Jesse Brown behind the assault on Ghomeshi . . .

[Jesse Brown]

The woman who filed charges against Jian - to be heard (or maybe not) in June is named here . . . . Kathryn Borel. And she's a 'personal friend' to Jesse Brown.

And it's questionable from this little talk whether Borel ever did file a formal complaint against Ghomeshi with CBC management.

Read here the animosity of Jesse Brown for CBC personalities - and guess where he used to work . . . . and the fact that Ezra Levant is his 'pal'.

If you're going to listen to the audio, you might want to scroll the bar at least 1/3 the way past the stupid exchanges.
__________________________________

http://freethepresscanada.org/Jan 27 Posted by Amy MacPherson


Jesse Brown Withholds Ghomeshi Evidence, Fails To Disclose CBC Conflict


In a stunning twist to the Jian Ghomeshi scandal, new details emerge from the reporter who broke this story that cast doubt on the professional integrity of his investigation. On or about December 11, 2014 and after charges were laid against Ghomeshi, Jesse Brown provided a friendly interview to Ed The Sock that raises considerable issues (clip appears below).
____________________________

AUDIO of the 'interview' with the scandal-monger, Jesse Brown:
https://soundcloud.com/ed-the-sock/ed-the-socks-sock-talk-wjesse-brown
____________________________

Ed The Sock is a provocative puppet personality and a former fixture at CityTV. The character was played by Steven Kerzner who no longer stars on MuchMusic, but he maintains an obscure podcast to keep in touch with nostalgic fans. Kerzner previously ran for the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario before supporting the NDP, as well.

With fewer than 1,200 listeners, Brown admitted numerous details he withheld from the Ghomeshi exposé, that was eventually published in conjunction with the Toronto Star. A hearty dose of laughter accompanies this discussion about Brown's "recriminations", that may precipitate a need to examine his involvement.


Personal & Professional Conflicts at CBC

Jesse Brown begins by confessing he is a personal friend to Kathryn Borel, the former CBC producer who alleges Ghomeshi threatened to "hate f-k" her during a business meeting at Q. It is unknown whether Brown failed to disclose his personal conflicts, or if the Toronto Star agreed to withhold the information in light of Ms. Borel's intention to remain anonymous at the onset. Neither Brown nor the Toronto Star would respond to questions about this matter.


Not only were Brown and Borel friends, but they were also coworkers. Jesse Brown failed to disclose his relationship with CBC as a radio host, in competition with Ghomeshi, at the very time Borel confided in him about the alleged harassment.

The three were CBC colleagues and Brown now admits he was the employee who didn't come forward to report the abuse. He goes on to suggest that all men need to have this conversation, about why they remain silent as he did and what is required of men to protect women in modern times.

From Brown's perspective and due to the shrinking pool of available jobs in journalism, he felt that reporting Ghomeshi would result in losing his position for rocking the boat and forcing CBC to confront its workplace issues.

No events were mentioned to cause this apprehension, but Brown freely admits his own ambition was a factor in staying quiet, as the only person who also confesses to knowing about Borel's predicament. Every insult and allegation leveled against Q staff and CBC producers was ultimately directed inward.


CBC Complaint & The Missing Witness

The other part of Brown's explanation for remaining silent raises issues for the internal investigation. CBC hired an outside lawyer to determine what went wrong, because Borel claims to have submitted a complaint that was ignored by the union and broadcaster.

However, the Canadian Media Guild denied receiving a complaint that included sexual harassment allegations and CBC is under fire for failing to discover corresponding records that identify her claim.

In the audio clip, Jesse Brown mentions that Borel never made a complaint and he was sworn to secrecy because she didn't wish to come forward. He says it wasn't his place to betray Borel's wishes and he supported his friend by instructing her to keep notes, at least.

Brown adds there was a witness to the former producer's allegation; but none was mentioned in the Toronto Star report, witnesses were excluded from the Ghomeshi narrative and Brown is continuing to withhold that name. Without it, neither the CBC nor the police and Ghomeshi's lawyers can investigate.

Kathryn Borel also approached foreign press at The Guardian to finish telling her story, instead of sharing with the immediately concerned Canadian media. In her editorial, Borel adds new sexual assault allegations that accuse Ghomeshi of massaging her upper body and thrusting his private area into her backside (clothed). She claims there was a witness to this event in support of Brown's recent interview, but doesn't disclose that name either.


The Toronto Star and Jesse Brown declined to comment about their knowledge of Borel's newly published allegations. It's unknown if Borel withheld this information in her anonymous account, or if the investigating reporters withheld these details since the beginning. The more fulsome description that was published in another country isn't aided by Brown's confession that he "amended details" about all the women's stories, due to his self perceived "license" to direct, craft and alter their reports.

This is also the first time a friendship between Kathryn Borel and Jesse Brown was disclosed, by the complainant and not the journalist. Furthermore, Brown admits he was the one to solicit Borel's allegation for the news. He explains sharing her story with the other women and offering to seek his friend's support to bolster their claims.

Based on Jesse Brown's confession, there appears to be a conflict of interest to protect his old job while selectively blaming former colleagues and censoring the bulk of details that include his direct involvement.

Ethics forbid this behaviour and the failure to disclose, but Brown admits he is new to investigative journalism and believes that online reporting is allowed to play by 'different rules' than the mainstream is required to uphold. These rules are understood by journalists as libel law and issues that concern truth in reporting, vetting and verification.

Were The Women Using Jesse?

In this interview with Ed The Sock, Jesse Brown elaborates on the other female complainants. He describes the initial email from the first woman and says it led to consecutive interviews with the others. Brown nor the Toronto Star would comment if the first complainant coordinated the others, or if these women approached Brown independently.


But he did accuse the females of "using him". When Ed The Sock realized the inappropriate nature of this comment, he guided Brown to describe the event as washing each other's hands, as opposed to being used.

Brown responds by agreeing and admits his professional position was compromised, that he crossed into "sticky territory" as a supportive and friendly therapist. There were questions if the women were "pissed off", that Brown used their friendship to obtain a story - one they didn't wish to be told. He describes a process of having to remind the complainants about his status as a reporter, when they shared details about their relationships with Ghomeshi.


To achieve the females' consent, Brown admits he amended details and yet there were still "certain places they didn't want him to go". He admits altering more than their names and "all sorts of stuff" was withheld. This suppression occurred in concert with censorship that Brown demanded, because to him this wasn't about a sex scandal.

In his license and authority to reconstruct the narrative, he admits fighting with the Toronto Star to bury and exclude information that would shift from his focus on violence and CBC as a sick institution.


Regarding acts of sexual violence, Jesse Brown reports the women questioning their memories and if they could trust their recollections. According to the interview, he describes having to "push and pull" the complainants to obtain their information and admits "media proofing" them prior to the Toronto Star's publication.


Strombo Equated With Ghomeshi, Levant On A Pedestal

Expanding on Brown's view about the real problem surrounding Jian Ghomeshi, he blames the CBC for creating stars when they've done nothing to earn that prestige.
To him, this wasn't about the criminal charges and rather the success of talent that he doesn't deem worthy.

Brown goes on to discuss his greater performance and believes he lost his position at CBC because they're not looking for skilled staff of his caliber.

For some time Brown rants about the employment of George Stroumboulopoulus and claims the same case can be made against him as Ghomeshi.

It's not that Brown is alleging sexual misconduct, but this drives the point home that his concerns about Ghomeshi didn't focus on the women or the alleged assaults. To him, this was strictly about the future of CBC, his own access to employment and ratings.

It's Ed The Sock who feels compelled to defend George Strombo and he appears surprised by Brown's attack. The clash occurs again when Brown slurs "they could never wash the CityTV off" and then accuses CBC of poaching unmerited celebrity from competitors like MuchMusic and bands like the one Ghomeshi starred in.

To provide context, Jesse Brown lavishes Ezra Levant with admiration for his exceptional talent at pushing everyone's buttons. Two weeks before this commentary, Levant lost an $80,000 lawsuit that was filed against him for defamation. The judge cited his "reckless disregard for the truth", but this had no effect on Brown's perception of successful news personalities, versus the substandard celebrity he attributes to the CBC and the vast majority of Canadian entertainment.


Politics & Jeffrey Dvorkin

In another interview with J-Source that slightly pre-dates the Ghomeshi story, Brown describes himself as a bitter and disgruntled, ex-employee of the CBC. He says Canadaland was losing money and the show's more generous sponsorship had come to an end.

At the midpoint of a Ghomeshi investigation, Brown told The Walrus he was struggling so badly that filmmakers and comedy writers were being added to cover the gap in entertainment. He felt the podcast had become poisonous to his connections and career.

These commentaries span a few months and mere weeks before the Ghomeshi story broke, he lamented about a need for stable funding to continue. Brown attributes some optimism to daily encouragement he received from other journalists, specifically naming Jeffrey Dvorkin.

Dvorkin hails from Calgary, Alberta and now serves as the Director of Journalism at the University of Toronto. Before that, he held positions in Canada at CBC Radio and on the stateside at NPR. In 2010, he accepted an assignment from the U.S. Department of State, to lecture Niger and Guinea on the role of press in elections.

This was followed by a similar mission to teach Turkish reporters about their powers in 2011, despite the widespread incarceration of journalists and a government- media scandal that ensued.

Dvorkin is also a major force behind the push to remove CBC from television airwaves, converting solely to internet production and the often debated Canadian Netflix. He was making this case at the same time Jesse Brown began the Ghomeshi investigation.

Before any news about the sexual allegations surfaced, Dvorkin appeared on Canadaland to encourage support for the dismantling and reconstruction of CBC.

During this interview with Jesse Brown, Dvorkin scoffs at senior CBC staff for suggesting that Justin Trudeau's Liberals would restore funding to cure their ills. He closes by citing cuts from Liberal governments as the reason he left CBC for greener pastures in the United States.

This viewpoint appears to influence Jesse Brown's position, as heard in the audio clip with Ed The Sock. At length, he parrots the same talking points and goes on to assert the CRTC should plan for obsolescence too. This rant is peppered with much criticism for Canadian talent and programming, with a dig at ACTRA forming part of the exchange.

It should be noted that Lucy DeCoutere, one of the Ghomeshi complainants, is also one of these Canadian actors that Brown carelessly disparages with gusto, in addition to his description of feeling used.


Friends & Eyes Wide Shut

Less known is Brown's entry into the lucrative tech business, as the co-creator of Bitstrips. This app was once popular on social media and allows users to express their lives in cartoon caricature versions of themselves. It's still popular in the school system and the company received a $3 million investment, but articles about Bitstrips fail to mention Brown and he's the only source to assert this relationship. He declined to answer questions from FreeThePressCanada about this issue.

In his other pursuits, Brown's investigation of Ghomeshi benefited from an allegation that arose from Professor Jeremy Copeland. The Toronto Star published that Copeland shunned his students from pursuing internships at Q due to inappropriate behaviour, but Western University denied this was possible and so did the student newspaper.

Other journalism programs then came forward to deny issues or complaints about Ghomeshi at their facilities. The matter was never questioned or readdressed by the press.

Cautiously and coincidentally, Jeremy Copeland worked with the U.S. government to fill a similar role as Jeffrey Dvorkin. The former was the American spokesperson for out-of-country voting in Iraq and he trained Iraqi journalists how to cover their election after the war that responded to 9/11 attacks. The same as Turkey, this country descended into chaos and lost the battle for message control. Both are now mired by ISIS and political-media issues, along with the greatest threat to the survival of journalists.


Jesse Brown describes this cast of personalities as the media version of Eyes Wide Shut in his discussion with Ed The Sock. He claims the community is Toronto-centric and he singles out neighbourhoods from Beaches and the Annex, as those who know and contribute to the decline by playing along. Brown believes they're all friends or married to one another and he admits being part of this dysfunctional but influential posse, that determines the narrative for Canadian views.

Brown describes the group as inbred and David Akin reminds everyone that Sun TV was pursuing a 'hotbed' of sexual harassment suspicions at CBC since the year before.

He used the Ghomeshi scandal to suggest that CBC mislead parliament when it responded to accusations in the last round. In that example, the broadcaster was accused of processing 1,454 sexual harassment complaints in Toronto and Ottawa alone (proven untrue, see link for details). Regardless, Ezra Levant from Sun TV appeared on Canadaland a few days ago.


Cash Flow Returns, But Politics Remain

In Jesse Brown's history with the CBC, he once faced a dispute about the right to republish work from The Contrarian on his own website. The broadcaster has a policy to archive online materials after a period of 2 years, thereby causing the content to become inaccessible. As Brown attempted to save his creative input from the compression pile, he received a takedown notice from CBC management and today these shows are nowhere to be found on the internet.

When the same issue arose regarding Jian Ghomeshi and the public's sensitivity toward archiving programs from Q, Brown was at the forefront pushing for this content to be relegated in the same manner.


After the Ghomeshi story broke, the Globe and Mail reported Brown's income had risen to more than $9,000 per month. The Columbia Journalism Review went one step further and tracked these increases on a monthly basis since October - the same month Brown's crowdfunding campaign went live and the Ghomeshi allegations were published.


