Command line ACL, why doesn't the project owner have sufficient rights?

[Johan Martinsson]

We're connecting Gerrit to the ALM Tuleap. The workflow for migrating a project from the ALM to gerrit is something like:

1. create a project 
2. create several groups (contributors and integrators)
3. Associate rights to the groups 

But step 3 is not possible as per default neither an administrator nor a project creator has Read and Push on refs/meta/config.

We've found one workaround (manually creating a rights-only project which we use to give the rights Read and Push on refs/meta/confg and inheriting from that), but that's a complexity we'd like to avoid if possible. Is it?

Best regards

Johan Martinsson

Enalean/Tuleap

[Shawn Pearce]

Can you grant Read and Push on refs/meta/config to Administrators and
Project Owners in All-Projects? This will then be automatically
inherited into every project, so newly created projects would always
permit modification of refs/meta/config by git push.

[Edwin Kempin]

2012/11/12 Shawn Pearce <s...@google.com>

On Mon, Nov 12, 2012 at 2:45 AM, Johan Martinsson
<martinss...@gmail.com> wrote:
> We're connecting Gerrit to the ALM Tuleap. The workflow for migrating a
> project from the ALM to gerrit is something like:
>
> create a project
> create several groups (contributors and integrators)
> Associate rights to the groups
>
> But step 3 is not possible as per default neither an administrator nor a
> project creator has Read and Push on refs/meta/config.
>
> We've found one workaround (manually creating a rights-only project which we
> use to give the rights Read and Push on refs/meta/confg and inheriting from
> that), but that's a complexity we'd like to avoid if possible. Is it?

Can you grant Read and Push on refs/meta/config to Administrators and

Unfortunately I think we forbid to assign Push for refs/meta/config on the All-Projects project,
but you can assign in on refs/meta/* to make it work.
I will spend some time later today to fix this.
 

Project Owners in All-Projects? This will then be automatically
inherited into every project, so newly created projects would always
permit modification of refs/meta/config by git push.

--
To unsubscribe, email repo-discuss...@googlegroups.com
More info at http://groups.google.com/group/repo-discuss?hl=en

[Johan Martinsson]

Can you grant Read and Push on refs/meta/config to Administrators and
Project Owners in All-Projects? This will then be automatically
inherited into every project, so newly created projects would always
permit modification of refs/meta/config by git push.

No, in All-Projects there is only Push Merge Commit and Push Annotated Tag

[Johan Martinsson]

On Monday, November 12, 2012 4:12:57 PM UTC+1, Edwin Kempin wrote:

 

Can you grant Read and Push on refs/meta/config to Administrators and

Unfortunately I think we forbid to assign Push for refs/meta/config on the All-Projects project,
but you can assign in on refs/meta/* to make it work.
I will spend some time later today to fix this.

 Indeed that works

Thanks!