Accents

6 views
Skip to first unread message

Garrison

unread,
Aug 8, 2011, 2:42:33 PM8/8/11
to Miso...@googlegroups.com

I should point out that I've been using an accent of my own invention to indicate the difference between word forms. It's a little angle 'hat' accent on top of the letter (â, ê, î, ô). I'm suggesting a new accent because using a horizontal line for two different meanings seemed odd/ambiguous to me. 


A summary of accents as I understand them:


The feminine is a horizontal line on the last syllable that, according to Gajewski, was intended to be put over the syllable (dō, rē, mī, fā, sōl, lā, sī) and was only written after the letter in his book because he abbreviated everything. It's pronounced by prolonging the vowel.


The plural is an accute ( ' ) accent above the final consonant (written by Gajewski after the letter (d'o, r'e, m'i, etc.)) and pronounced by prolonging the by prolonging the consonant as if there were two (ddo, rre, mmi...)


To indicate various parts of speech (noun, adjective, person doing something, etc.), a horizontal line is also used above the syllable. Gajewski also writes this after the abreviated letter, so it's difficult to tell if it was meant to go over the vowel, like the feminine, or after the consonant, like the plural. According to Sudre, this one is a stress accent, pronounced by putting a sudden emphasis on the syllable.


The reason I wanted to use another symbol is because it seems needlessly confusing to use the same symbol for both, when they represent completely different pronunciation and meanings. Also, when putting accents over shorthand or music notes, it seems best to have different symbols, since you can't tell if it's over the vowel or the consonant. I thought of using the little pointy accent thing because it resembles an accent that would be used in music.


Obviously I'm not going to instate a new standard without asking first, so... Thoughts?


Garrison Osteen

unread,
Aug 8, 2011, 7:08:20 PM8/8/11
to Miso...@googlegroups.com
(My second favorite option would be to write the accents like this: dó, ré, mí, fá, sól, lá, sí. That's easier to type at least.)

M O

unread,
Aug 9, 2011, 8:57:56 PM8/9/11
to miso...@googlegroups.com
I think there are a lot of possibilities. For my own notes, I just double consonants for plural (so, "dore" = I, "dorre" = we) and vowels for feminine ("doree" - female first person). So, in those instances, accents aren't even necessary. But I also like the accents you've proposed. Especially the little hats :D But it would be good to start with some sort of convention for marking parts of speech. So far I've just seen people either using capital letters (DOmilado) or apostrophes (do'milado) for emphasis. Again, I don't have a preference at this point.

Garrison Osteen

unread,
Aug 9, 2011, 9:08:46 PM8/9/11
to miso...@googlegroups.com
Okay. Well I'll just keep using my little hats until someone tells me to stop, 'cause I like them :)
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages