Shen explodes over in Hacker News

30 views
Skip to first unread message

dr.mt...@gmail.com

unread,
Dec 18, 2025, 6:23:12 AM (3 days ago) Dec 18
to Shen
Every now and again I get thousands of hits on the Shen site in a day. 
Today this is coming from Hacker News.    And as usual, the complaint
is that TBoS is not free.  

TBoS could be bought for the price of a restaurant meal and read in depth.  
Then the OS reader could write a book based on his slant (not
plagiarism) and make it free.  Perfectly OK by me.   I want to flag that.
A free book based on teaching Shen with a commercial slant would
be a valuable asset.

But the OS community complains and ties to dragoon somebody who does
not support their ideas (me) into doing it for them.  The OS
community  is quite extraordinarily shallow at times.   

Anyway anybody who writes such a book, and does a good job, has my 
blessing.  I'll review the book, and, if it is good, endorse it.  If
they want to give it away, I'll be quite composed.   It is their book
and their decision.  What I would never do is try to pressure them
in making it free like these guys, or like Stallman accuse them of being 
immoral for selling it.

However the kerfuffel has jogged me into remembering that I intended
an e-copy.  My publisher seems to have walked away from this 
technology and probably I need to open this matter again.

Mark
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages