Hi Sharon,
A well written replay and spoke with your head
and heart and thanks Sharon.
We agree on some things and disagree with
others, so let me comment on your comments with the preface Marvin as
we scroll won.
>
> > However, I am old fashioned guy and think that a old
> > fashioned show business tradition of meeting the audience to say thank
> > you after a show is a courtesy that is to be upheld.
>
> I disagree to an extent. The ONLY thing the artist owes anyone is a
> good show - meeting fans afterward is a bonus not afforded to many.
> And there are several who don't meet fans after shows - Peter Noone,
> The Bacon Brothers, David Foster, Chris Botti are some that have done
> recent shows I've attended that had no meet and greet afterwards.
Marvin: I know Sinatra and others said that an artist owes nothing
to anyone but a good show, but that is an outdated statement and in an
internet age, where public relations and courtesy is always important,
an artist has to do all he/she can to get sell outs and their careers
going. If all the artists you mentioned go out of their way to avoid
doing meet and greets, they will have short careers.
>
> > It is terribly bad etiquette and insulting that a performer has to charge money to
> > talk with the audience for getting feedback after the show.
>
> Okay - lets look at this from a different perspective. Say Barry
> plays a huge arena -- there's going to be any number of people that
> would love to go back and say hello. Friends, family, record
> executives, PR folks, journalists. Then fans ... there's no way that
> he would be willing to meet that many people so the platinums allow
> him to meet a specific number of fans and everyone (for the most part)
> is happy. Am I happy that as a 30+ year fan (yep, I'm old) I have to
> "pay" to meet a celebrity I admire? No. Will I do it? Probably as it
> looks like lightning isn't going to strike and I'll have an
> opportunity to say hello outside of a show. But - you never know.
> I'm perpetually hopeful.
Marvin: Your points are valid Sharon. To be fair, Barry and
his staff make the platinums personable and memorable and it is
impossible for Barry to meet his audience, as his audience is bigger
than most performers. I just wish there was another way to meet fans
without it costing a high amount of money.
>
> (snip to)
>
> > You and I are both fans of Michael Feinstein and know that
> > Michael is always gracious after shows and will do autograph signings
> > and talk with his audience as a courtesy to them without a fee.. If
> > you talk with Michael Feinstein about Gershwin, he will have a long
> > conversation with you.
>
> I am invited backstag because I am a paying member of his fan club,
> and it's a courtesy that is given to the members of the club.
> Additionally, I make sure to send a thank you to his staff ... and I
> give them whatever photos I take. I'm sure if it got overwhelming
> that perk would go away. I am always thrilled to meet Michael, and he
> is both gracious and charming. As he says, he wouldn't be anywhere
> without us so he thanks US for coming! But -- I have supported his
> career for years! [Side story - I went to see him in San Diego and
> just as I got to the window the "Sold Out" sign was posted. I waited
> a bit and someone from the box office came out and handed me a 4th row
> seat - champagne seating no less - compliments of Mr. Feinstein". ] I
> finally got to thank him (in person) for that ticket and even 'tho the
> ticket was comped, I made sure to purhcase the value of the ticket in
> Symphony Swag so I "paid it forward".
Marvin: Thanks for sharing this story with us- and what a classy
guy Michael Feinstein and his staff is for giving you the ticket when
the venue could have easily turned you away.
>
> > Over the years of writing on and attending cultural arts
> > events, I met Marvin Hamlisch, Melissa Manchester, Lorna Luft, Joan
> > Rivers, Jackie Mason, Helen Hunt, the stars of "Jersey Boys", stars of
> > the NYC Ballet, Joshua Bell, Neil Sedaka, Frankie Avalon, Idina
> > Menzel, Linda Eder, etc. after shows and it wasn't only because I
> > write on the performers and hearing from them personally how much they
> > liked my articles..
>
> That is wonderful for you -- however, would you have gone to the same
> shows if you weren't going as a journalist? Do you support their
> careers other than just writing about them in purchasing CD's, or
> supporting any of their causes?
Marvin: I pay to see shows of performers that I am not writing
about, such as Linda Eder.
I support breast cancer and ovarian cancer organizations- Barbra
and Melissa's causes- but less because of the celebrity endorsements
and more because my relatives died from breast and ovarian cancers.
>
> The artists were also gracious to meet with
>
> > audience members as well for no fee for so many years.
>
> That trend seems to be fading. I wish it wasn't, but it seems like
> artists just don't have the time as they are rushing from one place to
> another.
Marvin: Artists should never take their fans for granted and stop
the meet and greets, or they will have short careers.Let them make the
time for the meet and greets.
>
> > So why should I pay to meet Barbra, Barry at shows when there are so many artists that would not think of charging money to meet fans? Marvin
>
> I guess again, there's a couple different ways to look at this --
> obviously, you have received some sort of compensaton for your
> articles, or you wouldn't write them. If the performers weren't
> performing, you wouldn't have anything to write about.
>
> If you're such a great fan of Barbra, and she's allowed you to make
> money from her career - why not save up the the bucks and meet her? I
> don't make any money from Manilow -- I don't write stories or books
> about him that would afford me any kind of compensation. But if I
> did ... and I received items free for doing it, I would probably find
> some way to give something back.
Marvin: I apologize if this sounds elitist, but I am doing the
artists a favor by writing on them to publicize their shows so readers
would know more about them. My editors and I are not obligated to give
free publicity to the artists. The artists benefit from my articles as
I do by seeing them perform. Many of the publicists that work for the
artists always invite me to their shows and to talk with the artists
because they need the publicity and it is all part of my business and
their business. There is never any shortage of topics for me to write
about, but I love writing on the cultural arts and most of the
performers I write about, so it is a win-win situation for both me and
the artists. It is an honor to have written the articles and getting
feedback from the artists about the articles..About saving enough
money to say hello to Barbra- well I don't charge Barbra or any other
artist to write on them, so why should they charge me or any other
audience member to meet with them?
>
> Just my humble 2 cents with too much caffiene this morning. :-)
>
> (DC) Sharon
I love your 2 cents and your words are worth a lot more. Marvin