In essence the Harry Potter universe is based upon the teachings of
Gerald Gardner, the founder of the Wicca religion, which is a witch
belief system that enherits back from pre-christian Europes heretical
cults, such as the Carthars and the Knight Templars (branch of the
masonic lodge.)
Before parents will notice Potters influence, the son/daughter might
already have begun to fiddle with occultism, and the need to take
action becomes thus yet more urgent. If a daughter is caught in
defiling her own body, or a son is found to posses "magic-cards" or
play roleplaying games, there very well be a reason to suspect Harry
Potter reading. Ofcourse if Potter reading already is a know activity,
there is no doubt but to call an exorcist in case of these symptoms.
The child may at first deny all occult activities, but this should just
encourage parents to be that even harcher in the interrogation! It
might be the Devil that splits her tongue, and you could try seeking
advice in Malleus Maleficarum on how to put her checkmate in her own
game.
There have been several teenagegirls who have been lead astray by
Potter, but have been guided on right course by loving adults. Some
girls have slipped thrugh the fingers of unvigilant parents, who didn't
find it important to dicipline and strenghten the morals of their
children, and these girls have become goth/wicca-witch.
Sincerely,
Mr. Martin Johansen
http://www.geocities.com/martin.honore.johansen
This is an old worn out troll. Think of something current.
> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
> other non-christian activities.
If you're trying to get on staff at The Onion, you'll have actually be
funny.
<snip>
Oh Sod off! It's just a book, what's the difference between Cinderella
where a woman needs a man to rescue her! For crying out loud!
--
"Keep away from people who try to belittle your ambitions. Small people
always do that, but the really great make you feel that you, too, can become
great. "
~Mark Twain~
Froggy
It's alarming that the bible makes adults believe that Harry Potter has
the power to bewitch their children.
--
Greg G.
I stepped on one of those fortune-telling scales. It said I was
intelligent, handsome, energetic, and resourceful. It had my weight
wrong, too.
It has nothing to do with the magic; it's because Harry wears
glasses. That's why so many of his fans become occulists.
--
David Canzi | Eternal truths come and go. |
"Greg G." <ggw...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1163025429.1...@e3g2000cwe.googlegroups.com...
--
"What is the first law?"
"To Protect."
"And the second?"
"Ourselves."
Terry Austin
And learn how to spell. And how to use commas and periods.
> It has nothing to do with the magic; it's because Harry wears
> glasses. That's why so many of his fans become occulists
The person who deals with eyesight, glasses etc is an oCulist (one C)
--
www.cheesesoup.myby.co.uk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nileh1ZPGq4
Fascinating.
Let us assume the premise is correct. I said "assume" so there's no
need to start laughing yet.
Wouldn't the Harry Potter series lead one to the Western Ceremonial
Tradition, such as the Golden Dawn, instead of the more earth based
religion of Wicca? I mean, I've read the books and while obviously
fiction, they seem like there would be more sympathy there than
elsewhere.
Jason Harvestdancer
I'm allowed to misspell on purpose -- I have an artistic license.
> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
> other non-christian activities.
>
> In essence the Harry Potter universe is based upon the teachings of
> Gerald Gardner, the founder of the Wicca religion, which is a witch
> belief system that enherits back from pre-christian Europes heretical
> cults, such as the Carthars
You mean the Cathars, also known as the Albigensians, a Christian sect
declared heretical. They were Christian and didn't influence Wicca.
> and the Knight Templars (branch of the
> masonic lodge.)
Hah! The Knights Templar are non-Christian? This is funny! They were a
Christian military order founded with the mission of protecting pilgrims
to Jerusalem after it was liberated by the Crusades. The problem was
that they got too powerful, so the Church declared them heretics and
ordered them all murdered on Friday, October 13th, 1307.
> Before parents will notice Potters influence, the son/daughter might
> already have begun to fiddle with occultism, and the need to take
> action becomes thus yet more urgent. If a daughter is caught in
> defiling her own body, or a son is found to posses "magic-cards" or
> play roleplaying games, there very well be a reason to suspect Harry
> Potter reading. Ofcourse if Potter reading already is a know activity,
> there is no doubt but to call an exorcist in case of these symptoms.
Oh, come off it. D&D is a healthy storytelling activity. It teaches
imagination, creativity, team play, morals and an enjoyment of
adventure.
> The child may at first deny all occult activities, but this should just
> encourage parents to be that even harcher in the interrogation! It
> might be the Devil that splits her tongue, and you could try seeking
> advice in Malleus Maleficarum on how to put her checkmate in her own
> game.
The Malleus Maleficarum set up a self-perpetuating industry wherein
prosecutor-judge-executioners could steal people's wealth and then kill
them, all sanctioned by the Church for the Common Good.
> There have been several teenagegirls who have been lead astray by
> Potter, but have been guided on right course by loving adults. Some
> girls have slipped thrugh the fingers of unvigilant parents, who didn't
> find it important to dicipline and strenghten the morals of their
> children, and these girls have become goth/wicca-witch.
Young people turning away from the evils perpetrated by the Christian
Church, such as the burning of Albigensians (the earliest protestants;
one of their beliefs was that one did not need a priest to ensure one's
entry into heaven), the murder of thousands of faithful warrior-monks,
and the burning alive of tens of thousands of innocent women, did not
begin with the publication of the Harry Potter novels.
And if you had read them at all , you'd know that the magic life isn't
much better than the one normal kids know. Rowling's imaginary world has
a government just as shady and corrupt as the mundane one.
You're being completely silly. Instead of misunderstanding a little
harmless make-believe (I bet you're one of those idiots who thinks that
the Christian holiday of All-Hallow's Eve [followed by All Hallows' Day
and All Souls Day] is actually satanic), why don't you work on some real
problems that kids face today? For instance, work at your church to help
married couples be successful in raising families, or volunteer at a
soup kitchen. Quit believing all this silly pagan/heretic crap.
--
Timberwoof <me at timberwoof dot com> http://www.timberwoof.com
It's easy to say a war is so important your neighbor should go fight it for you.
People and institutions are most threatened by those things which are
enough like them to be competition. Politicians are threatened by rival
politicians. Actors feel threatened by other actors. Nations feel
threatened by other nations.
Christianity is threatened by a fictional fantasy intended for
children. What does that tell you?
m
If people were as easy as that to mind control, I'd rule the world by
now.
>
> ohh-ohh_...@hotmail.com wrote:
>> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
>> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
>> other non-christian activities.
>
> It's alarming that the bible makes adults believe that Harry Potter has
> the power to bewitch their children.
The Bible does no such thing. Their own innate superstition
does.
--
I'd give my right arm to be ambidextrous.
Did Malleus Maleficarum replace Harry Potter in your home?
Alot of innocent people were burnt at the stake on account of
Malleus Maleficarum. It has been used as an authority for witchcraft
trials, many of them Protestant. Contrary to popular belief, it has
never been officially adapted by the Catholic Church and has been
condemned by many Christian institutions. It is full of fraud, and
started in fraud (claiming endorsement from the Pope that didn't
exist). Ironically, it may have helped preserve some of the pagan
beliefs the authors pretend to condemn.
Both Harry Potter and Malleus Maleficarum are occult make believe.
However, most readers know that Harry Potter is fiction. Many readers
of Malleus Maleficarum actually believed it (and apparently believe it
still), and have hurt hundreds to thousands of people.
I used to be threatened by drunk homeless people yelling obscenties and
starting fights outside the mission house next door to my student digs.
BUT I had a home. Totally different.
>
> m
Gardnerian witchcraft is a 20th century fabrication. It enherits (sic)
back no earlier than 1920.
> Before parents will notice Potters influence, the son/daughter might
> already have begun to fiddle with occultism, and the need to take
> action becomes thus yet more urgent. If a daughter is caught in
> defiling her own body, or a son is found to posses "magic-cards" or
> play roleplaying games, there very well be a reason to suspect Harry
> Potter reading. Ofcourse if Potter reading already is a know activity,
> there is no doubt but to call an exorcist in case of these symptoms.
>
> The child may at first deny all occult activities, but this should just
> encourage parents to be that even harcher in the interrogation! It
> might be the Devil that splits her tongue, and you could try seeking
> advice in Malleus Maleficarum on how to put her checkmate in her own
> game.
>
> There have been several teenagegirls who have been lead astray by
> Potter, but have been guided on right course by loving adults. Some
> girls have slipped thrugh the fingers of unvigilant parents, who didn't
> find it important to dicipline and strenghten the morals of their
> children, and these girls have become goth/wicca-witch.
The horror! Next thing, they'll be worshipping skyclad. Cover
your eyes lest you go blind. Better yet, put them out with
red hot knitting needles.
Christianity doesn't have any occultism? That's amazing! I had no idea
it was secular. Funny, but I seem to recall most Christians engaging in
occult practices.... I must have imagined it.
If some nut predicts the future by reading tarot cards, that's
occultism. If fundamentalist nuts keep predicting the end of the world
on (date of your choice), they are christians in good standing.
Christian nutcases are OK, nonchristian nutcases have made a pact with
the devil. Or something like that, I guess.
When I was a kid, I knew all this blasphemy would threaten civilization
when I read "The Wizard of Oz," A "good" witch? Hey, let's throw her
in the river and see if she floats!
-- Mike Palmer
Actually, JK Rowling would :)
> And learn how to spell. And how to use commas and periods.
--
Ferrous Patella
"Her vocabulary was as bad as, like, whatever."
Annual English Teachers' awards for best student
metaphors/analogies found in actual student papers
The old classics are best.
>
--
內躬偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,
Pip R. Lagenta Pip R. Lagenta Pip R. Lagenta Pip R. Lagenta
�虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌`偕爻,虜,齯滌
-- Pip R. Lagenta
President for Life
International Organization Of People Named Pip R. Lagenta
(If your name is Pip R. Lagenta, ask about our dues!)
<http://home.comcast.net/~galentripp/pip.html>
(For Email: I'm at home, not work.)
Have you seen the number of programs on cable TV devoted to debunking
that novel by Dan Brown? By all the attention "The Da Vinci Code" has
gotten from the fundies, one might think that he has stumbled upon some
very important secrets that they have to spend a lot of effort to
suppress again.
That is a good point. I can't speak for Wicca in general, but all the
practising Wiccans I know have a fairly free-flowing
whatever-works-for-this-moment sort of philosophy; I can't imagine them
putting up with such a solid and unbreakable set of magic laws such as
the ones that govern Harry Potter's world.
I would control her through a series of well designed fan letters.
Like thinking.
RS
It is worthwhile mentioning that anyone who can get a roomful of kids to
sit quietly and pay attention to a full-length movie is doing something
right.
They were too powerful and too wealthy. Undoubtedly, they had a strong
community and probably some secrets - but nothing has ever been produced to
prove them heretics... other than a "fiat" declaration by the church. As
you mention, the declartion of "heretic" was a very effective tool for the
church in the middle ages to either remove dissentors or claim wealth.
--
-J
** Keeper of Bette Midler and Betty Buckley **
Regards,
John
> On 2006-11-08 17:37:09 -0500, "Greg G." <ggw...@gmail.com> said:
>
>>
>> ohh-ohh_...@hotmail.com wrote:
>>
>>> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
>>> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
>>> other non-christian activities.
>>
>>
>> It's alarming that the bible makes adults believe that Harry Potter has
>> the power to bewitch their children.
>
>
> The Bible does no such thing. Their own innate
Not innate - you have to be taught
superstition
> does.
>
> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
> other non-christian activities.
Why is that alarming? Surely going into occultism and non-christian
activities is far, far more moral than supporting the group which, through
a 300-year program of systematic torture and murder, eliminated most of
Europe's earlier culture and literally demonized its reputation.
> In essence the Harry Potter universe is based upon the teachings of
> Gerald Gardner, the founder of the Wicca religion, which is a witch
> belief system that enherits back from pre-christian Europes heretical
> cults, such as the Carthars and the Knight Templars (branch of the
> masonic lodge.)
Impossible. Males still dominate as teachers in the Harry Potter
universe, whereas in the Wiccan culture which scares the piss out of you,
the knowledge and wisdom was preserved mainly by old women.
(But I don't blame you for being scared. Any eighty-year-old woman could
squash you like a bug.)
--
Mark Isaak eciton (at) earthlink (dot) net
"Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of
the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are
being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and
exposing the country to danger." -- Hermann Goering
it is up to god fearing parents to save all the children form this evil
influence since any god fearing person wouldnt shoplift the books they
must buy all they can to prevent impressionable minds read them
also you should check them out at your local library and claim them
lost and pay the fine
if you do not do this you are not following your beliefs and are a
hypocrite
he he he i think i got them the religion precludes stealing them to
burn them so they have to buy them and if they don't buy them they are
not stong in their convictions and are hypocrites
>It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
>youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
>other non-christian activities.
