Nuclear bomb blueprints for sale on world black market, experts fear
Pastor Dale Morgan
Nuclear bomb blueprints for sale on world black market, experts fear*
· Warning as Swiss destroy documents to prevent leak
· Copies may remain with data smuggling network
* Ian Traynor, Europe editor
* The Guardian,
* Saturday May 31 2008
Nuclear bomb blueprints and manuals on how to manufacture weapons-grade
uranium for warheads are feared to be circulating on the international
black market, according to investigators tracking the world's most
infamous nuclear smuggling racket.
Alarm about the sale of nuclear know-how follows the disclosure that the
Swiss government, allegedly acting under US pressure, secretly destroyed
tens of thousands of documents from a massive nuclear smuggling
investigation.
The information was seized from the home and computers of Urs Tinner, a
43-year-old Swiss engineer who has been in custody for almost four years
as a key suspect in the nuclear smuggling ring run by Abdul Qadeer Khan,
the Pakistani metallurgist who in 2004 admitted leaking nuclear secrets
and is under house arrest in Islamabad.
The Khan network trafficked nuclear materials, equipment and knowhow to
at least three countries: Iran, Libya, and North Korea.
President Pascal Couchepin stunned his Swiss compatriots last week by
announcing that the Tinner files, believed to number around 30,000
documents, had been shredded. The extraordinary move, prompting demands
for a parliamentary inquiry, was warranted to prevent the documents
"getting into the hands of a terrorist organisation or an unauthorised
state", according to Couchepin.
However, there are widespread fears this has already happened or still
could. "We know that copies were made," said Mark Fitzpatrick, an expert
on the illicit networks at the British-based International Institute of
Strategic Studies (IISS). "Both US intelligence and the IAEA
[International Atomic Energy Agency, the UN's nuclear watchdog] had been
pursuing this with great urgency and diligence. But what happened to the
other copies that [Tinner] made? It is worrisome that there are other
plans floating around somewhere out there."
Testimony at the 2006 trial of another Khan network suspect in Germany
alleged that Tinner told investigators he had nuclear bomb designs at
his office in Switzerland. The blueprints were in digital form and are
believed to have been copied on to the network's computers in Dubai, the
hub for the Khan operation.
"It's amazing these people had so much information, incredibly sensitive
stuff on nuclear weaponisation and gas centrifuges," said David
Albright, a Washington-based former UN weapons inspector. "I'm sure the
US got a copy. But who else got the documents? Can you believe these
two, the brothers [Marco Tinner is also in custody] were the only ones
who got the stuff?"
In his first interview since 2004 with the western media this week, Khan
told the Guardian that the Swiss case proved that anyone seeking a
nuclear bomb could easily obtain the wherewithal in the west.
He pledged he would never assist western or UN authorities and asserted
that his "confession" of February 2004 was coerced by the Pakistani regime.
While the Swiss government maintains the treasure trove of nuclear
intelligence was destroyed for reasons of national security, the
Americans may have been involved because Tinner is believed to have also
been working for the CIA. Albright said Tinner was recruited by the
American agency from 1999-2000.
"The Swiss were doing other people's dirty work," said an international
official familiar with the investigation into the Khan network. "The
allegation is that Urs was on the CIA payroll for a very large sum of
money."
Olli Heinonen, deputy director general at the IAEA, has led the
investigation into the Khan network for years. Last year his office
sought and gained access to the Tinner files and some of his officials
were also summoned to witness their destruction.
The Americans were also present, according to the international
official. "The Americans were involved in the destruction. They were
calling the shots," he said. The IAEA refused to comment publicly on the
case. A former senior IAEA official said: "I am quite astonished. It's
very unusual to see people destroying documents like this. They should
be put somewhere very safe.
"The real question is how many copies of these documents existed. If
copies were made, where did they go. That's the main issue."
The documents unearthed in the Tinner investigation were so "explosive",
said the government in Bern, that it was obliged to destroy them as a
non-nuclear state that is a signatory to the nuclear non-proliferation
treaty.
President Couchepin said: "There were detailed construction plans for
nuclear weapons, for gas ultracentrifuges to enrich weapons-grade
uranium as well as for guided missile delivery systems."
Had the evidence been presented in court, compromising and embarrassing
information about the CIA's activities with the Khan network could have
surfaced, say experts and officials.
However, destroying the evidence will jeopardise a successful
prosecution of Tinner, whose brother, Marco, and father Friedrich have
allegedly long been associated with the Khan network.
Friedrich Tinner's relationship with Khan goes back to the 1980s. He was
also investigated for aiding Saddam Hussein's alleged nuclear bomb projects.
"The Swiss family headed by Friedrich Tinner was key to the Khan network
for many years," wrote Fitzpatrick of the IISS in a study last year of
the Khan network.