. Chan

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
Daphne Liew <liew_...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3933c87f...@news.soneraplaza.nl...
: Oh, concealers, the bane, yet love of my life.....have found a few

: really nice ones, yet the quest for smoother, better coverage ones
: goes on......

Hey Daph, oh skincare guru of mine, so happy to see you post! Now you
can directly convey your wisdom on skincare and foundations to AF,
rather than via yours truly.

: Ones that I *approve* of right now :


:
: -Ben Nye Red Neutralizer in #1 ( slight dry texture that doesn't budge
: once on skin, yet surprisingly doesn't emphasize the fine lines under
: my eye area too)

Yes, love this! A soft and creamy pencil that doesn't pull on the
fragile undereye area. Offers nicely opaque coverage.

: -Keromask by Christy ( A rather new aquisition, relatively hard to


: find and imo damn expensive for the tiny tube but what a gem! Covers
: flawlessly w/o sinking into fine lines and just a smidgen, as in a
: tiny dot will be enough for both eyes. Make sure to moisturise the
: undereye area well first as it's super-pigmented and needs a moist
: surface to blend perfectly. Anyone who knows me, would know that I
: rarely if ever rave about any product, but this is one concealer that
: everyone should try)

I've never met anyone as picky about concealers <g>. I've tried out
Daph's tube of Keromask in Ultra Light, and yes, it's great. I want one
of my own! For those of you who love Shu's Mark Cealer for its super
coverage, but find Beige 4 still too dark, Keromask in Ultra Light is a
very nice, super pale yellow-based shade. It comes in 6 shades in total,
Dark, Medium, Light, Ultra Light, Yellow, and White. You can find out
more at http://www.amazingconcealer.com/.

Screenface used to have this, but no longer :(. Brushup also sells
Keromask, and I know Andira and Daphne are also hoping to stock it (good
luck, guys).

--
Saresha [remove 'antispam.' to reply]
http://sites.netscape.net/saresha/swaplist.htm


Daphne Liew

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to

Sarsh! You give me too much credit.....many a time there were that I
remember, being the good lil lemming that you are ( me too) have
ordered so many skincare prdts sight unseen and I believe with more
to come in the future..your brave forays into the world of rare and
unknown but much raved about goes unparrelled...

If I am your skincare gure, then surely you are my *colour
initiato*r...if not for your constant urgings to be brave, daring and
*seize that heavenly, shimmering, bold green*, I'd still be lost in
the sea of pale beiges and whites, alas now, I can barely resist
anything green, blue, purple, turquoise and glittery and for that, I
thank you...

The keromask, I found can also be used to mixed with some moisturiser
to form your own DIY TM, and because it's so very pigmented, once
again, you only have to use a miniscule portion of it to get it to
work and it really worked just as well as my LM.

I have also tried using loose mineral powder e.g LBD, BE and
youngblood as a concealer and it did work somewhat, gave nice glowy
coverage, but a bit of a hassle to concoct as one has to mix the
powders with an eyecream first and it had to be a very exact amount of
powder used as too much would render it gunky and hard to blend while
too little wouldn't provide the coverage needed.

I would still opt for the Ben nye as the overall winner as it gave the
optimum coverage and had the texture that I look for in an undereye
concealer. iT is creamy yet wasn't too emollient that after 5 mins,
it'd start to crease...perfect imo. Also, the price can't be beat.
About $6 for a small pot.

still on the hunt,
daphne

H. Chan

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
Daphne Liew <liew_...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:39341f5f...@news.soneraplaza.nl...
:
: Sarsh! You give me too much credit.....many a time there were that I

: remember, being the good lil lemming that you are ( me too) have
: ordered so many skincare prdts sight unseen and I believe with more
: to come in the future..your brave forays into the world of rare and
: unknown but much raved about goes unparrelled...

You, madam, are single-handedly responsible for my now huge skincare
expenditure :P. To think I couldn't tell retinol from AHA before!

: If I am your skincare gure, then surely you are my *colour


: initiato*r...if not for your constant urgings to be brave, daring and
: *seize that heavenly, shimmering, bold green*, I'd still be lost in
: the sea of pale beiges and whites, alas now, I can barely resist
: anything green, blue, purple, turquoise and glittery and for that, I
: thank you...

Oh thank you, you know I had to return the favour ;-). And I refuse to
take responsibility for that fuchsia obsession you have going on, btw...

: The keromask, I found can also be used to mixed with some moisturiser


: to form your own DIY TM, and because it's so very pigmented, once
: again, you only have to use a miniscule portion of it to get it to
: work and it really worked just as well as my LM.

And I imagine to get the perfect shade, one could mix in the white
and/or yellow shades as toners. I'm not even a religious concealer user,
but I can't wait to get my hands on a tube of keromask now! (This is
true lemming spirit, eh?)

: I have also tried using loose mineral powder e.g LBD, BE and


: youngblood as a concealer and it did work somewhat, gave nice glowy
: coverage, but a bit of a hassle to concoct as one has to mix the
: powders with an eyecream first and it had to be a very exact amount of
: powder used as too much would render it gunky and hard to blend while
: too little wouldn't provide the coverage needed.

That's what I thought too, that it'll be hard to get an even product. In
any case, I find loose mineral powder too hard to use as foundation, and
I wouldn't buy it just for use as concealer.

: I would still opt for the Ben nye as the overall winner as it gave the


: optimum coverage and had the texture that I look for in an undereye
: concealer. iT is creamy yet wasn't too emollient that after 5 mins,
: it'd start to crease...perfect imo. Also, the price can't be beat.
: About $6 for a small pot.

Oh you weren't talking about the pencil? Ok, I have to admit being lazy
with concealers. I like Shu's Mark Cealer very much, for example, but
most days it's just easier to use the Ben Nye pencil, or Nars concealer
(comes in a twist up lipstick tube). The Nars is quite nice if you
aren't looking for maximum coverage.

I also have the BB concealer (in a small concealer), but I haven't used
it much. Even more often, I just use a stick foundation on the parts
that need concealing. FACE Stockholm Highlighter Yellow (in a pot) is a
very pale pastel yellow that works well. It's rather dry and waxy, and
you just need very very little (or else you can get odd yellow patches
under the eyes). Another pale waxy yellow (though not pastel but closer
to skin tone) concealer is Le Maquillage Fard Creme in C.1. I don't have
dry skin, so I don't have much difficulty with dry concealers. In
addition to moisturising the eye area, what works really well is to hold
the finger over the undereye area, let the concealer melt in nicely,
then pat it in to blend. I believe I learnt the trick here.

H. Chan

unread,
May 30, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/30/00
to
H. Chan <morg...@antispam.cryogen.com> wrote in message
news:8h1bgv$25bbp$1...@fu-berlin.de...
: I also have the BB concealer (in a small concealer),

I meant, in a small compact. This one is pretty dry too, I just noticed.

karen+ang

unread,
May 31, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/31/00
to

>I've never met anyone as picky about concealers <g>. I've tried out

Yes yes. And when it comes to under eye concealers, how can I forget
Daphne?

I've been using Stila's eye concealer and realised now that it's the
culprit that emphasized my fine lines, by bringing all the powder
particles in the creases.

I guess I will have to search for the Keromask ($40!!!!) and the Ben
Nye. If it's an aye from Daphne, it can't be too bad.

karen
_______________________________________
If I do not want what you want,
please try not to tell me that my want is wrong.

http://karen.webvis.net/karenang

Daphne Liew

unread,
May 31, 2000, 3:00:00 AM5/31/00
to
hey karen!! Long time no see! :)

I think you'll really like the ben nye. It comes in both the pencil
(which saresha likes a lot and which I regret not getting! ) and pot
form. Remember the KP pencil concealer that we tried before? Well, the
BN pencil one is way creamier and gives an even better coverage than
that! Except that the KP one was a pale pale yellow shade while the BN
is a pale neutral, I believe there is one called mellow yellow that
lives up to it's name but not quite as pale as I'd like it to be, but
the texture is equally great as the red neutralizer.

For lighter coverage ( or for those with less severe undereye problems
as I ), you could try Lancome's Effercerns, comes in a tube and super
blendable, or Loreal's Visible Lift concealer which is so much like
the above only 2x cheaper! Both are really smooth and covers nicely
without drying out the skin or sinking into those dreaded lines. One I
did not like was the CM concealer which despite felt and looked so
nice when tested out on my hand (as most prdts do, strangely, okok so
maybe my face is more wrinkled than anywhere else on my body ) when on
really blotchy and unevenly under the eyes, no matter how long I took
to pat it on.

Okay girls, I believe I've gone on enough about concealers for the
night.....time to catch some Zzzz before Iam forced to resort to
something stronger than mere concealer, lazer surgery perhaps?
hmm...something to sleep on.....

nite all!
daphne

0 new messages