>
>In essence the Harry Potter universe is based upon the teachings of
>Gerald Gardner, the founder of the Wicca religion, which is a witch
>belief system that enherits back from pre-christian Europes heretical
>cults, such as the Carthars and the Knight Templars (branch of the
>masonic lodge.)
>
>Before parents will notice Potters influence, the son/daughter might
>already have begun to fiddle with occultism, and the need to take
>action becomes thus yet more urgent. If a daughter is caught in
>defiling her own body, or a son is found to posses "magic-cards" or
>play roleplaying games, there very well be a reason to suspect Harry
>Potter reading. Ofcourse if Potter reading already is a know activity,
>there is no doubt but to call an exorcist in case of these symptoms.
>
>The child may at first deny all occult activities, but this should just
>encourage parents to be that even harcher in the interrogation! It
>might be the Devil that splits her tongue, and you could try seeking
>advice in Malleus Maleficarum on how to put her checkmate in her own
>game.
>
>There have been several teenagegirls who have been lead astray by
>Potter, but have been guided on right course by loving adults. Some
>girls have slipped thrugh the fingers of unvigilant parents, who didn't
>find it important to dicipline and strenghten the morals of their
>children, and these girls have become goth/wicca-witch.
>
>
>Sincerely,
>Mr. Martin Johansen
>http://www.geocities.com/martin.honore.johansen
Maybe if you bothered to read the books before making an asinine,
completely false statement as you have here you would be less ignorant
of the facts.
Not once in the Harry Potter series is Wicca - or any other religion
for that matter - mentioned at all. They DO celebrate Christian
holidays such as Christmas and Easter (not the politically-correct
'Winter holiday' and 'Spring break'). This leads us to make the
logical deduction that those in Rowling's made-up world are of the
same religious faiths as those in the real world.
If ignorance is bliss, you are truly in Nirvana.
- Chip Stobb
The man had to be the biggest pusher of witchcraft and magic ideology
in the history of mankind, Satan aside.
Maybe it's all the noise and primary colors.
...and the Cathars are thought to be derived from Arian Christianity
(converted
Goths, around 600ad) which was later supressed...fyi.
> Timberwoof wrote:
> > In article <1163023620.2...@b28g2000cwb.googlegroups.com>,
> > ohh-ohh_...@hotmail.com wrote:
> >
> > > It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
> > > youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
> > > other non-christian activities.
> > >
> > > In essence the Harry Potter universe is based upon the teachings of
> > > Gerald Gardner, the founder of the Wicca religion, which is a witch
> > > belief system that enherits back from pre-christian Europes heretical
> > > cults, such as the Carthars
> >
> > You mean the Cathars, also known as the Albigensians, a Christian sect
> > declared heretical. They were Christian and didn't influence Wicca.
>
> ...and the Cathars are thought to be derived from Arian Christianity
> (converted
> Goths, around 600ad) which was later supressed...fyi.
No, the Cathars are a development of the Bogomir form of gnosticism,
which derives from the Paulician heresy, which is a late form of the
widespread gnsoticism of the late classical era.
--
John S. Wilkins, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Biohumanities Project
University of Queensland - Blog: scienceblogs.com/evolvingthoughts
"He used... sarcasm. He knew all the tricks, dramatic irony, metaphor,
bathos, puns, parody, litotes and... satire. He was vicious."
>It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
>youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
>other non-christian activities.
<CrapSnip>
Posting the same ignorant rant 3 times doesn't make it true;
it just shows your lack of any sort of netiquette. Piss off
now...
--
Bob C.
"Evidence confirming an observation is
evidence that the observation is wrong."
- McNameless
Yeah, I believe all your claims.
--
Bobby Bryant
Reno, Nevada
Remove your hat to reply by e-mail.
> Oh, come off it. D&D is a healthy storytelling activity. It teaches
> imagination, creativity, team play, morals and an enjoyment of
> adventure.
Not to mention correct techniques for killing zombies. Useful thing to
know if our nation is ever attacked by the unquiet dead!
--
[The address listed is a spam trap. To reply, take off every zig.]
Richard Clayton
"During wars laws are silent." -- Cicero
Nothing was "preserved". The religion did not exist prior to the 1930's.
--
Please reply to: | "One of the hardest parts of my job is to
pciszek at panix dot com | connect Iraq to the War on Terror."
Autoreply is disabled | -- G. W. Bush, 9/7/2006
I dont know if I should slot this person as another moronic intolerant
or a very clever Bloomsbury shareholder!!!
