WHY WOULD READ: P CHIDAMBARAM PROTECT ADVOCATE SAURABH SOPARKAR IN GTB ?? ......

[MODY]

BOTH P CHIDAMBARAM AND SAURABH SOPARKAR APPEARED AS COLLEAGUES IN
GUJARAT HIGH COURT AND HENCE CHIDAMBARAM WOULD PROTECT MR. SAURABH
SOPARKAR AT ANY COST AND THEREFORE HE WOULD NOT BE PROBING THE MATTER
INSPITE OF PRESIDENTIAL INSTRUCTIONS WAY BACK IN SPETEMBER 2004.

FOLLOWING IS THE INTERNET LINK DESCRIBING THE CASE MATTER .

http://gujarathighcourt.nic.in/Judgement/TAXAPPEALNo273of2002.htm

--------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
MR.MIHIR JOSHI, MR.PRANAV G.DESAI MR. TANVISH U. BHATT
ADVOCATES - in all the appeals for the Revenue
MR. P.CHIDAMBARAM, SR.ADVOCATE WITH
MR.S.N.SOPARKAR, SR. ADVOCATE FOR MRS SWATI SOPARKAR,
ADVOCATE, MR.K.H.KAZI, MR. K.C.PATEL, SR. ADVOCATE,
MR.R.K.PATEL, MR.BHARGAV KARIA, MR. M.K. PATEL,
MR. MANISH KAJI, MR.TUSHAR HEMANI Advocates -
in respective appeals for the assessees
MR.J.P.SHAH, Advocate, as intervener.
--------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : MR.JUSTICE R.K.ABICHANDANI
and
MR.JUSTICE A.L.DAVE
Date of decision: 20/03/2003

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
TAX APPEAL No 273 of 2002
with
TAX APPEALS NOS. 285, 286, 299 and 348 of 2002
with
TAX APPEALS NOS. 374, 375, 376, 377, 381 & 382 of 2002
with
TAX APPEALS NOS. 383, 384, 385, 359, 360 & 362 OF 2002
with
TAX APPEALS NOS. 128, 129, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199, 257,
258, 259, 300, 361, 380 of 2002
with
TAX APPEALS NOS. 22 and 23 of 2003

For Approval and Signature:
Hon'ble MR.JUSTICE R.K.ABICHANDANI
and
Hon'ble MR.JUSTICE A.L.DAVE

--------------------------------------------------------------
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (Appellant in all Appeals)
Versus
VIJAY SHIP BREAKING CORPN (Respondent in Tax Appeal
No. 273 of 2002)
M/S. ANNAPURNA SHIP BREAKERS (Respondent in Tax Appeal
No. 374 of 2002)
M/S. GAUTAM SHIP BREAKING INDUSTRIES (P) LTD.(Respondent
in Tax Appeal Nos. 375 & 376 of 2002)
M/S. BHARAT SHIP BREAKERS CORPORATION (Respondent in
Tax Appeal No. 377 of 2002)
M/S. TRIVENI SHIP BREAKING (Respondent in Tax Appeal
No. 380 of 2002)
M/S. MADHAV INDUSTRIAL CORPORATION (Respondent in
Tax Appeal No. 381 of 2002)
M/S. WESTERN SHIP BREAKING CORPORATION (Respondent
in Tax Appeal Nos. 199, 259, 286, 382 of 2002 & Tax
Appeal Nos. 22 and 23 of 2003)
M/S. SHIP TRADE CORPORATION (Respondent in
Tax Appeal No. 383 of 2002)
M/S. MADHAV STEELS (Respondent in Tax Appeal 384 of
2002)
M/S. SHIP TRADE CORPORATION (Respondent in Tax Appeal
Nos. 359 & 385 of 2002)
M/S. GAUTAM SHIP BREAKING IND. (P.) LTD.
(Respondent in Tax Appeal No. 285 of 2002)
M/S. SHIRIJI TRADERS (Respondent in Tax Appeal
No.299 of 2002)
M/S. A.G. SCRAP CORPORATION (Respondent in Tax Appeal
No. 300 of 2002)
M/S. BHARAT SHIP BREAKING CORPORATION (Respondent
in Tax Appeal Nos. 257, 258 & 361 of 2002)
MADHAV INDUSTRIAL CORPORATION (Respondent
in Tax Appeal Nos. 128 & 129 of 2002)
M/S. APPOLLO VIKAS STEEL PVT. LTD. (Respondent in
Tax Appeal Nos.195, 196, 197 & 198 of 2002)
M/S. PRIYA BLUE INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD. (Respondent
in Tax Appeal Nos. 360 & 362 of 2002)
M/S. MAHALAXMI SHIP BREAKING CORPORATION (Respondent
in Tax Appeal No. 348 of 2002)

--------------------------------------------------------------