Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

HELP? Girlfriend off deep end!!

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Tim Scott

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 7:48:33 PM3/2/03
to
Sorry to bother you folks, but my girlfriend is driving me crazy with a
remodeling project SHE is handling. She has remodeled the inside of a small
house in Tennessee with fair success. The exterior of the house had asbestos
siding over the original 1x8 wood siding. She had it removed and found a few
rotten pieces of wood siding. Her original plan was to have vinyl siding
installed. Her building inspector told her vinyl sucked and she should
restore to wood siding. Her budget doesn't allow for complete removal and
installation of new wood siding and the original siding has been painted
many times and looks like crap. Someone else suggested hardy plank as if she
didn't have enough to think about. whew! Anyway she is easily persuaded and
I believe she should have stuck with the original plan of vinyl. Does anyone
here know what the most economical solution would be that will give the
house a decent look? Or have any suggestions at all?

Sorry for all that babbling, I had to tell someone.


Thanks
Tim


Mac whiter

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 8:05:56 PM3/2/03
to
Hey Tim,

We have an old place in NY state that has thre original wood siding. Although
it can take some time, it's not too hard to replace the rotted stuff, scrape,
prime, and paint. It comes out looking pretty decent actually. Of course, it
all depends on what you have to start out with, but it's true, vinyl can screw
up a historic place, and it doesn't last that long either.

Dave

deborah barrie

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 8:05:13 PM3/2/03
to
While this event is over it could be why wood was suggested.
Deborah
International Green Building Conference and Exposition Attendees
ARE CORDIALLY INVITED TO MEET THE DIRECTOR OF THE AWARD WINNING DOCUMENTARY
BLUE VINYL AT A SPECIAL RECEPTION THAT WILL RECOGNIZE 4 LEADERS
IN THE GREEN BUILDING MOVEMENT
AT THE ALAMO DRAFTHOUSE ON WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 13
Reception Begins at 6PM, BLUE VINYL SCREENING AT 7:30PM
(409 COLORADO STREET, BET 4TH AND 5TH, SHORT WALK FROM THE CONFERENCE)


Co-produced with Julia D. Parker

THE HEALTHY BUILDING NETWORK & WORKING FILMS &
CENTER FOR MAXIMUM POTENTIAL BUILDING SYSTEMS
PRESENT
LEADERSHIP AWARDS
TO
AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR HEALTHCARE ENGINEERING, ENVIRONMENTAL BUILDING NEWS,
KAISER PERMANENTE, NYS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION
These organizations and corporations have led the green building movement with
actions that have accelerated the transition to building materials that reduce
health and environmental hazards throughout their lifecycle.
Co-Hosts
Judith Helfand (co-director, co-producer BLUE VINYL), Gail D.A. Vittori (Center
for Maximum Potential Building Systems) & Bill Walsh (Director of Healthy
Building Network)

"THE GREEN BUILDING MOVEMENT MAY HAVE JUST ACQUIRED IT FIRST CULT FILM"
-- Environmental Building News
**2002 “Nice Modernists” Award to BLUE VINYL: DWELL MAGAZINE**

Who knew toxics, vinyl, persistent organic pollution, corporate deceit and
denial, sustainability and "green" building could be such fun?
With humor, chutzpah and a piece of vinyl siding in hand, Daniel Gold & Judith
Helfand's award-winning Blue Vinyl picks up where Helfand's Peabody
award-winning film A Healthy Baby Girl left off – in search of the truth about
vinyl, America’s most popular plastic. Helfand's parents’ decision to “re-side”
their house with this seemingly benign cure-all for many suburban homes turns
into a toxic odyssey with twists and turns that most ordinary homeowners would
never dare to take. A detective story, an eco-activism doc and a rollicking
comedy all rolled into one --- it’s a journey you can’t afford to miss.

"If you think studying the dangers inherent in the manufacture and disposal of
polyvinyl chloride is about as dull as watching paint dry, then you obviously
haven't seen the entertaining and personally fashioned Blue Vinyl"
The Austin Chronicle

2002 Sundance Film Festival
**Excellence in Cinematography Award **

**2002 Environmental Messenger of the Year Award**
Environmental Grantmakers Association

"Scary and hilarious!"
Elvis Mitchell, New York Times

** Best Documentary: Bermuda International Film Festival **
** Audience Award: Philadelphia Festival of World Cinema **
**Audience Award: Santa Cruz International Film Festival**

"That rare muckraking film with a sense of humor."
Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles Times

"Frightening and funny! Blue Vinyl has left audiences lingering in the hallways
for hours to debate and question."
Sharon Waxman, Washington Post

For information about the consumer and education campaign, go to:
www.myhouseisyourhouse.org
For more information about the film, go to: www.bluevinyl.org

Working Films ? 602 South Fifth ? Wilmington NC 28401 ? 910 342 9000 ?
in...@workingfilms.org

Eric Lee Green

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 8:21:39 PM3/2/03
to
In article <20030302200556...@mb-fb.aol.com>, Mac whiter ruminated:

If she wants to replace the original wood siding with something more
durable, the Hardi-plank (a cementous plank siding) doesn't look bad,
and is far more durable than wood. Does require re-painting, just like
the wood, and isn't cheap, so probably repairing the original wood is
better unless it is totally rotted.

Vinyl siding on older homes in cold climates built before modern vapor
barriers were invented can be a nightmare, because it traps moisture.
This can cause the insulation to become soaked and cause mold problems
and etc. within the walls.

--
Eric Lee Green GnuPG public key at http://badtux.org/eric/eric.gpg
mailto:er...@badtux.org Web: http://www.badtux.org


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 80,000 Newsgroups - 16 Different Servers! =-----

Chuck

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 8:57:12 PM3/2/03
to
Tell her to go with a good quality vinyl siding. I have lived in homes with
vinyl siding, aluminum siding, and cedar shake siding. I was by far the
happiest with the vinyl. It is so easy to care for- just hose it off once in
a while.

Cheap vinyl siding looks like crap, but the good quality stuff really looks
pretty good.

PS- vinyl siding does NOT trap moisture and make the insulation wet. All
vinyl siding is made with weep holes to prevent this from happening.

"Tim Scott" <tim....@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:Qbmcnembze_...@comcast.com...

Paul Fritz

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 9:09:52 PM3/2/03
to

"Tim Scott" <tim....@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:Qbmcnembze_...@comcast.com...

Depends on the siding.......beveled cedar is easy to find and easy to
replace and will last a long time.....regarding the orginal
siding......check out a product called peel-away.......it beats scraping.

>


JsWalker LazenbyJr

unread,
Mar 2, 2003, 9:28:32 PM3/2/03
to
Stick with the vinyl . . . BUT, stick with a better vinyl
siding, not the cheap stuff usually sold by street vendors
and home improvement "retailers."
Also, don't resort to the J-channel surrounding the existing
wood trim. Better vinyl manufacturers have matching vinyl
for trim. Use that.
Jim

"Tim Scott" <tim....@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:Qbmcnembze_...@comcast.com...

Jimmy Galvin

unread,
Mar 3, 2003, 7:26:12 AM3/3/03
to
Get a price from a painting contactor to replace the wood (probably subbed
out) and restore the house to an acceptable level. If the numbers work ask
to see a job he has done. If not go with a good vinyl product.

"Tim Scott" <tim....@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:Qbmcnembze_...@comcast.com...
0 new messages