One for Snipe, this: crosspost u.r.g/
a.2.e.s.b.t.2t.lt.cl
Carer brought the shopping home: I'd got shallots on the list and my
first reaction to the bag of bulbs was: "They're pickling On!ons, not
shallots!
On!on-shaped to a 't' - round and dumpy, they were On!on-shaped, not the
long, sometimes slightly curved clumped pointy things *I* call 'shallots'.
But, from Wicked Pædia:
"The shallot is a botanical variety (a cultivar) of the onion. Until
2010, the (French red) shallot was classified as a separate species,
Allium ascalonicum. The taxon was synonymized with Allium cepa (the
common onion) in 2010, as the difference was too small to justify a
separate species.
As part of the onion genus Allium, its close relatives include garlic,
scallions, leeks, chives, and the Chinese onion."
To me, the shallot has a distinctive growth-pattern reminiscent of
garlic bulbs, without the sheath of dead outside layers which embrace
'El Spanielbreath'.
Show me a plot of those and I think "Shallots" not "Onions".
I don't know the criteria for separating species, but IMO the French
Shallot is sufficiently different in shape, growth pattern, flavour and
appearance to justify separation from Allium cepa.
Puts me in mind of the taxonomical stir in the classification of many
fungi - they seem to leap not only in specific name but often from genus
to genus - qv Rhodocybe gemina...
Does the team think some taxonomists are trying to make a name for
themselves? The field of mycology is littered with specific names
attended by asides indicating the 'authority' of the namer.
Comments solicited.
--
Rusty Hinge
To err is human. To really foul things up requires a computer and the BOFH.