are u a hindu or a secularist

13 views
Skip to first unread message

amit kumar chatterjee

unread,
Jan 21, 2006, 9:25:05 AM1/21/06
to BM_discussion
bharatiya yodhao
Secularism is a new religion developed by anti-hindus who call them as
protector of secular indea.but we nationalist call them
Pseudo-secularist.However if u r annoyed ther are some brain teasers u
wud like to know
1-there are nearly 52 islamic nation in world name 1 country which
provides haj -subsidy?

2-show one nation which has a non muslim as a leader of their country?

3 -Hindu majority maharastra,bihar kerela have elected nonhindus as
their leaders in past but can u expect kashmir,nagaland to do the same

4-if muslims/christian are minorities in mamharashtra,up etc..are
hindus not minority in kashmir or north-east,why r they denied minority
rights?

5-do you think india will be more secular if it becomes a muslim
majority state

answer me
amit kumar chatterjee

kiran...@gmail.com

unread,
Jan 22, 2006, 7:47:32 AM1/22/06
to BM_discussion
Dear Brother Amit,

The best way to stop imbalance is by promoting balance. Lets us
transform the society into one that believes in love and harmony, I
know, its not easy, but that is the only way to achieve a happy
nation.

If you see, there is some mistrust between many religions in India,
let us promote common values in all religions as one common ground
that can be shared and practised by all of us.

to answer your question, are u a hindu or a secularist ? I would
answer 'neither' .
I sometimes felt that vote-bank politics was being practised, dividing
the people on the basis of religion, caste etc..

The solution would be promote Oneness - Humanity Without Barriers.
I am not advocating dormant pacificism - but a gradual progression
towards 'Humanity Without Barriers'

Kiran

panda

unread,
Jan 22, 2006, 11:22:07 PM1/22/06
to BM_discussion
I am a Hndu secularistic atheist. Why? By default or by birth I am a
Hindu Brahmin. Most of the relatives, friends and neighbours are
Hindus. The festivals and other gatherings(socio-cultural events) are
basically having religious tones(in good sense). So all these has given
me an identity. Why I am secular? ( not the pseudo-one) because I do
not think religion is not that much required as far as governance is
concerned. Religion is required for the common mass for spirituality
and setting the parameters of principles. Secularism actually means to
denounce the institutions. It was a very old theory existing in India.
Like CHARWAKS. And a Hindu may be truely secular. Our school of thought
is very rich and open minded and ready to experiment. Now why atheist?
It is also there in our philosophy. A 'bhakta' gets 'mukti' in 12 lives
but a 'shatru' of Bhagawan gets it in 3 lives. Why? Because it's again
really difficult to be an atheist and as man is very weak. I am
attached to Ramakrishna mission and have faith on Shree Ramakrishna and
Vivekananda. They were mortals with flesh and blood. Yes as they
believed in God, I have to think very cautiously and may not throw the
vanishing act.
We are here to work and perform our 'Karma' and 'Dharma which does not
mean religion but 'duty'. It is much more above religion. We have to be
proud with our culture and heritage. We have to regularly treat and
filter our water (life) regularly as dirt always sets in. And 'Vidya
dadati vinayam'. True knowledge makes one sober. The tree which bore
many fruits, vows itself down (nata)
regards
panda

harsha

unread,
Jan 22, 2006, 11:43:03 PM1/22/06
to BM_discussion
amit,
have you ever thought despite being given so many provisions,
why muslims in india still the most economically backward
section? and also they constitute most illiterates, did you
know that less than 5% of muslim women are litereates.

i happen to see MLA/MP seats/jobs being reserved for
SC/ST/OBC but not for muslims. they certainly need to be
given enough economical pull to bring into mainstream like
SC/STs. I really don't wonder if tomorrow government
comes with muslim reservation in education and jobs,
since they are as bad as any other backward section
in India, though people deny reservations based on
caste lines.

Instead of mud slinging, we should be better souls if we
can call ourselves nationalistic and work together for the
betterment of nation.

as far as your fifth point considered, it takes centuries
for muslims population to overtake hindu population with
muslims still being about 18% of total indian population.

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages