dgmoeny said "I just can't get quite comfortable on this bike with it happening unpredictibly."
Is it so unpredictable that you don't know how to make it happen? Or do you have a pretty good idea how to make it happen? If you have a good way to force it to happen, then that can serve as your test case to see if you've solved it.
I've experienced a similar phenomenon with my Black Mountain La Cabra, which has drop bars, full hydraulic disc brakes and a straight legged non-suspension fork. Under very hard braking, and hard dirt trail conditions, I have experienced the front fork semi-violently wobbling front to back. What I think is happening is that the braking forces flex the fork BACKWARDS, which flexes the fork DOWN into the dirt. When traction just gives way, the front wheel unflexes FORWARD, which unflexes UP and the tire loses most of it's contact with the ground and the fork unloads all the way forward and up. Now my weight plants the front wheel back on the ground and the front wheel is locked at that moment, which loads up the system again. With no changes to this resonant system, it'll just cycle over and over, maybe 6-8 times per second.
Does this sound like what is happening with you? If so, I don't think it has anything directly to do with brake pads per se. It has to do with the fact that you are braking hard with comparatively low traction tires. My "solution" on my La Cabra is two fold. I increased traction with lower air pressure, and I now use the bike in an area of the country where the trail are not as hard. Behaviorally, if I get that onset of resonance, I blame it on braking too hard and I let off the front brake slightly -OR- I try to improve front traction by a careful weight shift forward, pushing harder into the front tire so it doesn't let go.
If you aren't sure whether this is what's going on, the experiment I would recommend would be:
-go out and make it happen a few times.
-swap out the front tire to a much wider one, at a lower pressure.
-try to make it happen again
If you fail to make it happen with a wider tire, then that would suggest that it's too much front braking for the comparatively small amount of front traction.
I suspect it's possible that a far stiffer fork could also make it a lot harder to force this situation, but that's a much more expensive experiment.
In a very hand-wavy way, I could argue that experimenting with rotor diameter could change the dynamics, but that's just a guess.
Bill Lindsay
El Cerrito, CA