Plans for Atheist Temple Cause Furore Among Atheists

0 views
Skip to first unread message

BIL...@aol.com

unread,
Jan 27, 2012, 3:33:17 PM1/27/12
to radical...@googlegroups.com, BIL...@aol.com
 
Christian Post > World|Fri, Jan. 27 2012 11:14 AM EDT

Richard Dawkins Opposed to Temple for Atheists Planned for London

By Alex Murashko | Christian Post Reporter
 
 
Atheist Richard Dawkins appears to be leading the charge among non-believers in the U.K. who are appalled that a Swiss philosopher and writer residing in London plans to build a "temple for atheists" in the city's financial center.

Alain de Botton said he wants to counter Dawkins' "aggressive" and "destructive" approach to non-belief by building a 151-foot tower to celebrate a "new atheism," according to news reports out of the U.K.

"Normally a temple is to Jesus, Mary or Buddha, but you can build a temple to anything that's positive and good," said De Botton, according to The Guardian. "That could mean a temple to love, friendship, calm or perspective. Because of Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens atheism has become known as a destructive force. But there are lots of people who don't believe but aren't aggressive towards religions."

De Botton, author of the newly released book Religion For Atheists, insists that atheists have as much right to build and enjoy inspiring architecture as religious people.

On Thursday, Dawkins spoke out against the project. The author of The God Delusion is one of several humanists that see plans for the structure as being "misplaced for non-believers to build quasi-religious buildings, because atheists did not need temples to probe the meaning of life."

"Atheists don't need temples," said Dawkins, as reported in The Guardian. "I think there are better things to spend this kind of money on. If you are going to spend money on atheism you could improve secular education and build non-religious schools which teach rational, skeptical critical thinking."

De Botton said he wants the temple to symbolize more than 300 million years of life on earth. The tower's interior has been designed to show the staggering difference between the earth's age and the amount of time humans have existed. The Guardian reports that the exterior "would be inscribed with a binary code denoting the human genome sequence."

Half the funds for the project have already been raised by De Botton to be used by a group of developers who want to remain anonymous, according to the Guardian reporter. Construction could begin by the end of 2013 should the project be approved by the Corporation of London.

However, in addition to opposition from Dawkins and other prominent atheists in the U.K., London authorities are not moving forward with the project's approval because "they can't be seen to be connected to anything to do with atheism," the project's architect, Tom Greenall, said.

De Botton said he chose the country's financial center because he believes it is "where people have most seriously lost perspective on life's priorities."

Rise of the Center

unread,
Jan 28, 2012, 6:45:11 AM1/28/12
to Radical...@googlegroups.com, radical...@googlegroups.com, BIL...@aol.com
This de Botten guy is spot on in his assessment of the Dawkins breed of atheism being aggressive and destructive. Dawkins' response actually illustrates the point some.

In the experience of most people I've talked about this with, atheists have the exact damn same problem that religionists have. Most people who think that way do so and mind their own damn business. But the ones who make the most noise, like freak shows like Dawkins, are the ones that get the most attention and thus give the overall population the impression that a greater number of antheists are judgemental pricks like he is... and sadly a lot of them are. I'm an agnostic myself, and I seriously tried to find a grouping of atheists and agnostics in my area to just hang out with, but the only ones that exist much as well call themselves "Omaha Club for Athiest and Agnostic Victims and Egotistical Prick Religion Haters". The same goes for every group online that I've found, and I've heard the same from friends who live in other areas. It's sad.

I hope de Botten's idea takes off, and spreads. I'd sure as hell go.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages