On Wed, 9 Nov 2016 10:37:37 -0000 (UTC), TMack <
qw...@yuiop.com>
wrote:
>>>> It's my view that there are *no* subjects which are out of bounds for
>>>> humour. Although it's a pretty unfashionable view nowadays, where
>>>> taking offence has become an international sport.
>> OK, so here's my favourite (probably only) racist joke:
>>
>> Q. Why didn't the nigger want his daughter to marry a mexican?
>> A. Because he didn't want his grandkids to grow up too lazy to steal
>> for a living.
>>
>> On the surface, this is just two awful stereotypes. But the way it
>> melds them together exposes them for what they are, and, imo, turns the
>> target towards people who might hold these views.
>>
>> Or maybe not - humour is the ultimate subjectivity.
>Your particular interpretation of that "joke" doesn't make it OK. It would probably go down well with Britain
>First or the EDL. However, Try telling it at your place of work and see how much your employers laugh. Try
>telling it to some black guys to find out how funny they think it is.
You appear to be saying that for a joke to be funny, it must be
amusing for 100% of people who hear it. That is never going to be the
case. I wouldn't tell the joke at work, because clearly there's the
possibility of people not realising I'm trying to invoke some irony.
And I wouldn't tell it to anyone who was black (or mexican) unless I
already had a solid friendship with them (i.e. I *have* told it to my
mate Mike Horton)
>There are people who think it is very funny to denigrate minority ethnic and cultural groups; there are people
>who will mock the disabled for laughs; there are people who think that causing gratuitous harm to others is very
>amusing - their humour doesn't justify their actions "It's funny" does not override all the rules of civilised society.
I've never said that humour overrides the rules of civilised society.
I'm allowed to say that I don't find something funny. I'm not allowed
to tell someone else that he shouldn't find something funny. Of
course, if he finds something funny that I find offensive, then we
have different world views, and probably aren't going to get along.