current events commentary: due Tues, 1/10, before school
7 views
Skip to first unread message
Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)
Jan 9, 2012, 1:11:35 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Please post a commentary on any NTY article you read over the past
week: 1/3 - 1/8 (1/9 on the web) that interested you. Please identify
the article title and date.
week: 1/3 - 1/8 (1/9 on the web) that interested you. Please identify
the article title and date.
Josh Klag
Jan 9, 2012, 4:01:26 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"For Iranians Waylaid by Pirates, U.S. to the Rescue"- 1/7/12
I thought that the whole situation involving the rescue of Iranian
sailors taken captive by pirates was very beneficial to the U.S., as
well as hilariously ironic. The article states that just earlier that
week, Iran had threatened to attack the Stennis (U.S. ship) if it ever
returned to the Persian Gulf due to an oil conflict. This same ship
then went on to save these Iranian hostages. Although it is not
necessarily indicative of the truth, this event certainly makes the
U.S. look like "the good guy" in this situation. I'm sure it will not
change many people's opinions of the U.S., but it is definitely a step
in the right direction.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
I thought that the whole situation involving the rescue of Iranian
sailors taken captive by pirates was very beneficial to the U.S., as
well as hilariously ironic. The article states that just earlier that
week, Iran had threatened to attack the Stennis (U.S. ship) if it ever
returned to the Persian Gulf due to an oil conflict. This same ship
then went on to save these Iranian hostages. Although it is not
necessarily indicative of the truth, this event certainly makes the
U.S. look like "the good guy" in this situation. I'm sure it will not
change many people's opinions of the U.S., but it is definitely a step
in the right direction.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
Lizzy Hilt
Jan 9, 2012, 4:38:42 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
South Korean Law Casts Wide Net, Snaring Satirists in a Hunt for Spies
By Choe Sang-Hung
January 7, 2012
This article discussed the issue of South Korea prosecuting its
citizens who they believed were “aiding the enemy” (North Korea). This
was very shocking to me because I didn’t think that South Korea
restricted its citizens from expressing their feelings towards North
Korea. A man who was convinced shared his story in this article. He
ran a website that sold books that “aided the enemy”, in other words
he sold a biography of Karl Marx and other stories like this. It
opened my eyes and showed how South Korea is a little corrupt. The
impression given is that this country is very advanced politically
with no flaws. I think this is because it is in comparison to its
Northern neighbor. When in reality, they don’t let their citizens
express their feelings on issues pertaining to North Korea if they are
positive. The government didn’t allow people to express their sympathy
when Kim Jong-il died. This is cutting off their freedom of speech and
shows that the government has a few flaws. Although, I do recognize
that North Korea and Kim Jong-il have done horrific things, it should
not be prosecutable to express your feelings towards this subject.
By Choe Sang-Hung
January 7, 2012
This article discussed the issue of South Korea prosecuting its
citizens who they believed were “aiding the enemy” (North Korea). This
was very shocking to me because I didn’t think that South Korea
restricted its citizens from expressing their feelings towards North
Korea. A man who was convinced shared his story in this article. He
ran a website that sold books that “aided the enemy”, in other words
he sold a biography of Karl Marx and other stories like this. It
opened my eyes and showed how South Korea is a little corrupt. The
impression given is that this country is very advanced politically
with no flaws. I think this is because it is in comparison to its
Northern neighbor. When in reality, they don’t let their citizens
express their feelings on issues pertaining to North Korea if they are
positive. The government didn’t allow people to express their sympathy
when Kim Jong-il died. This is cutting off their freedom of speech and
shows that the government has a few flaws. Although, I do recognize
that North Korea and Kim Jong-il have done horrific things, it should
not be prosecutable to express your feelings towards this subject.
Alexa Lee
Jan 9, 2012, 4:41:24 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"For Congo Children, Food Today Means None Tomorrow" 1/3/12
I felt heartbroken when I read this article. The fact that children
and parents in D.R. Congo have to switch off eating every other day
devastated and enraged me. There is great irony in that Americans and
Europeans have such an abundance of food that people are becoming
obese while the Congolese can barely feed their own children. I mean
the people in Congo can barely afford buying one pound of beef that
costs $5, an amount of money most of us in Radnor consider miniscule!
The enormous gap between rich and poor in the world infuriates me
because it means that many of the rich people do not care enough for
their fellow human beings to lend a friendly hand and give
generously. We must take more action and responsibility in helping
others in need rather than just focusing on our ambitions and our
interests. For the people in D.R. Congo are the same as us. The only
difference is that we happened to be lucky. Therefore it is our duty
as human beings to care for our brothers and sisters in poverty
stricken places like D.R. Congo.
I felt heartbroken when I read this article. The fact that children
and parents in D.R. Congo have to switch off eating every other day
devastated and enraged me. There is great irony in that Americans and
Europeans have such an abundance of food that people are becoming
obese while the Congolese can barely feed their own children. I mean
the people in Congo can barely afford buying one pound of beef that
costs $5, an amount of money most of us in Radnor consider miniscule!
The enormous gap between rich and poor in the world infuriates me
because it means that many of the rich people do not care enough for
their fellow human beings to lend a friendly hand and give
generously. We must take more action and responsibility in helping
others in need rather than just focusing on our ambitions and our
interests. For the people in D.R. Congo are the same as us. The only
difference is that we happened to be lucky. Therefore it is our duty
as human beings to care for our brothers and sisters in poverty
stricken places like D.R. Congo.
