RE: [SysML-Evaluators] D Smith Comments

[Dandashi, Fatma]

Darold,

I read your assessment of pitfalls of OO in the SysML_OO SE Approach_V1 doc you sent to the group. I find it curious that you indicate "reject" on both specs.  not sure what that means since in your recommendation (last sentence) you state:

"Take this issue into account as a caveat when using SysML OO methodology."

 

if this issue is taken as a caveat, I would think it means we accept both specs.  I think this goes to the heart of most of our discussions on other issues also.  INCOSE requested that OO design techniques be adapted for SE processes and launched the SysML RFI and RFP process through OMG.  I believe both specs have done that well (both specs were essentially the same as of Nov 2005).  SEs now have to learn UML and SysML and adopt the OO techniques which, as you stated, are fundamentally design tools.

 

Given this caveat, I think we should accept the specs.

 

I believe others on this review team echo my position (others who agree, please provide your feedback)

r,

fatma

---

From: SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com [mailto:SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Smith, Darold
Sent: Friday, January 06, 2006 7:51 PM
To: SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: [SysML-Evaluators] D Smith Comments

See the comments attached.

 

Darold K. Smith: PE, CSEP

Certified Systems Engineering Professional

UGS Corporation: Transforming the Process of Innovation

Teamcenter for Systems Engineering

Systems Engineering Consulting Services

darold...@ugs.com

Office: 903.883.0781

Fax:    903.883.2981

[Smith, Darold]

The rejects in both columns were an oversight as I copied the form and didn't change it.  I sent out an email to that effect.

 

However, see the "Update on Issue 30..." sent out yesterday.

 

Regards,

 

Darold K. Smith: PE, CSEP

Certified Systems Engineering Professional

UGS Corporation: Transforming the Process of Innovation

Teamcenter for Systems Engineering

Systems Engineering Consulting Services

darold...@ugs.com

Office: 903.883.0781

Fax:    903.883.2981

---

From: SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com on behalf of Dandashi, Fatma
Sent: Tue 1/17/2006 2:38 PM
To: SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: [SysML-Evaluators] Re: D Smith Comments

[Dandashi, Fatma]

Darold,

Thanks for the clarification. sorry I am behind on catching up with emails.

 

 

---

From: SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com [mailto:SysML-Ev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Smith, Darold

Sent: Tuesday, January 17, 2006 2:47 PM
To: SysML-Evaluators
Subject: [SysML-Evaluators] FW: [SysML-Evaluators] Re: D Smith Comments

[David Oliver]

Darrold,

 

I want to change the accept/reject items in issues 30.00 and 30.10. From the E-mail trail, i think you want both to be accept, but I am not sure. Please E-mail or phone me exactly what matches your opinion.

 

Dave

----- Original Message -----

From: Smith, Darold

To: SysML-Evaluators

Sent: Tuesday, January 17, 2006 2:47 PM