I don't think there is any such thing as the "Best" coleslaw... I hate
onion and mustard in cole slaw, ruins it, I especially abhor Dijon
mustard (an abomination) in anything. I love a good cole slaw, I too
would cut way down on the celery seed, in fact I would use Penseys
celery salt to taste instead (who needs celery seeds stuck between
their teeth), while cutting back on the salt (salt to taste). I don't
think it's possible to follow a slaw recipe exactly anyway, how much
cabbage is a medium head? What are medium carrots? And I've seen
bell peppers that weigh over a pound, I've grown them (I think red
bell pepper is better in slaw, looks nicer too, often I use both red
and green). I make cole slaw often, I use fresh picked cabbage from
my garden... none from a produce department come close in flavor. I
make slaw by eyeball and taste because all veggies are different
sizes... I've never in my life actually measured ingredients for a
slaw... go easy with the vinegar, sugar, and especially salt... you
can always add more but you can't take it out. And remember that
commercial mayo contains a lot of salt. I sometimes halve the mayo
and use plain yogurt or sour cream. To me the most impartant element
of cole slaw is shredding the cabbage, I want long paper thin shreds.
I don't like slaw made with chewed up cabbage like from a food
processor. I slice my cabbage by hand, I have a carbon steel 12"
chefs knife just for that purpose.... years ago Lee Valley was selling
old Sabatier hand forged carbon steel knives, I should have bought
more.