Steven Wood
Jan 9, 2012, 5:22:47 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Internet Access Is Not a Human Right"
By VINTON G. CERF
Published: January 4, 2012
An interesting question Mr. Cerf poses, is access to the internet a
human right? In short I believe no it is not. A logical situation
that explains my outlook is an analogy that was included in this OP-Ed
piece. " For example, at one time if you didn't have a horse it was
hard to make a living. But the important right in that case was the
right to make a living, not the right to a horse", this quotation
summarizes his whole argument, at least in the case of the U.S.. This
is a reasonable argument because to become a human right it must be
intrinsic to human life, not to be a tool of human rights. Internet
access is more of a "tool" of human rights, almost as a horse is,
enabling freedom of speech and various other rights while it is not
directly a human right. Although I do not feel the U.S. should follow
the UN's decision, of making internet acces a human right, but the
government should strive for internet access for all. This action for
internet of all is very similar to how we spread telephone connection
and electricity. As for the concern that internet access should
become a civil right, It already silently seems to be, as I stated
previously, with the spread of broadband connection. In conclusion,
should internet access become a human right? No, internet access does
not directly relate to human life, in other words, you can live freely
and happily without it.
On Jan 9, 10:11 am, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
By VINTON G. CERF
Published: January 4, 2012
An interesting question Mr. Cerf poses, is access to the internet a
human right? In short I believe no it is not. A logical situation
that explains my outlook is an analogy that was included in this OP-Ed
piece. " For example, at one time if you didn't have a horse it was
hard to make a living. But the important right in that case was the
right to make a living, not the right to a horse", this quotation
summarizes his whole argument, at least in the case of the U.S.. This
is a reasonable argument because to become a human right it must be
intrinsic to human life, not to be a tool of human rights. Internet
access is more of a "tool" of human rights, almost as a horse is,
enabling freedom of speech and various other rights while it is not
directly a human right. Although I do not feel the U.S. should follow
the UN's decision, of making internet acces a human right, but the
government should strive for internet access for all. This action for
internet of all is very similar to how we spread telephone connection
and electricity. As for the concern that internet access should
become a civil right, It already silently seems to be, as I stated
previously, with the spread of broadband connection. In conclusion,
should internet access become a human right? No, internet access does
not directly relate to human life, in other words, you can live freely
and happily without it.
On Jan 9, 10:11 am, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
Cat Mosier-Mills
Jan 9, 2012, 5:24:06 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Charges Against Journalists Dim the Democratic Glow in Turkey"
By DAN BILEFSKY and SEBNEM ARSU
Published: January 4, 2012
Turkey is a fascinating country, both geographically and politically.
It sits in the divide between Eastern culture (specificially the
Middle East), and Western culture, and must constantly leap between
the values of both sides. It has a long history of being split, with
one section of Istanbul displaying breathtaking Orthodox cathedrals,
and the other half showing the domes of equally impressive mosques.
But lately, this indecision has caused a few riffs. Turkey has debated
about whether or not it will follow the Western economic model (which
has been an extra-difficult subject after the collapse of the euro) or
if it will join its historic allies in the Middle East; it already has
frayed ties with Israel, a western nation, and has had instability in
its own borders regarding the Kurds. This article highlights the fact
that Turkey has been introducing some anti-democratic movements
recently, including one that limits free speech; already, many
journalists, publishers, and activists who study government corruption
have been arrested. As the article stated, "at a time when Washington
and Europe are praising Turkey as the model of Muslim democracy for
the Arab world, Turkish human rights advocates say the crackdown is
part of an ominous trend." "The Arab world" and "undemocratic" don't
go hand-in-hand, but the recent uprisings against repressive leaders
and the successful overthrow of governments has made many people
question if the Turkish people share the same sentiments.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
By DAN BILEFSKY and SEBNEM ARSU
Published: January 4, 2012
Turkey is a fascinating country, both geographically and politically.
It sits in the divide between Eastern culture (specificially the
Middle East), and Western culture, and must constantly leap between
the values of both sides. It has a long history of being split, with
one section of Istanbul displaying breathtaking Orthodox cathedrals,
and the other half showing the domes of equally impressive mosques.
But lately, this indecision has caused a few riffs. Turkey has debated
about whether or not it will follow the Western economic model (which
has been an extra-difficult subject after the collapse of the euro) or
if it will join its historic allies in the Middle East; it already has
frayed ties with Israel, a western nation, and has had instability in
its own borders regarding the Kurds. This article highlights the fact
that Turkey has been introducing some anti-democratic movements
recently, including one that limits free speech; already, many
journalists, publishers, and activists who study government corruption
have been arrested. As the article stated, "at a time when Washington
and Europe are praising Turkey as the model of Muslim democracy for
the Arab world, Turkish human rights advocates say the crackdown is
part of an ominous trend." "The Arab world" and "undemocratic" don't
go hand-in-hand, but the recent uprisings against repressive leaders
and the successful overthrow of governments has made many people
question if the Turkish people share the same sentiments.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
Ben Cohen
Jan 9, 2012, 5:47:14 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Accounts Emerge in South Sudan of 3,000 Deaths in Ethnic Violence"-
Jeffery Gettleman
1/5/12
This article discusses the ethnic violence taking place in South
Sudan. The violence has erupted recently . A large group from the Lou
Nuer ethnic group of about 6000 to 8000 fighters has been spotted by a
UN aircraft. This group has massacred over 3000 while they steal the
peoples' cows. This is very sad news coming from the relatively
recently liberated South Sudan. The country split from Sudan to avoid
massacres of their people, but now the massacres are taking place from
within. The ethnic clashes stop the countries progression
indefinitely. The worrying reasons behind the massacres seem to be the
Lou Nuer's want for cattle. Massacring people for cattle is simply
inhumane. It is very sad seeing a country go through this and not have
the government power to stop it. The future looks grim for South
Sudan, hopefully it will turn around.
Jeffery Gettleman
1/5/12
This article discusses the ethnic violence taking place in South
Sudan. The violence has erupted recently . A large group from the Lou
Nuer ethnic group of about 6000 to 8000 fighters has been spotted by a
UN aircraft. This group has massacred over 3000 while they steal the
peoples' cows. This is very sad news coming from the relatively
recently liberated South Sudan. The country split from Sudan to avoid
massacres of their people, but now the massacres are taking place from
within. The ethnic clashes stop the countries progression
indefinitely. The worrying reasons behind the massacres seem to be the
Lou Nuer's want for cattle. Massacring people for cattle is simply
inhumane. It is very sad seeing a country go through this and not have
the government power to stop it. The future looks grim for South
Sudan, hopefully it will turn around.
