On Tuesday, January 3, 2023 at 2:17:34 AM UTC-7, Mike S Goodmann wrote:
> I concur completely with your last sentence. I find it outrageous that the cave had to be sealed in concrete because a hotshot med. student couldn't read the cave map correctly!
Having been in the cave once I can see how somehow who doesn't understand, recognize, or doesn't have a chaperone to explain the scale of the map, if they had one, against the actual size of the cave. A huge amount of the cave is full of squeezes and chambers that even short/thin amateurs would have had trouble in, so I would otherwise understand someone getting a bit confused where they may be at. This guy was at 15 stone, 6'1" tall. Then the local and then even national media sensationalized it into a ticking time bomb story, which it ultimately was
The cave was on SITLA land, which those guys can't be bothered to manage anything, and they had already had rescues in the past with it with some boy scout troops. Factor in the Utah culture and angle of the family and they had a cement mixer up there practically the next day and capping the mountain with a bronze memorial
It's odd to me that they wouldn't let things settle then go in later for recovery, but they dynamited the system of tubes he was in. A lot of families would want something different I would think. It was also odd to me the wife (while pregnant when it happened) went on to marry another guy not long later (big Utah thinking cap)