From: S. Elizabeth Bird, *For Enquiring Minds: A Cultural Study of
Supermarket
Tabloids*, Knoxville: U. Tennessee Press, 1992, pp. 175-6, 178.
Perhaps the most striking theme is the "Kennedy-Is-Alive" story. This
legend still circulates orally and was first documented in the
folklore
literature in the late 1960s. De Caro and Oring (1969) document tales
collected from oral tradition that describe Kennedy as alive in a
"vegetable-like state" in Athens, and the marriage of Jacqueline
Kennedy
to Aristotle Onassis as a carefully arranged fake, with sources often
offering psychic Jeane Dixon as authority for the story. Rosenberg
(1976)
gives oral variants in which Kennedy is in Parkland Hospital in Dallas
or
at Camp David.
Rosenberg also discusses the circulation of the story, attributed to
Truman Capote, in the Milwaukee *Metro-News* and the *National
Informer*,
a now-defunct Chicago-based tabloid, again including an explanation
for
Jacqueline Kennedy's marriage. Baker (1976) offers a variant reported
in
the *National Tattler* in 1971--Kennedy on a Greek island owned by
Onassis. His widow is supposed to have married Onassis only so that
she
can visit the island without suspicion. The story also appeared in
1971 in
the Montreal-based tabloid *Midnight* (which later became the
*Globe*). In
this story (Oct. 18, 1971, pp. 14-15), the island is identified as
Skorpios. The elaborate story includes photographs supposedly taken by
a
British tourist, and quotes "six unshakable eyewitnesses." The
"witnesses"
reported that Kennedy was "helpless like a baby. His body was wasted
away." In addition, "The entire back of his head was a scarred mass.
It
had been operated on several times. There was a metal plate under the
skin
to protect the brain where the bone was broken away." According to a
former staff member of that publication, the story and photographs
were
fabricated and staged and were prompted by the widely known legends
circulating orally at the time (interview with Mary Perpich, Aug. 6,
1985). In another issue (Aug. 30, 1971, 10-12), *Midnight* claimed
that
the story had recently appeared in the British *Sunday Express*, the
Italian *Oggi*, and the Belgian *Zondag Nieuws*.
A 1980s version provided a best-selling cover story for the *National
Examiner* (July 26, 1983). In this variant, Kennedy is being kept
closely
guarded at a retreat in the Swiss Alps. He has regained some of his
mental
functions, and on good days he has the abilities of an
eleven-year-old.
The story is reminiscent both of urban legends and of mainstream news
accounts in its attention to detail and insistence on attribution to
reliable sources. In this case the authority is a Swedish psychic,
Sven
Petersen, "who contributes to para-psychology newsletters around the
world
and is especially respected for his experiments in communication with
the
dead." Throughout the story his expertise is stressed in such language
as:
"a reputation as one of the world's most skilled mediums," "a
considerable
reputation for accuracy and veracity." The story also quotes a Dr.
Chandra
Singh, "a political scientist at the University of Calcutta," who
maintains that these circumstances would explain the many
discrepancies in
accounts of what happened to Kennedy after the shooting. In this
version,
it is pointed out that Jacqueline Kennedy was not party to the secret,
a
point that indicates the way she has been gradually cut out of the
picture
over the years as the image of JFK himself has assumed prominence.
Most recently, the *Weekly World News* resurrected the story yet again
(Aug. 21, 1990). The paper's source is a letter purported to have been
written by a Polish neurosurgeon who has been attending Kennedy in a
secret convalescence center in Poland. After the shooting, Kennedy was
apparently spirited away to Poland to prevent a second attempt on his
life, and a wax likeness was buried at Arlington National Cemetery.
"At
least 16 politicians and businessmen as well as the CIA were in on the
deception" (p. 46). In keeping with the gradual improvement in
Kennedy's
health seen in the tales over the years, JFK, although paralyzed, is
lucid, and has been advising American presidents in times of crisis.
The
paper's cover shows an artist's impression of Kennedy as he appears
today,
and the story offers final "proof" of its veracity with a quote from
Dr.
Andy Reiss, a "Los Angeles-based psychic and metaphysician," who
states:
"It may be more than a coincidence that he recently appeared to me in
a
vision, giving me the feeling that he is still here with us--and very
much
alive" (p. 46). Once again, the role of Jacqueline Kennedy in all this
does not merit a mention.
Apparently encouraged by the success of this story, the *News* returns
to
the theme a few months later with a cover proclaiming: "JFK
photographed
in secret hideout!" (Nov. 6, 1990). The paper then launches into a
retelling of the "Kennedy on Skorpios" variant, explaining that the
photographs "originally appeared in a major news magazine" (p. 2). The
news magazine in question is the 1971 issue of *Midnight* referred to
above; photographs, sources, and quotes are identical. The *News* ties
the
tale to its August version, explaining that, after his sojourn on
Skorpios, JFK was taken to Poland, and later to parts unknown. In a
final
flourish, the *News* prints a photograph of a check for $1 million,
which
it is offering to any reader who can verify the present whereabouts of
the
president.
Baker, Ronald L. 1976. "The Influence of Mass Culture on Modern
Legends."
Southern Folklore Quarterly 40:367-76.
De Caro, F.A., and E. Oring. 1969. "J.F.K. Is Alive: A Modern Legend."
Folklore Forum 2 (2):54-55.
Rosenberg, B.A. 1976. "Kennedy in Camelot: The Arthurian Legend in
America." Western Folklore 25 (1):52-59.
All spawned rumors as to their survival.
Not that any person on such a list illustrates the veracity or absurdity
of the others, but it does seem to be a common thought of many people with
respect to larger-than-life figures.
Ken West
Gary Buell wrote:
> If anyone has any info or copies of old tabloids on this I would love
> to hear from you.
>
>
> From: S. Elizabeth Bird, *For Enquiring Minds: A Cultural Study of
> Supermarket
> Tabloids*, Knoxville: U. Tennessee Press, 1992, pp. 175-6, 178.
>
> Perhaps the most striking theme is the "Kennedy-Is-Alive" story. This
> legend still circulates orally and was first documented in the
> folklore
> literature in the late 1960s. De Caro and Oring (1969) document tales
> collected from oral tradition that describe Kennedy as alive in a
> "vegetable-like state" in Athens, and the marriage of Jacqueline
> Kennedy
> to Aristotle Onassis as a carefully arranged fake, with sources often
> offering psychic Jeane Dixon as authority for the story. Rosenberg
> (1976)
> gives oral variants in which Kennedy is in Parkland Hospital in Dallas
> or
> at Camp David.
>
. . . snip ,. . .
Staff Sgt Ed White...our NCOIC asked the good Dr. his impression of the
possibility of JFK being alive.
The Col. replied "The last time I saw him he was dead".....at that time I
had no idea who Col Finck was.
That was the first time I encountered Col. Finck........I did one more
processing job for him. He would not discuss anything in relationship to
JFK.
jko
Ken West <kenw...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3FAAD779...@hotmail.com...