Connor
Jan 9, 2012, 5:50:04 PM1/9/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com
"Watching Elephants Fly"
By: Thomas Friedman
January 7, 2011
Friedman's article captured the power struggle and emotions being felt in a post-Mubarak Egypt. He explained the "four-way power struggle" between the army, Islamist parties, secular parties and the youth of Tahrir square. Although many in the West panic at the sight of Islamists winning the elections, the population of Egypt seems to see them, not as radical implementers of Islamic law, but as the best candidates for the job. Coming from the United States, with a secular government, I am obviously biased against the notion of religious implementation in the government. The people of Egypt, as seen from Friedman's article, don't vote for the Islamists because they are Islamists, but because they feel as if they will move the country in the right direction in the future. The protesting youth, however, maintain a different viewpoint. They feel betrayed that Islamists are winning elections, because the widely secular protest movement caused the elections in the first place. Regardless of who is winning the elections, it seems as is everyone is just happy that they are happening in the first place.
Allie Martin
Jan 9, 2012, 6:09:18 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Accounts in South Sudan of 3,000 Deaths in Ethnic Violence" January
6, 2012 By: Jeffery Gettleman
In South Sudan, the newest country on the globe ethnic violence is
escalating terribly. Though the numbers aren't confirmed, with no way
to confirm them, this isn't something to be taken lightly. I think
it's really sad how a couple months of independence this country is
breaking into sectarian warfare. And the fact that the UN and other
organizations are out number by the 6,000-8,000 armed men of the Lou
Nuer tribe isn't helping much. These two tribes have been fighting for
the longest time over cows which has steadily escalated recently
though it has been claiming lives through all these years. Cow raising
a tradition there and it's really terrible to see what these
competitions turn into when you move from spears to AK-47's. And this
is just one more thing that adds on to the unimaginably long list of
problems that Afria has at the moment. Even though that list is long,
all Africa an do is work at it on eproblem at a time.
6, 2012 By: Jeffery Gettleman
In South Sudan, the newest country on the globe ethnic violence is
escalating terribly. Though the numbers aren't confirmed, with no way
to confirm them, this isn't something to be taken lightly. I think
it's really sad how a couple months of independence this country is
breaking into sectarian warfare. And the fact that the UN and other
organizations are out number by the 6,000-8,000 armed men of the Lou
Nuer tribe isn't helping much. These two tribes have been fighting for
the longest time over cows which has steadily escalated recently
though it has been claiming lives through all these years. Cow raising
a tradition there and it's really terrible to see what these
competitions turn into when you move from spears to AK-47's. And this
is just one more thing that adds on to the unimaginably long list of
problems that Afria has at the moment. Even though that list is long,
all Africa an do is work at it on eproblem at a time.
Maddie Chapin
Jan 9, 2012, 6:17:54 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Singer Responds to ‘Patriotic Duty’ to Enter Senegal’s Presidential
Race" 1/4
By Larry Rohter
This article was about a famous grammy winning singer and songwriter
from Senegal, Youssou N’Dour, who has decided to run for president,
although a little late in the race, but still upholds a chance. It
shed light on something I would have never thought about before, which
is a famous celebrity running for president and really opened my eyes
on how his fame could potentially benefit him. The article discussed
the citizens optimism for a new and improved Senegal, and this step
symbolic towards the "new Senegal" that this society has been hoping
for. This singer is someone whom we also learned about in our French
class and was featured in our French book, so it was fun for me to
read this article and have a connection while already having a little
bit of background on the man that could potentially be the next leader
and Senegal; Also, it helped me realize how well known he is.
Race" 1/4
By Larry Rohter
This article was about a famous grammy winning singer and songwriter
from Senegal, Youssou N’Dour, who has decided to run for president,
although a little late in the race, but still upholds a chance. It
shed light on something I would have never thought about before, which
is a famous celebrity running for president and really opened my eyes
on how his fame could potentially benefit him. The article discussed
the citizens optimism for a new and improved Senegal, and this step
symbolic towards the "new Senegal" that this society has been hoping
for. This singer is someone whom we also learned about in our French
class and was featured in our French book, so it was fun for me to
read this article and have a connection while already having a little
bit of background on the man that could potentially be the next leader
and Senegal; Also, it helped me realize how well known he is.
Ashley Gubernick
Jan 9, 2012, 6:20:38 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Tip for London Police Officers: Booze and Secrets Don’t Mix
January 4, 2012
In this article the author explains that after the phone hacking
scandal involving News of the World, hospitality towards journalist
will be scarce. It also says, "Do not indulge in “late-night
carousing” with journalists. Do not flirt with them, either." It was
astonishing that the police, who British citizens trust for security,
would have to be reminded not to drink and flirt with journalists in
order to not share secrets. In order to trust police, British people
need to be able to have confidence in the police force. I know if I
were British I would be worried that any officer should need a
reminder not to get too cozy with a journalists who may share any
information that I have disclosed. Journalists on the other hand
should be ashamed that they have been pushing police officers with
these sly tricks. Britain needs to be coherent to have credence
flowing through the country. Guileful journalists and acquiescent
policemen make for a country with many secrets, because no one will
trust each other. It is helpful that the police will now be less
easygoing with journalists, but knowing that the police are going to
do a better job keeping secrets should also make citizens uneasy, as
well, because it means the police must have a lot of secrets to keep.
Overall I think this is a lose-lose situation.
January 4, 2012
In this article the author explains that after the phone hacking
scandal involving News of the World, hospitality towards journalist
will be scarce. It also says, "Do not indulge in “late-night
carousing” with journalists. Do not flirt with them, either." It was
astonishing that the police, who British citizens trust for security,
would have to be reminded not to drink and flirt with journalists in
order to not share secrets. In order to trust police, British people
need to be able to have confidence in the police force. I know if I
were British I would be worried that any officer should need a
reminder not to get too cozy with a journalists who may share any
information that I have disclosed. Journalists on the other hand
should be ashamed that they have been pushing police officers with
these sly tricks. Britain needs to be coherent to have credence
flowing through the country. Guileful journalists and acquiescent
policemen make for a country with many secrets, because no one will
trust each other. It is helpful that the police will now be less
easygoing with journalists, but knowing that the police are going to
do a better job keeping secrets should also make citizens uneasy, as
well, because it means the police must have a lot of secrets to keep.
Overall I think this is a lose-lose situation.
James Lofton
Jan 9, 2012, 6:37:39 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Iran Warns US Aircraft Carrier Not To Return To The Gulf" - 1/3/12
By: J. David Goodman
In this article, the country of Iran bluntly warns the United States
that the USS John C. Stenis that harsh penalties will be issued if the
carrier were to try to return to the Persian Gulf. The carrier is a
part of the US Navy's 5th fleet which is stationed out of Bahrain. The
Government of Iran has said dumb things in the past, some really dumb
things, but in my opinion is is up there with some of the elite. Some
background on the Stennis: it is a $4.5 billion, Nimitz-class, nuclear
powered, weapon of destruction capable of carrying 90 fixed wing or
rotary aircraft. The Nimitz class carrier is quite possibly the most
destructive weapons system in the world. It is a floating city capable
of reaching out and attacking targets hundreds of miles away. When the
ship is deployed in-theatre, it has a crew of up to 6500. Now the
Iranian navy. It is believed that the total personnel of the
Republic's sea-weary forces is around 28000. A total of 65 aircraft
and most capable warships being 5 frigates.
Knowing this information, I feel it is safe to say that Iran is like
the bully from "A Christmas Story" who talks a good game but cries
when in a fight. They have nothing to back up their claims (Unless of
course there is nuclear capability... but even then). The United
States Navy and their subsidiaries (i.e. Navy Seals) are the most
capable fighting force on the planet, and Iran claiming to possess the
ability to close the Strait of Hormuz, or even stop the Stenis from
returning to base, is absolutely outrageous. I have faith that the US
and allies (essentially the entire world in this particular matter)
will not let Iran dictate the international waters of the Persian
Gulf, and there will not be a debacle such as the world saw during the
Iran-Iraq war. Iran's smack talk will continue while life in their
country will become worse due to sanctions, so it seems to me that
either the "Persian Spring" comes or Iran bites off more than they can
chew militarily. Or maybe both...
By: J. David Goodman
In this article, the country of Iran bluntly warns the United States
that the USS John C. Stenis that harsh penalties will be issued if the
carrier were to try to return to the Persian Gulf. The carrier is a
part of the US Navy's 5th fleet which is stationed out of Bahrain. The
Government of Iran has said dumb things in the past, some really dumb
things, but in my opinion is is up there with some of the elite. Some
background on the Stennis: it is a $4.5 billion, Nimitz-class, nuclear
powered, weapon of destruction capable of carrying 90 fixed wing or
rotary aircraft. The Nimitz class carrier is quite possibly the most
destructive weapons system in the world. It is a floating city capable
of reaching out and attacking targets hundreds of miles away. When the
ship is deployed in-theatre, it has a crew of up to 6500. Now the
Iranian navy. It is believed that the total personnel of the
Republic's sea-weary forces is around 28000. A total of 65 aircraft
and most capable warships being 5 frigates.
Knowing this information, I feel it is safe to say that Iran is like
the bully from "A Christmas Story" who talks a good game but cries
when in a fight. They have nothing to back up their claims (Unless of
course there is nuclear capability... but even then). The United
States Navy and their subsidiaries (i.e. Navy Seals) are the most
capable fighting force on the planet, and Iran claiming to possess the
ability to close the Strait of Hormuz, or even stop the Stenis from
returning to base, is absolutely outrageous. I have faith that the US
and allies (essentially the entire world in this particular matter)
will not let Iran dictate the international waters of the Persian
Gulf, and there will not be a debacle such as the world saw during the
Iran-Iraq war. Iran's smack talk will continue while life in their
country will become worse due to sanctions, so it seems to me that
either the "Persian Spring" comes or Iran bites off more than they can
chew militarily. Or maybe both...
Melissa Lee
Jan 9, 2012, 6:41:35 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Indonesia Activists Call for Boy's Release in Petty-Theft Case
By Sara Schonhardt
1/4/12
After 15-year-old Indonesian boy was accused of stealing shoes, and
consequently brought to court, unique protest of the case ensued. He
had supposedly stolen an officer’s shoes and now Sgt. Harahap has
ordered interrogation that led to abuse of the boy. More than 1,200
flip-flops and other sandals lay among the grounds of Palu, where
students and protestors have already surrounded the courtroom. The
National Commission for Child Protection organizes the gathering of
the footwear. A National Police representative claims the procedures
had been followed through successfully and correctly, but the
activists beg to differ. In result, the boy may be sentenced to five
years in prison. Through the case officials continue to look into
police “misconduct”. This incident displayed the questionability of
security and police forces, and awakens and unifies many Indonesians
against the issue. The unfair misfortune for the young boy represents
a hole in the judicial system of the nation, and as the protestors
have urged, reform is much needed in the country of islands,
especially towards the rights of children upon crime.
By Sara Schonhardt
1/4/12
After 15-year-old Indonesian boy was accused of stealing shoes, and
consequently brought to court, unique protest of the case ensued. He
had supposedly stolen an officer’s shoes and now Sgt. Harahap has
ordered interrogation that led to abuse of the boy. More than 1,200
flip-flops and other sandals lay among the grounds of Palu, where
students and protestors have already surrounded the courtroom. The
National Commission for Child Protection organizes the gathering of
the footwear. A National Police representative claims the procedures
had been followed through successfully and correctly, but the
activists beg to differ. In result, the boy may be sentenced to five
years in prison. Through the case officials continue to look into
police “misconduct”. This incident displayed the questionability of
security and police forces, and awakens and unifies many Indonesians
against the issue. The unfair misfortune for the young boy represents
a hole in the judicial system of the nation, and as the protestors
have urged, reform is much needed in the country of islands,
especially towards the rights of children upon crime.
Colin Castro
Jan 9, 2012, 6:54:57 PM1/9/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com
U.S. Reverses Policy in Reaching Out to the Muslim Brotherhood
By: David D. Kirkpatrick
January 3rd, 2012
I found this article interesting on a multitude of levels. First, as a supporter of Obama, I was happy to see this. I think American government needs to take into account and recognize the great strides the people of the Middle East have fought for in the last year. Many of the Middle Eastern people have a goal of setting up a democracy, something that's the pinnacle of our political ideology. I wasn't happy with American relations with Egypt, because it seemed that the Obama administration was just trying to keep the Mubarak team propped up. The military leadership has shown quite a few Mubarak leftovers, and power-hungry people. Violence has been seen, as has awful stories of women being sexually humiliated in public. Throughout the last 30 years the American government has sided themselves with some shady dictatorships in the Middle East. But, America has a chance to become a partner with the countries in a process of rebirth, and importantly protect Israel. Egypt is the most vital, and necessary ally for the Americans in the Middle East.
This article highlighted the Americans new-found interests in the Muslim Brotherhood. Progressive meetings were noted between the two sides. The Muslim Brotherhood has captured the popularity in Egypt, and this could be a good thing. The American government has had a history of viewing the Muslim Brotherhood as extreme Islamists. This piece featured quotations from the brotherhood that stress a Brotherhood interested in respecting women, creating a democracy and establishing relationships with the West. It's also made clear that the Obama team doesn't find this mission ideal, but with the Muslim Brotherhood's seemingly rational stances the administrations first priority would be the safety of the Camp David Accords. A quotation from John Kerry focused on the importance of a change in America's stance. If the Obama Administration can find a way to support Egypt, grow closer and more trusting of the Muslim Brotherhood and preserve The Camp David Accords that would be a victory.
Leigh
Jan 9, 2012, 7:28:36 PM1/9/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com
"3 In-Laws of Afghan Girl, 15, Are Held in Her Torture" by Graham Bowley 1/3/12
I found this story absolutely awful and had a hard time reading it. A 15 year old girl in Afghanistan was tortured by her husband's family because she refused to go into prostitution. They brutally abused her physically and kept her locked in a bathroom in the basement of their house. Since she is the same age as me it really hit home. I can't fathom surviving what she went through, and expect she is now psychologically damaged for the rest of her life. I think it's appalling that things like this go unnoticed for around 6 months. At the same time I am so proud of this girl I have never even met. I think she was very courageous and strong. In today's world people like these are the true heroes, not celebrities or billionaires. I wish all the best to Sahar Gul, and hope she recovers from this awful experience.
I found this story absolutely awful and had a hard time reading it. A 15 year old girl in Afghanistan was tortured by her husband's family because she refused to go into prostitution. They brutally abused her physically and kept her locked in a bathroom in the basement of their house. Since she is the same age as me it really hit home. I can't fathom surviving what she went through, and expect she is now psychologically damaged for the rest of her life. I think it's appalling that things like this go unnoticed for around 6 months. At the same time I am so proud of this girl I have never even met. I think she was very courageous and strong. In today's world people like these are the true heroes, not celebrities or billionaires. I wish all the best to Sahar Gul, and hope she recovers from this awful experience.
Addy
Jan 9, 2012, 8:03:47 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Indonesia Activists Call for Boy’s Release in Petty-Theft Case 1/4/12
This article is about a 'protest' of the arrest of a young 15 year
old. The boy was caught stealing the shoes of a police officer. The
officer then arrested him, and he is currently on trial. The
Indonesian people are protesting this trial by collecting shoes. The
original goal was 1000, but they now have collected 1200. I my opion
the goal of the collection is to show how commonplace, and there for
worthless, shoes are. They are causeing the police officer to be
embarrassed becasused of how rediculous the charges are. I choose to
write about this story, because it really accentuates the TIME
magizine person of the year, the protestor. The power of the protester
is a massive force. Eventhough this protest is tiny in comparison to
the arab spring/serbian winter protests, it just shows how the idea of
free speech, and the power of a person going against the establishment
has taken hold throughout the world.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
This article is about a 'protest' of the arrest of a young 15 year
old. The boy was caught stealing the shoes of a police officer. The
officer then arrested him, and he is currently on trial. The
Indonesian people are protesting this trial by collecting shoes. The
original goal was 1000, but they now have collected 1200. I my opion
the goal of the collection is to show how commonplace, and there for
worthless, shoes are. They are causeing the police officer to be
embarrassed becasused of how rediculous the charges are. I choose to
write about this story, because it really accentuates the TIME
magizine person of the year, the protestor. The power of the protester
is a massive force. Eventhough this protest is tiny in comparison to
the arab spring/serbian winter protests, it just shows how the idea of
free speech, and the power of a person going against the establishment
has taken hold throughout the world.
On Jan 9, 1:11 pm, "Ken Sklar (Radnor High School)"
Jeremy Rhome
Jan 9, 2012, 9:03:22 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
“Bold Lie Turns Run-In At Sea Into Dramatic Rescue”
CJ Chivers, January 7th 2012
Out of all of the articles this week I found this one the most
interesting by far. This article was a more detailed account of the
six weeks that the Iranian sailors were taken hostage by Somali
pirates and how language and a daring lie played a large role. When
the hijacked ship was docked a French naval vessel was suspicious of
the boat and asked in both Arabic and English if the crew was in
distress. The hijackers answered, pretending to be the crew, and
informed the French that the ship was fine. When the American
destroyer Kidd pulled alongside the captured vessel they first asked
in Arabic and English, then in Urdu. The captain, risking his life,
responded in Urdu. He asked for help and told the Americans to
board. The Somali pirates asked what had just been said, and the
Captain made his biggest bluff yet, he told them that the Americans
were going to blow up the ship. They called his bluff, panicked, and
surrendered. Besides the bold move by the Captain this story is a
current testament to the importance of learning language in foreign
affairs. The French did not have an Urdu speaker and the Americans
did, this is what potentially saved violence and human life. These
types of situations were also evident in the culture handouts we
received early this year, which outlined the problems the US has with
foreign relations because of language barriers. I am glad that in
this situation the US Navy’s foreign language skills and some courage
on behalf of the Iranians ended up victorious. Ironically this boat
was in the same group of ships that the Iranians had warned not to
return to the Persian Gulf. Hopefully this event can improve relations
between Iran and the US.
CJ Chivers, January 7th 2012
Out of all of the articles this week I found this one the most
interesting by far. This article was a more detailed account of the
six weeks that the Iranian sailors were taken hostage by Somali
pirates and how language and a daring lie played a large role. When
the hijacked ship was docked a French naval vessel was suspicious of
the boat and asked in both Arabic and English if the crew was in
distress. The hijackers answered, pretending to be the crew, and
informed the French that the ship was fine. When the American
destroyer Kidd pulled alongside the captured vessel they first asked
in Arabic and English, then in Urdu. The captain, risking his life,
responded in Urdu. He asked for help and told the Americans to
board. The Somali pirates asked what had just been said, and the
Captain made his biggest bluff yet, he told them that the Americans
were going to blow up the ship. They called his bluff, panicked, and
surrendered. Besides the bold move by the Captain this story is a
current testament to the importance of learning language in foreign
affairs. The French did not have an Urdu speaker and the Americans
did, this is what potentially saved violence and human life. These
types of situations were also evident in the culture handouts we
received early this year, which outlined the problems the US has with
foreign relations because of language barriers. I am glad that in
this situation the US Navy’s foreign language skills and some courage
on behalf of the Iranians ended up victorious. Ironically this boat
was in the same group of ships that the Iranians had warned not to
return to the Persian Gulf. Hopefully this event can improve relations
between Iran and the US.
Rachel Hochberger
Jan 9, 2012, 9:15:08 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Russian Art Group Claims Attack on Police Van
By Ellen Barry
1/3/12
I found this article interesting, because Voina was a group whose
rebellious artistic demonstrations and works I had heard of before.
However I found this story of them attacking police vehicles with
gasoline bombs surprising. While many revolutions recently have come
with extreme violence and terroristic attacks, it would seem
appropriate for an art group to respond in a more pacifistic way,
letting their work speak for itself. But instead, the members of this
group felt the need to portray a more “activist” approach, by
destroying a vehicle used to transport convicts as a symbol of
liberation to political prisoners. I agree with the idea that art
should be used as a way to convey strong emotions, but I found it
interesting that Voina chose to do so in this way.
By Ellen Barry
1/3/12
I found this article interesting, because Voina was a group whose
rebellious artistic demonstrations and works I had heard of before.
However I found this story of them attacking police vehicles with
gasoline bombs surprising. While many revolutions recently have come
with extreme violence and terroristic attacks, it would seem
appropriate for an art group to respond in a more pacifistic way,
letting their work speak for itself. But instead, the members of this
group felt the need to portray a more “activist” approach, by
destroying a vehicle used to transport convicts as a symbol of
liberation to political prisoners. I agree with the idea that art
should be used as a way to convey strong emotions, but I found it
interesting that Voina chose to do so in this way.
Alex Freedman
Jan 9, 2012, 9:17:56 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Israelis and Palestinians Exchange Position Papers, and Talks Will
Resume by Agence France-Presse, 1-5-12
The article briefly talked about Israeli and Palestinian negotiators
exchanging position papers. Although the article also mentioned that
"long negotiations await us" I have a lot of hope. This article
interested me for two reasons. The first being that I just was in
Israel and able to see how the conflict truly effects the people of
Israel. The second being that I hope to see peace between Israel and
the Palestinians in my lifetime because it is important for the future
of the Jewish people and the state of Israel and the entire Middle
East that peace is acchieved very soon. This is so important because
of the vital role Israel plays in relations with other countries in
the Middle East such as Jordan and Egypt, but also western countries
such as the US. I believe Jordan sees that hosting the talks will
speed up the process in peace making, allowing Jordan to no longer
have to struggle to pick sides between two allies. While this is only
the beginning, I know that (hopefully) only progess can be achieved
from this point on.
Resume by Agence France-Presse, 1-5-12
The article briefly talked about Israeli and Palestinian negotiators
exchanging position papers. Although the article also mentioned that
"long negotiations await us" I have a lot of hope. This article
interested me for two reasons. The first being that I just was in
Israel and able to see how the conflict truly effects the people of
Israel. The second being that I hope to see peace between Israel and
the Palestinians in my lifetime because it is important for the future
of the Jewish people and the state of Israel and the entire Middle
East that peace is acchieved very soon. This is so important because
of the vital role Israel plays in relations with other countries in
the Middle East such as Jordan and Egypt, but also western countries
such as the US. I believe Jordan sees that hosting the talks will
speed up the process in peace making, allowing Jordan to no longer
have to struggle to pick sides between two allies. While this is only
the beginning, I know that (hopefully) only progess can be achieved
from this point on.
Erica
Jan 9, 2012, 9:49:06 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"Karzai Gives a Lukewarm Welcome to Taliban Talks"-1/4/12
by Graham Bowley
This article was an analytical piece regarding Karzai's response to
the Taliban opening an office in Qatar. The Taliban recently announced
that they will be opening an office in Qatar, in order to possibly
begin negotiating with the United States. Afghanistan president Hamid
Karzai 'welcomed the Taliban's announcement,' seemingly unfazed by
this unexpected occurrence. It wasn't his response, however, that is
getting people talking, but the fact that it took a day for him to
respond to the Taliban. The reason for this is that Afghanistan
planned on being a key participant in peace talks, not a secondary
one. Talks between the United States and Afghanistan have led to the
conclusion that Afghanistan should be the catalyst for these talks.
Most of all, I think Karzai is puzzled- can this terrorist group
really be trusted to begin peace talks? They aren't exactly what
anybody would call the peaceful type. We'll see how this plays out
over time, but I can't see it going in a positive direction.
by Graham Bowley
This article was an analytical piece regarding Karzai's response to
the Taliban opening an office in Qatar. The Taliban recently announced
that they will be opening an office in Qatar, in order to possibly
begin negotiating with the United States. Afghanistan president Hamid
Karzai 'welcomed the Taliban's announcement,' seemingly unfazed by
this unexpected occurrence. It wasn't his response, however, that is
getting people talking, but the fact that it took a day for him to
respond to the Taliban. The reason for this is that Afghanistan
planned on being a key participant in peace talks, not a secondary
one. Talks between the United States and Afghanistan have led to the
conclusion that Afghanistan should be the catalyst for these talks.
Most of all, I think Karzai is puzzled- can this terrorist group
really be trusted to begin peace talks? They aren't exactly what
anybody would call the peaceful type. We'll see how this plays out
over time, but I can't see it going in a positive direction.
Zoe Bermudez
Jan 9, 2012, 10:41:38 PM1/9/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com
By: Andrew Jacobs
Published: January 3, 2012
This article really stood out to me the most. China is trying to punish yet another innocent civilian who is trying to stand up for what they believe is the correct for the suppressed people of the country. This poor woman was simply a lawyer who would defend cases of other human rights activists against the government, and for that she was horribly abused. Apparently she was beaten so bad, she's been in a wheelchair ever since the police abused her in jail the first time. The story this article told angered me that an innocent woman was crippled on so many levels just because she was helping others like her. This only goes to show how much China lacks in toleration of its people. The government is disgusting; maiming its own people and denying them the right to freedom of speech. Human beings need a form of expression and if China continues to try to oppress its citizens, sooner or later it will lead to violence.
PART 2
For Congo Children, Food Today Means None Tomorrow
Published: January 3, 2012
Reading this article had such a strong impact on me. It was heart wrenching to think about the millions of children that will go without food for weeks. A couple memories came back to me but they were only of not eating for a couple weeks and sometimes it wasn't because I had to. The children of the D.R. Congo are suffering and there's nothing they can do about it; I wish I could. I can only imagine how all those parents feel, watching as their babies slowly starve. Every good parent wants their child to be happy so it must be heart breaking for all those mothers and fathers witness their kids go through unwanted pain, even though they're trying the hardest they can. Reading these kinds of articles makes me want to go back to thinking about becoming a volunteer worker for the UN to help suffering humans in need. But for now, I can only hope that whoever out there is reading these same articles and donating money towards helping these families. I'd like to do that when I'm older.
Maureen McDermott
Jan 9, 2012, 11:16:19 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
"U.S. Navy rescues Iranians Held by Pirates"
by Robert Mackey and J.David Goodman
January 6, 2012
There have been a few articles about this topic in the past week, and
this is just one of them, but I found this topic to be really
interesting. Somali pirates had been holding these 13 Iranian
fisherman hostage for more than a month. A US Navy destroyer had been
patrolling the waters they were in and rescued them. That is pretty
cool since the US and Iran are not on good terms, and now more than
ever with the sanctions we have recently imposed on them, but despite
that our Navy still came to their rescue and saved them from the
pirates. I don't think for a second that that would really enhance the
Iranian/American relationship at all, but it was just a nice gesture
of good faith. Also, another article on the rescue this week (that I
can't seem to find right now) was telling the story of how the rescue
actually happened, and it was really interesting. Apparently what
happened is Americans made an announcement (in Urdu i believe) telling
everyone on board that was armed to drop all their weapons and the
Somali pirates didn't speak Urdu so they asked the Iranian hostages
what the Americans said and one of the hostages told them that we were
going to blow up the boat. This caused the pirates to panic and they
all ran below deck for shelter and then the Americans were able to
board the boat, save the Iranians, and take the pirates into custody.
I just thought that was really interesting and clever of the Iranian,
and I am intrigued to see if anything more will come of this issue/the
piracy issue in general.
by Robert Mackey and J.David Goodman
January 6, 2012
There have been a few articles about this topic in the past week, and
this is just one of them, but I found this topic to be really
interesting. Somali pirates had been holding these 13 Iranian
fisherman hostage for more than a month. A US Navy destroyer had been
patrolling the waters they were in and rescued them. That is pretty
cool since the US and Iran are not on good terms, and now more than
ever with the sanctions we have recently imposed on them, but despite
that our Navy still came to their rescue and saved them from the
pirates. I don't think for a second that that would really enhance the
Iranian/American relationship at all, but it was just a nice gesture
of good faith. Also, another article on the rescue this week (that I
can't seem to find right now) was telling the story of how the rescue
actually happened, and it was really interesting. Apparently what
happened is Americans made an announcement (in Urdu i believe) telling
everyone on board that was armed to drop all their weapons and the
Somali pirates didn't speak Urdu so they asked the Iranian hostages
what the Americans said and one of the hostages told them that we were
going to blow up the boat. This caused the pirates to panic and they
all ran below deck for shelter and then the Americans were able to
board the boat, save the Iranians, and take the pirates into custody.
I just thought that was really interesting and clever of the Iranian,
and I am intrigued to see if anything more will come of this issue/the
piracy issue in general.
Kaleigh Link
Jan 10, 2012, 6:32:31 AM1/10/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Prosecutor Accuses Security Forces of Interfering in Mubarak Trial
By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK
Published: January 4, 2012
This article talks about how during Mr. Mubarak's trial there was some
foul play, that the "security forces" obstructed the evidence. I think
that this is surprisingly ironic because the government was trying to
hide all this evidence from the prosecutor so that they could dismiss
the case, but in the end the prosecutor decided to lead his own
investigation and found exactly what he was looking for and got all of
them thrown out of the government but now, he is throwing them even
more under the bus by saying that the government constrained with part
of the trio;. This article kind of teaches us to always be honest
because when you lie or hide something, it can always be found.
