Ed Stasiak <
esta...@att.net> wrote:
>>Adam H. Kerman
>>>Ed Stasiak
>>>The Old Testament is myth, not a historical document and if the Palestinians
>>>never "owned" the area, then the Jews didn't either, seeing as how until
>>>1948 A.D. they were subject to one or another of the surrounding (and
>>>historically proven) kingdoms and empires.
>>I had to change your "smart quotes" to plain ASCII; please don't do that.
>They^Yre just plain old quotation marks on my end.
Bullshit. You've got Rich Text turned on, haven't you. Google Groups
sucks enough. You don't need to make it suck more by not using plain text.
>>The territory of Palestine was occupied by Egypt and Jordan until the
>>1967 Six Day War.
>And by the British before that and the Turks before them and the Byzantines
>before them and so on, all the way back to thru history. With the exception
>of a few short lived revolts against foreign overlords, the area has never
>been independent.
You're missing the point. It wasn't partitioned till The Mandate in the
Treaty of Versailles when the French and British grabbed the non-Turkish
part of the Ottoman Empire for themselves, and then the post WWII partition
of 1948. There just weren't any international boundaries before then,
no nation states.
I want you to acknowledge that it was the Arabs themselves that rejected
the two-state solution (with an international Jerusalem).
>>Curious how Egypt and Jordan were never seen as repressers of the
>>Palestinian people yearning for their own state during that period, the
>>one promised them by the U.N. partition.
>How nice of the UN to ^@^\give^@^\ the Palestinian their own state, while handing
>over half their territory to European immigrants.
The Jews of Central Europe weren't immigrants; they were exiles. You just
told us it wasn't Palestinian territory, but British territory, and
Turkish territory before that, and Byzantine territory before that,
and Roman territory before that.
>It^@^Ys the equivalent of me declaring The Kingdom of Gondor in your
>backyard, with the cops telling you to just accept it or they’ll beat your
>ass.
>>The Palestinians are hardly a Biblical people
>But Israeli Jews, almost all of whom are Europeans, are?
No. Sephardic Jews had lived all over the Middle East, including
Jerusalem, for centuries, ever since they were exiled from Spain.
It's about half and half.
>Seems to me, the Palestinians are the ones who never left, so they^@^Yd
>get dibs but what^@^Ys done is done.
What do you mean, never left? They're only partly descended from peoples
mentioned in the Bible, intermixed with Arabs from the Arabian Peninsula.
They're actually genetically similar to lots of Sephardic Jews, hence
all the curly hair and darker complexions.
You are aware that the Jews have been exiled repeatedly throughout history,
yes? You really do deny a whole lot of history.