As you stated, our god Science, knows VERY LITTLE about the human
mind. Less about how it interacts with the universe through the
sense organs and even LESS about how this interaction is
affected by the sleep state.
From an ancient (read eastern) perspective, we are not seperate from the
universe.
It penetrates and informs us. Our seperatness is only an illusion.
Your emphatic insistance that 'it's ONLY a dream' albiet a
'realistic' lucid dream is misguided. This mental state is a
highly evolved and complex dilema spiritually speaking.
Since we are part of the Universe and not seperate, the lucid
state offers insight into this fact. It hammers home this
truth. The level of control one has over what one perceives
does not prove anything. We have a great degree of control over our
environments while awake and look how screwed up we are.
This is new territory. Language has difficulty encapsulating
the depth of feeling these experiences evoke. Your eagerness to
dismiss anyone who uses metaphysical terminology shows your
own close-mindedness and limited understanding of this miraculous
phenomena.
> :::snip::: The power of the human brain has
>only been touched upon by science, we should not underestimate
>it ( and that includes the possible explanation of some
>paranormal phenomena - telepathy between twins, knowing the
>phone is going to ring before it does, sensing someone is
>watching you without seeing them etc. etc.) but neither should
>we attribute phenomena produced by it as being the work of some
>bullshit mumbo jumbo astral force which transcends you to some
>alternative astral plane crap.
>It's a dream. You have control. The very fact that you do have
>control should tell you that is a product of your own brain.
>Stay lucid,
>Gareth
While some may choose to flame your choice of words, I think your
point is one that can't be emphasized strongly enough. Lucid dreaming
is a wonderful--and useful--facility of the human mind. Surely the
facts of LD are amazing enough; do we really need to drag in all the
New Age (God, that term makes me cringe) stuff? It's nice to hear from
a lucid dreamer who's...lucid. Good post. I enjoyed reading it. =^)
___ _______ _ __ ___
/ __|_ / _ \ '__/ _ \ | "Connections were broken | czero
| (__ / / __/ | | (_) | | as a child might snap | @
\___/___\___|_| \___/ | the wings from flies." | cris.com
I agree with both your post, and the orginal one--well
said, on your part, a most balanced reply. We needed both the
injection of healthy, optimistic skepticism, and the more moderate
and delicately crafted reply--good points from the orginal poster
and you.
>not some mythical astral force. The power of the human brain has
>only been touched upon by science, we should not underestimate
>it ( and that includes the possible explanation of some
>paranormal phenomena - telepathy between twins, knowing the
>phone is going to ring before it does, sensing someone is
>watching you without seeing them etc. etc.) but neither should
>we attribute phenomena produced by it as being the work of some
>bullshit mumbo jumbo astral force which transcends you to some
>alternative astral plane crap.
>It's a dream. You have control. The very fact that you do have
>control should tell you that is a product of your own brain.
>Stay lucid,
>Gareth
Hi Gareth,
My experiences with lucid dreams have had much in common with some of
the points you raise, (total recall as is the dream were a waking
experience). My dreams (non lucid) also have many points in common
with you ( very real , technicolour, most senses and some control).
However I have to disagree with your OBE theories.
I think your argument is really sound , and my MIND tends to agree
with your logic, I could go along with you except for the following:-
I had a obe once after being hit by a car and I feel it is unlike any
lucid dream I have ever had. You havent (yet) addressed the things one
sees whilst OBE (such as hospital equipment connected to you while
unconscious etc), I find it difficult to come up with a purely "lucid"
explanation for this.
Now I can't prove anything, this is all just mho but I think you
should keep an open mind on the subject, cause unless one has a
complete blueprint to the human being on hand,......we cant really be
sure what is and what is not ?
You also seem quite emotive about it ? (astral crap etc), I wonder
why. Do you believe that the mind is the soul participant in our lives
(pun intended :-) ?
Just my humble thoughts on the matter
Terry
--------------- Perth Western Australia ----------------------
Via Free Agent, offline news reader
Its BRILLIANT and free! check it out.