By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK
Published: January 4, 2012
This article talks about how during Mr. Mubarak's trial there was some
foul play, that the "security forces" obstructed the evidence. I think
that this is surprisingly ironic because the government was trying to
hide all this evidence from the prosecutor so that they could dismiss
the case, but in the end the prosecutor decided to lead his own
investigation and found exactly what he was looking for and got all of
them thrown out of the government but now, he is throwing them even
more under the bus by saying that the government constrained with part
of the trio;. This article kind of teaches us to always be honest
because when you lie or hide something, it can always be found.
Shefain Islam
Jan 10, 2012, 6:35:24 AM1/10/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com, 2011 Global Issues
"Iraq Turns Justice Into a Show, and Terror Confessions a Script"
By: Jack Healy
Published: January 7, 2012
By: Jack Healy
Published: January 7, 2012
The second the U.S. left Iraq, Iraq turned its head with a mischievous grin, similar to a disobedient child whose strict mother just left for the first time. Taking this metaphor farther, Iraq has just begun recking the house and throwing the raging party. Iraq has begun to televise their practices of "justice" to advertise the power of what they hope will be their all Shiite government. The sheer nerve Iraq must have to reinstate this dictatorship practice must be a sight to see. After thousands upon thousands of people died for on both the American side and the Iraqi side, Iraq goes back to the type of government that everyone suffered so much to get rid of. Not only are these televised events dehumanizing, corrupt, and illegal but they also show that Iraq is just getting started.
Claire Kirby
Jan 10, 2012, 9:33:57 AM1/10/12
to 2011-glob...@googlegroups.com
"Overtures to Egypt's Islamists Reverse Longtime U.S. Policy"
1/3/12
I thought that this article was really interesting because it really showed how different countries can really affect the way our country is run. In this case, the U.S. is attempting to create stronger ties with Egypt as an allie to try and gain connections with the Muslim Brotherhood for good future relations. Currently in Egypt, the Muslim Brotherhood is pulling almost full majority in the Parliament, causing Obama to think differently witht how he wants to control our MIddle Eastern relations. I think this change will be a good one, as it will gain support for us among other Middle Eastern countries we don't normally have good relations with. Also, with many Islamist groups taking over nations that recently went through Arab Spring revolutions, it will hopefully secure better relations with the region in the future.
Quincy Shuda
Jan 9, 2012, 7:58:25 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
“Myanmar’s First Girl Band Pushes Limits of Censors, and Parents”
January 4, 2012
This article was one that I found particularly interesting from the
news this week, about a Myanmar’s first girl band - Me n Ma Girls. The
article talked about how Myanmar is becoming a more “Asian” culture
which comes along with censored artwork, media, and of course music.
But these Asian cultures are recently struggling with the attraction
from their younger generations to more Western culture aspects, of
which the music industry is very large, along with clothing and family
values. This story enlightening me by showing me the similarities and
differences that these mid twenty-year old girls and girls the same
age and younger have in America. In the article it talked about how
one girls father only wanted her to sing gospel songs. This kind of
thought can be found in the United States but in a less extreme sense
it seems. Here in America it seems to me that most parents do whatever
they can to keep their children motivated to achieve whatever it is
that they want out of life while still keeping up with their morals.
But I know my parents would support me on most paths I would decide to
take. This must mean that in Myanmar, dressing in Western clothing and
singing “provocative” songs is so unacceptable that the parents will
not allow it; this would be similar to something of the nature of
prostitution here in the United States. The article talks about how
the girls travelled to Bangkok in Thailand and how it was an eye
opening, amazing experience for them - not being called a “slut” or
“bad girl” for wearing clothes that would be completely normal for
girls in America. I guess growing up in a culture that is so
conservative compared to ours would give a girl a different sense of
cultural boundaries. But for me to imagine living such a censored
place seems a bit crazy. What this shows is that you can’t miss what
you never had - some children are brought up in ways and they expect
that is just the way you live, no exceptions made. This story made me
so grateful to live in a country where girls can express themselves
however they want without being punished for it.
January 4, 2012
This article was one that I found particularly interesting from the
news this week, about a Myanmar’s first girl band - Me n Ma Girls. The
article talked about how Myanmar is becoming a more “Asian” culture
which comes along with censored artwork, media, and of course music.
But these Asian cultures are recently struggling with the attraction
from their younger generations to more Western culture aspects, of
which the music industry is very large, along with clothing and family
values. This story enlightening me by showing me the similarities and
differences that these mid twenty-year old girls and girls the same
age and younger have in America. In the article it talked about how
one girls father only wanted her to sing gospel songs. This kind of
thought can be found in the United States but in a less extreme sense
it seems. Here in America it seems to me that most parents do whatever
they can to keep their children motivated to achieve whatever it is
that they want out of life while still keeping up with their morals.
But I know my parents would support me on most paths I would decide to
take. This must mean that in Myanmar, dressing in Western clothing and
singing “provocative” songs is so unacceptable that the parents will
not allow it; this would be similar to something of the nature of
prostitution here in the United States. The article talks about how
the girls travelled to Bangkok in Thailand and how it was an eye
opening, amazing experience for them - not being called a “slut” or
“bad girl” for wearing clothes that would be completely normal for
girls in America. I guess growing up in a culture that is so
conservative compared to ours would give a girl a different sense of
cultural boundaries. But for me to imagine living such a censored
place seems a bit crazy. What this shows is that you can’t miss what
you never had - some children are brought up in ways and they expect
that is just the way you live, no exceptions made. This story made me
so grateful to live in a country where girls can express themselves
however they want without being punished for it.
Quincy Shuda
Jan 9, 2012, 8:02:10 PM1/9/12
to 2011 Global Issues
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages