Pro-Active action needed from Indian Church to help educate the poor

[Dr. John Dayal]

A crore of Christian youth may get good education at government
expense if the Church wakes up

More than Rupees 3,500 crores to be had in scholarships and assistance

JOHN DAYAL

More than Rupees 3,500 crore has to be had from the government just
for the education of Christian children from primary to doctorate and
foreign studies in the next six years – if only the Church and laity
wake up and help. Ballpark estimates say almost a crore of boys and
girls of economically disadvantaged rural and urban families from the
pre-primary to PhDs, engineering, medical and professional courses
students could be assisted.

The money is in the government’s Plan budgets. And this is apart from
the money that is spent on minority-concentrated districts – and
hopefully block level units in the future – by various ministries such
as those of Social Welfare, rural development and even of water supply
for the befit of the minorities after the Justice Rajender Sachchar
committee excavated the bitter fact that these areas continued to
suffer from lack of development even when compared to “general”
districts in the backwards group.

According to the data available with the Planning Commission’s Working
group on Minorities, the Budget provisions under the ongoing Five year
Plan for the period 2010 is Rupees 2,600 crores, making a total of Rs
7,000 crores for the 11th Plan. For the 12th Plan now under
preparation, a massive sum of Rs 15,000 crore is envisaged for
scholarship and other schemes under the Ministry of Minorities
Affairs. This is for all minorities to be distributed on a pro rata
basis. The Christian community is about a fifth the size of the Muslim
community according to official records. Their share of the entire
amount is 20 per cent, a whopping figure. Rule of thumb statistics put
the number of Christian students at one crore, including Tribals who
continue to get benefits under the Scheduled Tribes quotas.

This figure does not include Dalit Christians who are neither counted
a Scheduled Caste, nor as Christian unless they so register
themselves. In starts such as Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Naidu, even in
Kerala and Maharashtra, many want to be listed as Hindus so that they
can get the Scheduled caste benefits denied to them so cruelly under
the Presidential order of 1950. [The case has been before the Supreme
Court for a number of years, and it is not clear when there will be a
ruling on it.]

The government releases these funds under several schemes, including
the Maulana Azad Foundation, free coaching and allied schemes, equity
to the National Minorities Development Fund, Research and monitoring
studies, grants in aid to state governmetns, schemes for leadership
development among young women, interest free subsidy on academic bank
loans for studies abroad in addition to separate funds for centrally
sponsored scholarship schemes.

The leadership of the Muslim community ahs woken up this fact. Deeply
focused and committed NGOs have been set up to ensure that every
student who qualifies for the merit cum means and other scholarships
gets the benefit and is not left to the mercy of fate. Muslim NGOs and
religious leadership, according to their statements, may have been
successful in ensuring that over 80 lakh students have scholarships
this year, specially in states such as Andhra, Kerala and Uttar
Pradesh with large Muslim populations, because of the initiative taken
by the community leadership.

There is unfortunately a hiatus in the mass communication of such
scholarships despite the claims of the central and state governments.
An additional problem is the red tape, an uncaring state bureaucracy,
and the lack of cooperation from both private second and public sector
banking institutions. The forms have to be taken from local education
officers, or downloaded from the internet website of the government,
not an easy task in rural areas or where the 2G and 3G networks do not
exist, and internet cafes are continuously harried by the police
looking for “suspects”. Once the forms are procured and distributed,
they have to be correctly filled up, the signatures of uncooperative
principals appended to them, income certificates wrested out of
empowers of the parents – and difficult if the family in unemployed –
various other certificates received, and then the entire bunch
uploaded to the department’s website, with the papers submitted to the
appropriate authority.

Muslim grassroots experience has shown that this is an impossible task
for a child or a parent to do unless expert assistance is available.
This is where the special NGOs and volunteers have entered the scene
to help the students. The results have been miraculous.

The same NGOs are now pressing on the Governmnt through the Ministry
of Minority Affairs and the Planning commission that at least 6
crore Muslim students be given scholarships in the 12th Five year
Plan. They have assured the government that they would be able to
assist as many students of the community across India to avail of the
scholarships. The NGOs have also urged the authorities to streamline
the scholarship process, specially as the students rise to higher
classes in their institutions to ensure that scholarships are
available for the entire course and not just for one year. This, they
feel, will encourage the students to complete their studies instead of
dropping out if the scholarship is terminated because they do not get
a 50 per cent score in some year.

Compare this with the Christian situation. It to the best of this
writer’s knowledge, no catholic or protestant church group, nor any
lay association, has set up such a extensive and committed support
infrastructure to assist its student community. The catholic Bishops
Conference or its constituents in the Latin, Syro Malabar and Syro
Malankara Rites, the National Council of Churches in India
representing almost 30 Protestant churches and the Evangelical
Fellowship of India do not have the institutions to do this work. This
has been left to the Dioceses or individual regional churches. But
even in their sectarian – denominational – way, they are almost
entirely ineffective.

In almost every state, when the Bishops of the dioceses are informed
of the availability of the scholarships, all that they do is to ask
Parish priests to announce it after Mass one day. School principals
put the scholarship details on the notice board.

The lay organisations, wherever they exist have not even done this,
though some of them offer pitifully small scholarships for the poor of
the parish by way of charity.

The result of course is that most students are out of the coverage of
these schemes, both for the pre Matric classes and in higher
education.

A large chunk of the money has lapsed. And there is pitifully little
database for advocacy groups to work with the Planning Commission’s
Working Group of Minorities drafting the Minorities component of the
Plan. Christian leadership has done almost no research on how much of
the government’s scholarships have been actually used countrywide. The
Muslim monitoring of the government schemes has to be seen to be
believed. After the Sachchar commission report, the country’s largest
minority has understood that information is power, and an important
tool in influencing the making of government policy. The church
leadership is yet to understand this.

The minorities are of course demanding that their quota be built into
all schemes as a special component, much on the lines of the Scheduled
caste ad Scheduled Tribes quotas that are constitutionally built into
all government plan spending. It is a moot question that the
government will accept this demand, beset as it is by charges from the
Bharatiya Janata party that it is appeasing minorities in general and
the Muslim community in particular. The phrase “vote bank politics”
has become a stick in the hands of the Hindutva forces to beat the
government and force it to withdraw from pr-active measures for the
amelioration of the poor of the minorities, who are doubly
disadvantaged. Their women and the Dalit components have thier future
blinded three-fold.

The situation will be corrected once the community becomes pro-active,
and its leadership assumes responsibility on ensuring that the
benefits reach the youth, and the women.