Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Engine oil change checks

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Alan Berry

unread,
Nov 26, 2009, 4:31:05 PM11/26/09
to
I am now the proud owner of a 2008 Disco 2.7 Diesel. I have to say I am very
pleased with it and intend to look after it.

It is still in warranty and part of the deal was that it would be serviced
at a LR dealer and the book stamped.

In the past I have always maintained all my vehicles and never fail to
change the oil regularly. I had my last disco for 16years.

Having taken a look at the oil in my new disco it does not look that clean
to me assuming it has been changed.

Yes I know that it usually gets a bit discoloured by the remnants of the old
oil in the sump.

Two questions.

Is there some way of getting a check done on the oil to prove it has / has
not been changed.

The service I had stamped in the book was a service B 29541mls. The oil
service check box has not been ticked. Not sure if service B automaitcally
includes an oil change.

The previous service was a service A at 17797mls.

I am having real problems trying to locate service information such as oil
change intervals.

I am planning to go back to the garage to enquire but before that I would be
interested in getting some advice here.

Thanks

Alan


andrew

unread,
Nov 26, 2009, 5:10:48 PM11/26/09
to

>
>
> Is there some way of getting a check done on the oil to prove it has / has
> not been changed.

http://www.spectro-oil.com

I have had no dealings with them and it is probably OTT but they may be
worth a call. They chifly analyse oil from big kit to see what is wearing
in the engine but they should be able to analyse thing like residual
detergent, deterioration in viscosity improvers and soot contamination.

AJH

Andy

unread,
Nov 26, 2009, 5:36:33 PM11/26/09
to
"Alan Berry" <alan....@dsl.pipex.com> wrote in message
news:kuadnVoMdZXAZ5PW...@pipex.net...

>I am now the proud owner of a 2008 Disco 2.7 Diesel. I have to say I am
>very pleased with it and intend to look after it.
>
> I am having real problems trying to locate service information such as oil
> change intervals.
> I am planning to go back to the garage to enquire but before that I would
> be interested in getting some advice here.
Alan


I have had a couple of D3's now, best place for info is here
www.disco3.co.uk

Loads of very useful info and a great bunch of people, search around on the
site or join the forum and post your question. (my username is CFB)

Cheers

--
Andy


Dougal

unread,
Nov 26, 2009, 6:01:57 PM11/26/09
to
andrew wrote:
>>
>> Is there some way of getting a check done on the oil to prove it has / has
>> not been changed.
>
> http://www.spectro-oil.com
>
> I have had no dealings with them and it is probably OTT but they may be
> worth a call. They chiefly analyse oil from big kit to see what is wearing

> in the engine but they should be able to analyse thing like residual
> detergent, deterioration in viscosity improvers and soot contamination.
>
> AJH

The quickest and cheapeast solution is to trust no-one and change the
oil regardless. Or even get them to change it for free! Be honest,
you're not going to be happy unless you've done so anyway.

Oil analysis is fine for fleet users trying to reduce lubricant costs to
the minimum whilst at the same time keeping an eye open for incipient
problems: it's not for you and me. It is, as Andrew suggests, OTT just
to avoid the cost of a fill of oil and won't give you any feeling of
real 'comfort'.

Diesels dirty their oil very quickly and it is quite possible that
nothing is amiss. But I have a feeling that you, like me, don't agree
with the current move to grossly extended oil change intervals. I was a
confirmed 3000mi changer (2.25/3.5/300Tdi) but have dragged myself to
5000mi for the TD5 - that's quite enough for the average type of use.

Get a blank copy of the service check list from the dealer - it was in
RAVE for the earlier models: I wouldn't know where to look for this model.

Neil

unread,
Nov 27, 2009, 6:52:09 AM11/27/09
to Dougal
>
> Diesels dirty their oil very quickly and it is quite possible that
> nothing is amiss. But I have a feeling that you, like me, don't agree
> with the current move to grossly extended oil change intervals. I was a
> confirmed 3000mi changer (2.25/3.5/300Tdi) but have dragged myself to
> 5000mi for the TD5 - that's quite enough for the average type of use.
>

I'm much happier with the 16,000 intervals, considering the astounding
price of the oil my RR prefers :(

--
Neil

Nige

unread,
Nov 27, 2009, 6:54:55 AM11/27/09
to

"Neil" <n.bro...@pccsuk-nospamplease.com> wrote in message
news:4B0FBD69...@pccsuk-nospamplease.com...

Standard!


0 new messages