Many players refused to record. Remember, it was a totally new
thing. Not "iphone" new but perhaps "personal computer" new. No one
knew if it would be a lasting technology and the sound reproduction
was pitiful at best. Converse died in '03, right? By then, Edison
was just bringing to market his "gold moulded" process. Prior to
that, cylinder making was a 1:1 thing. You arranged as many machines
in the room as you could get and played your piece. Change cylinders
and play it again. Imagine creating thousands of cylinders, 15 at a
time...same song played about every 10 minutes...eight to ten hours a
day. In the 1880's, many tunes were done with only 2 or 3 machines!
1902-1903, Edison's team figured out how to mould cylinders from a
single (or several) masters and mass production took over.
No wonder only a select few studio musicians existed early on.
Some musicians flatly refused to record anyway. Sousa famously
refused, saying he would never make "canned" music. His favorite,
trombonist Arthur Pryor, would take willing band members over to the
studio to make recordings of the band.
===Marc