What Gardner formalized is based on anthropolical studies of the
practices of the Pagani in Europe, before the RC destroyed natural
religions. The beliefs pre-date Gardner.
--
“What concerns me now is that even if you’re as brilliant as Newton, you
reach a point where you start basking in the majesty of God and then
your discovery stops — it just stops,” Dr. Tyson said. “You’re no good
anymore for advancing that frontier, waiting for somebody else to come
behind you who doesn’t have God on the brain and who says: ‘That’s a
really cool problem. I want to solve it.’
> Paul Ciszek wrote:
> > In article <pan.2006.11.10...@earthlink.net>,
> > Mark Isaak <eci...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> >> Impossible. Males still dominate as teachers in the Harry Potter
> >> universe, whereas in the Wiccan culture which scares the piss out of you,
> >> the knowledge and wisdom was preserved mainly by old women.
> >
> > Nothing was "preserved". The religion did not exist prior to the 1930's.
> >
>
> What Gardner formalized is based on anthropolical studies of the
> practices of the Pagani in Europe, before the RC destroyed natural
> religions. The beliefs pre-date Gardner.
>
And catholicism.
--
trippy
mhm31x9 Smeeter#29 WSD#30
sTaRShInE_mOOnBeAm aT HoTmAil dOt CoM
NP: "Heart And Soul" -- T'Pau
"Now, technology's getting better all the time and that's fine,
but most of the time all you need is a stick of gum, a pocketknife,
and a smile."
-- Robert Redford "Spy Game"
> It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their
> youth reading Harry Potter books, are seduced into occultism and
> other non-christian activities.
It's an alarming fact, that more and more teenagers, who spend their youth
reading the Bible, are seduced into superstition and other anti-
scientific activities.
Sigh. I've gone this route before...
Who were these pre-Christian Wiccans? Where did they live? Which
langauge family did they belong to?
I have read about several pre-Roman (more applicable than pre-Christian
in this context, I think) European cultures, and *none* of them even
*remotely* resemble Wiccans.
The Germanic tribes enjoyed fighting wars and eating meat, and had
pretty well-defined gender roles (yeah, women got to fight or even rule
occassionally, but it was notable precisely because of its rarity).
Most of the important gods in their pantheon were male. And they didn't
separate their trash for recycling.
From what little I have been able to read about the Slavic pantheon,
they were no more Wiccan than the Teutons.
The Greeks and Romans? Don't make me laugh. The Greeks gave us the
pentagram, that's about as Wiccan as they got.
Ah, but the Celts! Surely the Celts were the peaceful, matriarchal,
vegetarian culture that practiced Wicca? Nope. While women were
considerably better off in Celtic societies than in Greek or Roman
ones (that ain't saying much), men seemed to mostly hold the leadership
positions. Queens like Bodicea were the exception, not the rule.
Again, they were fond of warfare--the Irish claimed to have defeated
their *own gods* in battle, fercryinoutloud. Celtic imagery and names
are popular among Wiccans, but "THE Goddess" central to Wicca has no
counterpart in the Celtic pantheon. Many gods and goddesses, but no
"THE Goddess".
At this point in the argument, someone usually points to the Venus of
Willendorf. *That* culture predates not just Christianity, but every
historical European culture; it got pretty thoroughly anihilated by the
ancestors of the cultures I mentioned above. If anything from the
neolithic survived in secret, it had to be kept a secret throughout not
just 2000 years of Christianity, but millenia of Indo-European culture
before that. You can claim Wicca is based on pre-Indo-European cultures,
but you might as well claim that pre-Indo-European cultures voted
Republican. We know very little about them that would confirm or deny
any claim made about their beliefs. Yes, the figure of a pregnant woman
must have been important to some of these cultures, as they seem to have
carved a large number of them. But we know nothing else of the religion.
Now, proponents of oral tradition like to claim that oral traditions
preserve things for many thousands of years without distortion, but so
what? Proponents of Biblical inerrency will gladly point you to a verse
in the Bible that says that it is inerrent. Both claims are circular.
So, I repeat my question: Which culture practiced Wicca? Where did
they live and when?
"THE Goddess" is a purely a twentieth century invention. Even Marija
Gimbutus does not support the claim of a single dominant goddess, and
she's about the most Wicca-friendly anthropologist you're going to find.
Someone knows only fluffy-bunny-llewellynite-silver-ravenwolf-newage
wiccans, and not the rest of us who are actually able to pull our head
out of our ass.
Jason Harvestdancer
<snip>
that was fun
i've seen a lot of odd posts
and perhaps even written a few.
but the quadruplicate posting of this
anti-Potter soliloquy is ... something.
if only we could give them some
Veritaserum and ask them their
true motivation, instead of wasting
time guessing.
So, can you answer my question? Where and when did the pre-Christian
Wiccans live? Can they be identified with any culture or language group
known to history or archeology?
>
> In article <1166053242....@f1g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
> Harvest Dancer <harves...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>> Paul Ciszek wrote:
>>>
>>> So, I repeat my question: Which culture practiced Wicca? Where did
>>> they live and when?
>>>
>>> "THE Goddess" is a purely a twentieth century invention. Even Marija
>>> Gimbutus does not support the claim of a single dominant goddess, and
>>> she's about the most Wicca-friendly anthropologist you're going to find.
>>
>> Someone knows only fluffy-bunny-llewellynite-silver-ravenwolf-newage
>> wiccans, and not the rest of us who are actually able to pull our head
>> out of our ass.
>
> So, can you answer my question? Where and when did the pre-Christian
> Wiccans live?
They lived a long, long time ago in a galaxy that's far, far, FAR away.
> Can they be identified with any culture or language group
> known to history or archeology?
They're Jedi. _Klingon_ Jedi. Heghlu'meH QaQ jajvam. Qapla'.
--
email to oshea dot j dot j at gmail dot com.
You're right. The "Left Behind" books and video games are much more
wholesome
entertainment.
Stuart
Hmmmm.... An interesting read and confirms my opinion that religion is a
mental illness that should be treated at as young an age as possible.
Curious misquotings from the HP books though, especially as they make no
obvious difference to the points being made.
And how do these people know that green is satan's favourite colour? I
wonder if they know god's favourite colour.....
Are they the ones that greet each other with "May the Force Be Used"?
What choice do "christians" like you have? Wear a paper bag over your head?
--
Seppo P.
What's wrong with Theocracy? (a Finnish Taliban, Oct 1, 2005)
> J.J. O'Shea <try.n...@but.see.sig> wrote:
>
>> On Wed, 13 Dec 2006 20:55:20 -0500, Paul Ciszek wrote
>> (in article <elqau8$oh2$1...@reader2.panix.com>):
>>
>>>
>>> In article <1166053242....@f1g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
>>> Harvest Dancer <harves...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>>>> Paul Ciszek wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> So, I repeat my question: Which culture practiced Wicca? Where did
>>>>> they live and when?
>>>>>
>>>>> "THE Goddess" is a purely a twentieth century invention. Even Marija
>>>>> Gimbutus does not support the claim of a single dominant goddess, and
>>>>> she's about the most Wicca-friendly anthropologist you're going to find.
>>>>
>>>> Someone knows only fluffy-bunny-llewellynite-silver-ravenwolf-newage
>>>> wiccans, and not the rest of us who are actually able to pull our head
>>>> out of our ass.
>>>
>>> So, can you answer my question? Where and when did the pre-Christian
>>> Wiccans live?
>>
>> They lived a long, long time ago in a galaxy that's far, far, FAR away.
>>
>>> Can they be identified with any culture or language group
>>> known to history or archeology?
>>
>> They're Jedi. _Klingon_ Jedi. Heghlu'meH QaQ jajvam. Qapla'.
>
> Are they the ones that greet each other with "May the Force Be Used"?
>
HIja'.
Well, I chose to not participate in religion posts, but it happens that
I am Catholic and I don't think I suffer from any mental illness, you
know? I don't either go around calling names to groups just because some
participants might be nuts.
> Curious misquotings from the HP books though, especially as they make no
> obvious difference to the points being made.
--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
I've always thought Satan's colour was red. You learn everyday :)
ANd I always thought that Satan's color was Black - of course I go back
to before the days of color TV.
I simply expressed my own personal opinion and quantified it as such and
I did not call anyone names.
But be assured, I find your religion at least as offensive as you find
my opinion of it so I guess that, excepting that your religion hurts
mankind more than my derisory opinion of it ever will, makes us quits.
Still waiting for a straight answer.
Many Wiccans willing to claim that Wicca comes from some sort of
pre-Christian European society, not one who is willing to point
to that society.
Hell, can anyone even identify a single pre-Christian European
society that used "An it harm none..." as a guiding principle?
The Greeks, Romans, Slavs, Celts, Germanii, and Finns all revered
and wrote sagas about guys who were particularly good at harming
others.
I also find it unlikely that a religious belief system could survive
for long underground in a dominant Christian culture. I would expect
to see, for the few generations they *did survive, to show rapid
deviation from an earlier norm for the ethnic group. Analogous to
punctuated equilibrium for memes.
If there were any surviving remnants, I would not expect to see much
continuity from ancient dominant cultures to surviving bands or
families in near-modern times. It may be that psychological needs
sometimes encouraged a "recreation" of old beliefs in various people
and peoples thru the centuries.
As for any incompatibility with "An it harm none" with actual ancient
behavior, imagine a future culture in which Christianity has fallen out
of favor and is then revived or recreated. How close a fit could we
expect between the Golden Rule and historical records of Christian
behavior?
IIRC, there was an underground society of Jews in China , numbering a
couple of hundred, who worshipped more or less in the old ways, but
they were few in number and had no books. There were larger communities
of Jews in China that existed for centuries (e.g. Kaifeng), but they
were not officially oppressed, nor underground.
Whenever a new dynasty was established in China, underground groups
supporting the last throne invariably were established, and it seems as
tho they all degenerated into mafia-type organizations after a few
generations ("tong").
I find it unlikely that underground medieval European pagans were
keeping good records for the historians. How could we tell the
difference between a 20th century made-up new-age pseudo-pagan group,
from an older pseudo-pagan group recreated in the eighteenth century,
from an easily mutated one that did somehow maintain continuity from
the ninth century?
I would *not expect to find a large tribe or country that maintained
pre-Christian practices in the history books. That's rather an unfair
expectation, isn't it? Rather like a creationist demanding to see a *
complete* transitional fossil record, presumably one example form every
generation, and all in the same place.
>
> --
> Please reply to: | "One of the hardest parts of my job is to
> pciszek at panix dot com | connect Iraq to the War on Terror."
> Autoreply is disabled | -- G. W. Bush, 9/7/2006
Kermit
Forget the movie. Think of a room full of kids sitting quietly reading
a 400-page book!
Chris
>
> --
> Timberwoof <me at timberwoof dot com> http://www.timberwoof.com
> It's easy to say a war is so important your neighbor should go fight it for you.
But my original question was asking for something much, much simpler:
Can the Wiccan religion be identified with the religion of any pre-
Christian European society known to history or archeology?
"I don't know" would be a perfectly honest anwer to that question, but
it's not an answer I've heard so far. Of the people who've answered
various forms of "yes", not one has pointed out the culture in question.
And we don't need a large tribe to have maintained pre-Christian
practices throughout the entire Christian era. We have records of
most of the larger tribes that were in Europe at the time that the Roman
Empire, and later Christianity, homogenized the cultures. Present day
Wicca is not a secret religion. I am asking someone who is knowledgeable
about both of these topics to point out a connection and make a case for
it. To extend your fossil record analogy, identifying current species
with their distant ancestors across gaps in the fossil record is all part
of what makes paleontology so interesting.
> And we don't need a large tribe to have maintained pre-Christian
> practices throughout the entire Christian era. We have records of
> most of the larger tribes that were in Europe at the time that the Roman
> Empire, and later Christianity, homogenized the cultures. Present day
> Wicca is not a secret religion. I am asking someone who is knowledgeable
> about both of these topics to point out a connection and make a case for
> it.
They simply can't do it. They're Jedi. Klingon Jedi. Or might as well be.
Unless, of course, someone, anyone, can produce an alternative answer?
> To extend your fossil record analogy, identifying current species
> with their distant ancestors across gaps in the fossil record is all part
> of what makes paleontology so interesting.
That it is. And that's exactly why you will _never_ get your straight answer.
> Males dominate as teachers in the Harry Potter universe.
That's not true, Mark.
SIX subjects (Arithmancy, Astronomy, Divination, Herbology,
Quidditch, and Transfiguration) are taught by females.
Only THREE subjects (Charms, History of Magic, and Potions)
are taught exclusively by males.
Blon Fel Fotch Passameer-Day Slitheen
--
Free Margaret Blaine now!
system21 u568567
Check out his game
<br><a href=http://gc.gamestotal.com/>Galactic Conquest</a>