I think both of you have it a bit wrong. As I wrote before... The INDX tool each has only the
thermal tube, a heat sink and the nozzle. That's all it is... minimal. There is a PTFE guide tube on each, as with all other tool changers to date. Each tool has material loaded from a roll of filament. There is no AMS like device needed. The heater, the thermal sensor and the feeder subsystem all ride in the carriage. Only ONE heater, ONE sensor and ONE feeder and any number of tools/materials all with only ONE controller board.
So... if you have eight tools then you will have eight guide tubes. But only one heater, sensor and feeder subsystem.
From what I see in the Bambu leaked vid, each tool has a heater and temp sensor. They eliminated the need for cabling to each tool, as is done with the XL, by using the wireless connection which transfers current inductively between the carriage and the tool. BUT.. where is the feeder? I do not see room on their tool for a feeder. So maybe it's a singular feeder. Maybe it is a Bowden? Perhaps each tool has the drive gear which somehow connects to the feeder stepper on the carriage? Someday we will see.
On each tool change the filament is pulled out. When parked, the Vortek tool is a completely decoupled component. So when a tool is parked it's what... moved down below somewhere away... and any material still in the tool's melt zone does... what? ooze out in that parking area? The vid does not get that detailed and as such IMO this is simply hyperbole right now.
True, Bondtech is only going to sell the tools and the carriage and not a fully integrated tool changer... but they are already showing the INDX system on open source machines such as the Voron at shows while the Bambu Vortek is currently only hearsay. If Prusa pulls it off and uses the INDX it could save his company, for awhile at least. His blog post is correct. The Chinese Govt is backing Bambu.
Both companies state that the heaters they will use are inductive heaters which, one would assume, will allow significantly faster and more accurate temp control for the melt zone on each tool which one would hope could help control ooze to some degree along with retracting out of the melt zone which I would assume the Bambu will have to do regardless on each tool change.
All of the above is pure conjecture. What is not conjecture right now is the fact that the only (mostly) out of the box tool changer one can buy today is the XL and mine works brilliantly.