On 9/30/17 7:24 PM, ScottW wrote:
> "MiNe109" <
pianof...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:oqojtq$1pnm$1...@gioia.aioe.org...
>> On 9/30/17 10:41 AM, ScottW wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Individual blacks = good
>>>>
>>>> Blacks as a whole = bad
>>>
>>> Why do you insist on a simpleton's analysis?
>>
>> That's "reductive." It's so Art can follow the argument.
>
> It's stupid and for your benefit alone.
"reductive ADJECTIVE
Tending to present a subject or problem in a simplified form, especially
one viewed as crude."
No, that's what I mean to do. If your argument won't stand up to being
simplified, maybe your argument is at fault.
>>>>> You actually do them a grave disservice by enforcing such a
>>>>> belief and it is your position that they are incapable of
>>>>> overcoming history and a stacked system. I say the barriers
>>>>> are not as great as you claim and their ability to overcome
>>>>> is underestimated by you.
>>>>
>>>> My claims are illustrated by your complaints.
>>>>
>>>>> As the writer on DACA protesters said, it is your position
>>>>> that holds people on the 21st century plantation. A position
>>>>> that demands people remain beholding to a political ideology
>>>>> that seeks to keep them beholding forever is this
>>>>> generations overseer.
>>>>
>>>> Plantation! You actually went there!
>>>
>>> Are you comfortable you petty overseer?
>>
>> Playing the "real racist" card! Boring.
>>
>>>> Where did all that individual up-by-their-bootstraps gumption
>>>> go?
>>>
>>> It's their if you nuture it. Instead you choose to crush it
>>> with tales of insurmountable systemic victimization.
>>
>>
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundown_town
>>
>> Yep, gumption can overcome that.
>
> Enough could with the courts on their side. Still, your reference
> provides no recent specific example> But I won't disupute the
> problem exists.
https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Society/2017/0327/Sundown-towns-Midwest-confronts-its-complicated-racial-legacy
In many ways, the legacy of that past lingers.
In September 2015, letters were sent to Utica High School and the school
district office threatening violence because of interracial dating. The
letters had images of the Confederate battle flag. The community and the
schools condemned the letters and launched a campaign called “Utica
United”; the homecoming football game and dance were canceled.
Chris Cooper took the threat personally. The letters were targeting
black people. “And there’s only so many adult black men in town – me and
my friend Robert, as far as I can tell.”
After the letters, Cooper pulled his son out of the Utica schools and
sent him to a more racially diverse school in Newark, a larger town down
the road.
End quote.
Also, too, gentrification.
>>>> Or does that only count to excuse racism, lack of
>>>> inter-generational wealth, redlining, institutional biases,
>>>> etc?
>>>
>>> and there you go crushing instead of nurturing again.....The path
>>> to equality is no longer in the streets protesting grievances
>>> that are no longer tangible. The path to equality is through hard
>>> work and knowledge.
>>
>> You left out 'opportunity.'
>
> I clearly argue the opporunity exists....it's up to the individual to
> take advantage of it.
You're wrong about the scale at which it exists. It doesn't do a
population any good if it requires the equivalent of The Hunger Games to
escape.