One month after that major headline, Ed The Sock was a guest on Jesse Brown's Canadaland in a role reversal. During this interview, Steven Kerzner (aka Ed), is asked about sexual misconduct allegations involving Moses Znaimer at CityTV. Odd behaviour is discussed, but Kerzner declines to contribute to any rumour mills.

When Brown visits Kerzner less than two weeks later, they discuss Jesse's pitch to all the major publishers for an earlier version of his media criticism program.

Brown reports he was prepared to be 'more responsible and sober' and 'not a satirical'. These blanket denials to provide him with a venue resulted in the establishment of Canadaland, described in the audio clip as kicking people in the shins, in lieu.

When the income generated by Brown's podcast hit the $10,000 per month benchmark, he intended to hire staff. Brown declined to answer questions about his income, but Sean D. B. Craig was employed to break the Amanda Lang story on behalf of Canadaland more recently.

Craig is unknown as a journalist and no bio can be found online. Originally he promoted himself as a CBC producer on social media, but later apologized for the humorous misrepresentation, due to the commotion and confusion it caused.

Brown then introduced his new hire as a "pinko comrade". The term pinko is commonly directed toward supporters of the NDP, both fondly and as a slur.



The Response

Jesse Brown, CBC, the Toronto Star and lawyers for Jian Ghomeshi were contacted.

The CBC was approached with this audio clip and a proposal to run the story. Director of Government Relations, Shaun Poulter, was exceptionally helpful to facilitate contact with others at the broadcaster. The Head of Media Relations, Chuck Thompson, also took a concerned interest to facilitate discussion. The latter agreed this information should be forwarded to the external investigator, but a decision to print the story would need to come from the news department directly.


Thompson involved the senior producer of CBC News, Ian Kalushner. After three days of debating the story without hearing the file, he declined any proposition to provide coverage. Mr. Thompson was then re-approached and encouraged to review the clip before another publication was canvassed, in lieu of the broadcaster's response.

At this time Thompson attended the news department to discuss the clip with Kalushner. A compromise was reached and the reporter regularly assigned to the Ghomeshi file was asked to evaluate the evidence, as the most knowledgeable person about these developments on staff. CBC News expressed hesitation to publish freelance work, despite the fact that FreeThePressCanada had a history of reporting politics for the broadcaster in years past.


After another five day lapse, CBC journalist Ioanna Roumeliotis accepted the file for review. Both she and producer Ian Kalushner responded,

"You would be accurate to describe my assessment of the audio clip as material that is not newsworthy."

Chuck Thompson responded,

"... I don't make editorial decisions for CBC News and I know you have been in touch with them. It's their call as to whether or not they want to go further with what you have discussed."


Jesse Brown was notified about the impending article and presented with 42 questions for comment. He declined to provide answers and politely rebutted,

"The story of my investigation of Jian Ghomeshi is an important one that I will tell the public in detail.

It will take a lot of work and care. Here's what I need to be mindful of:
Protecting my sources' identities. Presenting a full account may expose them, so I need to go over everything very carefully, consulting with them where possible to remove identifying details.

Legal concerns. The professional and personal behaviour of many people will be discussed, so this story needs to get lawyered.

Accuracy. This is a complicated story, key aspects of which unfolded rapidly. I need to go over hundreds of notes and emails and dozens of public documents. Since I see no immediate urgency in reporting this story as soon as possible (I'm not finished with the investigation of Jian itself yet!) I'm going to take my time and tell it as precisely and as well as possible.

Finally, I am in the news business, so of course my intention is to save all this stuff for my own report."


The Toronto Star was provided with a similar opportunity to comment and 25 related questions. Multiple attempts were made to contact investigative journalist, Kevin Donovan, and the newspaper's editor, Michael Cooke. Both were informed they are the only source that refuses to respond, beyond Mr. Donovan's messages to inquire about the nature of these questions on social media.

That silence was broken by an unrelated Toronto Star columnist, Jack Lakey, who proceeded to insult and intimidate FreeThePressCanada for approaching his colleagues to send the email inquiry.

Henein Hutchinson LLP accepted the audio clip quite recently.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
The law firm representing Jian Ghomeshi hasn't received a reasonable amount of time to examine and comment. If a statement is forthcoming, this article will be edited to include that response.

The Clip: Jesse Brown & Ed The Sock

Please be advised this audio contains profanity and racial, religious jokes that some may find offensive. Originally published by Ed The Sock's Soundcloud account, December 11, 2014. This is re-posted for news reporting and fair comment purposes (original source).