I don't know. That's kind of confusing.
What the saying "no sailor controls the sea" means in the context
of lucid dreaming is that since the unconscious aspects of one's
mind are still in play even in "fully lucid" dreaming, it's not
possible to totally control *every* aspect of dreaming. You can
often make "general suggestions" re: the overall dreaming scene,
but there will always be unexpected aspects of the scene anyway.
You can intentionally "materialize" specific objects, people
or things within a dreaming scene, as long as you don't try
to control every minute detail of those items, or every detail
of the general scene itself.
You can to a large extent control your own actions in and
reactions to the dream scene. And you can partially control
certain aspects of the dream scene and elements within it.
But there will always be aspects of a dreaming scene that are...
unpredictable, and often surprising - sometimes things
you couldn't even imagine you could possibly imagine.
Those elements are supplied by the unconscious.
In my opinion, one of the most fun things to do in lucid
dreaming is to NOT be very controlling of dream scenes
or items, so as to let the unconscious have full reign,
or to even encourage it to further manifest. That tends
to bring up all kinds of interesting situations.
How to 'encourage it'? Other than just letting scenes
present as they will without controlling anything,
you can ask "open ended questions" (you're not really
asking anyone or anything in particular - you're asking
your own unconscious, which will act kind of like an
internal Ouija board.) Example: "show me something that
I really need to see right now." And then just watch
and see what unfolds. What you have control over when
fully lucid is the sharpness of your self-awareness,
observational powers, command over your own actions
and choice of exactly what your attention focuses on.
Another example: intentionally change the dreaming scene
WITHOUT holding in mind anything about what it is to be.
Again be aware and observant regarding whatever unfolds.
My experience is that I always gets just as much or
more from the unconscious aspects of dreaming as I
do from my conscious mind. I think this is even true
in fully lucid dreaming. It is obviously the case in
ordinary dreaming.
In ordinary dreaming, 'the sailor' isn't consciously
steering the boat at all. In fully lucid dreaming,
'the sailor' has quite a bit of control over his/her
'boat in relation to the sea', and sometimes even
a bit of control over the state of the sea itself
(the general nature of the dream scene), but not
ever complete control over the complete scene.
The sailor can control his/her own self-awareness,
mental presence, choice over personal actions and
what is attended to in the moment, and can even
create or project general suggestions related to
the content of dream imagery (the boat in relation
to the sea). Everything else is supplied or filled
in by the unconscious, which is 'the deep sea'.
In my opinion, Slider, you focus heavily on your
conscious mind and moment-to-moment awareness.
Thus, you control dreaming scenes to a much greater
extent than I usually prefer to do. My opinion is
that it's more interesting to give the unconscious
mind greater leeway and be more quizzical toward its
capacity for manifesting the unexpected.
When I was a CC true believer, I believed that
a significant aspect of the unconscious mind was
what CC called "the spirit". Now I don't think that
was a warranted interpretation or conclusion, and I
think it merely manifested that way in my dreaming
in accord with my strong beliefs in Castaneda at
that time.
Carl Jung believed in a "collective unconscious" -
I think mainly just because he couldn't imagine
how a merely personal unconscious could be so vast
and surprising and deep. I think he was wrong,
and that the personal unconscious IS vast and
surprising and deep. I do not think there's any
evidence at all of a "collective unconscious"
or of "the spirit".
Now there are genetic components that probably
contribute to the unconscious and the instincts
which probably carry all kinds of information
from previous generations of life on earth,
but again, this does *not* magically comprise
a collective repository of all human unconscious
minds on earth. I don't really know what all
the unconscious consists of, of course, but I'm
pretty sure it isn't that.
I understand why Jung thought so, because the
unconscious mind is indeed vast and impressive.
There may even be aspects of it that ARE shared
by large numbers of people (traits passed down
to groups of people who have common ancestors).
Clearly the general brain mechanisms generating
mammalian dreaming ARE shared between people.
It's just not the "collective mental imagery"
of all human "souls". It's not that. Or at least,
there's little evidence that it is, and to me
it doesn't seem at all likely.
But each person's personal unconscious is vital.
Neurology discovers more about it every day.
And as you inhabit the virtual reality of your own
personal creation that is dreaming, what could
possibly be more influential than your own current
personal belief system, and your own expectations -
i.e your wishes, fantasies, fears, and memories?
This is the stuff that dreams are made of.
Why would you not expect your dreams to conform to
your deepest beliefs, wishes, fantasies, and fears?
You should. It would be weird if they didn't. But...
to whatever degree they DON'T, that's the unconscious. :)
So WHY do people still just LOVE to believe that
in their dreams they might be able to talk to
angels or Gods or dead relatives, or see the future,
or psychically intuit the lottery numbers or something?
The real opportunity in dreaming is not to connect
with other minds, see the future, divine information
from afar, or travel to other worlds. It's not clear
that any of those things are even possible. The real
opportunity in dreaming is to gain a deeper knowledge
of everything you are. You can also use lucid dreaming
to practice anything you might want to do or be,
live out your wishes and fantasies, or confront
any of your fears. Or just use it for fun.
When you meet other 'people' in dreaming, they
are only the internal representation of themselves
in your mind. If you then ask, "why do they seem
to have volition of their own?" Ask yourself next,
doesn't your *expectation* of a person always INCLUDE
the ability to act with a mind of his/her own?
Of course it does. Your unconscious know that too.
If your EXPECTATION within dreaming somehow becomes -
instead of that natural one - the altered one that
"dream people have no volition of their own" it is
possible that dream people will start to appear bland
and without desires and incapable of surprising you.
However, it's equally possible that even if you do
start to expect that, your unconscious will STILL
provide the people in your dreams with what appears
to be volition, because unconsciously you are still
totally USED to people having volition, and used
to people sometimes acting utterly contrary to you.
Thus, notice that it's entirely possible even in
*fully lucid dreaming* for there to be a *conflict*
between the conscious expectations and unconscious
facets of your mind.
That fact makes dreaming ever-unpredictable.
And that's one reason "no sailor controls the sea".
In dreaming you're never going anywhere outside
yourself. There's no reason to believe there will
ever be any way to do that. Your dreams are created
by mechanisms internal to your own being. Just like
a possum's dreams are. Just like a cat's dreams are.
Would you suppose you could 'connect' with 'the soul'
of a mouse in lucid dreaming? Or perhaps to the
"collective unconscious" of all mice everywhere??
No? *Why* would a human be any different?
Similarly, there's no 'essence' or 'soul' that can
leave and go outside your body when you die.
You just die. The same as any worm or any ant or
any mouse dies. It's almost certainly that simple.
Do you suppose there's a cosmic "akashic records"
keeping track of the content and doings of trillions
of 'souls' of all monkeys, mice, sea slugs, bacteria,
minnows, jackals, pigs, spiders, etc.? Really??
Probably not, huh?
Why would humans be any different?
Our DNA isn't all that different...
Humans just love to believe in magical nonsense.
We LOVE it. It's one of the main things we do
with our over-sized brains. And we should stop.