On 8/6/2017 4:44 PM, jbeattie wrote:
> On Sunday, August 6, 2017 at 8:01:12 AM UTC-7,
cycl...@gmail.com wrote:
>>
>> Jay - do you normally ride at such a speed that heavy braking with any sort of brake is necessary?
>
> Actually, my hardest braking is at slow speeds -- steep downhills with 90 degree non-banked turns at the bottom. Sled hills. Once in my life, I hit a twisting, paved down-hill with too much gusto and couldn't stop fast enough to make turn. I ended up in some blackberry bushes. I had some really crappy Universal single pivot brakes with bad pads. Dual pivots would have saved the day. Better pads would have saved the day.
The first ten speed I ever bought was a German-made Staiger with Balilla
center pull brakes. Even when I didn't know much about bikes I thought
they were dismal. I remember endless squealing despite playing with
toe-in and different shoes. But I probably paid $75 for the bike (in
1972) so I shouldn't complain much.
The next worst brakes I had were the Dia Compe long-reach centerpulls
that were originally on my 1973 (?) Raleigh Super Course. That was
before Kool Stop Salmon pads were available, of course. The long brake
arms decreased mechanical advantage. (My wife had identical brakes but
short reach, and they were fine.) At the time I was amazed at how good
they were, but that's only by comparison with the Balillas.
BTW, that long reach center pull set is on the three speed bike I built
a few years ago. For tootling around shopping, etc. they're perfectly fine.
> I couldn't stop my touring bike with my son in a Burley Trailer on some poorly adjusted cantilevers (they never worked well with STI levers). And I was on a very steep section of road and unable to stop on some cable discs with worn pads that I had not adjusted. I scrubbed enough speed to make the corner at the bottom and then stopped and adjusted the brakes and changed the pads when I got home.
As I've mentioned before, we had a Warm Showers guest who said he had no
(as in zero) brakes during one day on tour because he wore the pads
away. I think disc users should carry a set of spare pads.
>
> In wet weather, I prefer the positive fee of discs and the absence of free-fall as a caliper brake squeegees off the rim. Rim brakes also eat rims on wet dirty roads.
The most exciting free fall I experienced was with the Balillas on
dimpled steel rims. I guess the dimples act as water reservoirs,
preventing wiping the rims even semi-dry. In a thunderstorm downpour, we
sailed on literally hundreds of feet past our planned turning point.
ISTM in the old days, people were told when riding in the rain to wipe
the rims by light brake application before a spot where brakes might be
needed. With decent rims and shoes, that works well enough for me.
These days, people are told instead to buy disc brakes.
--
- Frank Krygowski