On Monday, January 15, 2018 at 6:11:57 PM UTC-5, Moriarty wrote:
> On Tuesday, January 16, 2018 at 8:55:37 AM UTC+11, J. Clarke wrote:
> > On Mon, 15 Jan 2018 21:37:43 +0000,
news{@bestley.co.uk (Mark Bestley)
> > wrote:
>
> <snip>
>
> > >> What happens wherever you are when the prof says "Turn in exercises 1,
> > >> 3, and 7" and the ones you turn in are from a different edition with
> > >> different numbering?
> > >
> > >The excercises are given by the tutor - either dictated or on handouts
> > >or do question X in the exam paper the University set in year Y. ie the
> > >questions are independant of the means used to teach.
> >
> > In this context what does "tutor" mean. In the US a "tutor" is
> > someone a student or his parents hire to help a student with
> > schoolwork.
> >
> > And exams are independent of homework.
>
> When I went to Uni there were two types (*) of class contact:
>
> 1) Lectures where the prof would tell us stuff and we'd all write down what he/she said/wrote. Questions weren't discouraged but were more or less impractical in, say, a first year Algebra lecture of 300 people. The person giving the lecture was a full time academic and employee of the uni.
>
That would be an instructor, in the US. Those lecturing to classes
that large are usually not adjunct faculty, but somewhere on the
tenure track: associate Prof, assistant Prof, full Prof, every
once in a while a visiting Professor.
> 2) Tutorials, much smaller classes, usually no more than 20 people where questions could be asked, examples worked through, past papers gone over etc. The person running that was a tutor. I taught first year algebra and calculus tutorials for five years while a postgrad, and it was fairly common for postgrads to earn a few extra bucks that way.
>
The guy or gal who meets with the smaller groups of students is a
"teaching assistant," or TA. In science classes there are also
"lab assistants." These are usually grad students, acting as
the instructor's assistant as part of the deal giving the grad
student a break on tuition.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teaching_assistant#Graduate
> Neither lectures or tutorials were compulsory but we still were required to take the roll in tutorials. I think the only thing it was used for was to check students' attitudes in the event they made a claim for special consideration when they failed an exam.
>
I enrolled in an honors track, and as a result was never in any of
those monster classes. I think we had nearly 100 in a "Physics for Poets"
2-semester course I took as a freshman. I had skipped Physics in
high school, and need to science coursed for humanities core
curriculum requirement. There was no lab, so we didn't have any TAs or
lab assistants.
My fellow freshmen had a 3-day a week, hour-long "Rise of Western
Civilization" course given in the campus movie theatre, which
held 600 students. One day a week they met with a TA, and were
subjected to quizzes. Meanwhile, I was in a similar course with
20-30 classmates, and could interact with the professor. English
Comp en masse was something else I avoided.
> I suspect that's what Mark meant.
>
> It's much more complicated these days. My daughter is at uni and much of the class contact is by webinar or podcast or somesuch.
>
The other large classes tended to be things like introductory
Biology and Chemistry, where Liberal Arts B.A and B.S majors,
Engineering students, pre-meds, nursing students, those aiming
at other health fields like Medical Technologist had to punch
their "basic science" tickets before going on to take fun stuff
like Organic Chemistry or Materials Science.
IMS, there were sections with higher course numbers for the
science and engineering majors, and lower numbers for those
of us merely rounding ourselves out in the old-fashioned
"liberal arts" sense.
Besides instructors who are professors, or some junior variant,
there are mere instructors. These guys are academic nomads, often
teaching at more than one campus, and never knowing from year to
year where they will get hired next. I had pretty good luck
with those. I learned Macroeconomics from someone who had a
full time job doing econometrics a local Fortune 500 company.
I took two introductory computer programming classes from a
woman who worked full time for the local Bell phone company,
in the days before all the individual Bells merged into RBOCs,
aka "Baby Bells." I had an instructor for a sophomore level
intro to philosophy class who was working on his doctorate.
He was a natural teacher. I had previously taken that class in
the honors track, with a professor teaching, and that fellow
made my head swim. Well, that and the fact that I took it
in the semester I got sick and had to withdraw from the course.
My university had about 8 or 9 thousand undergrads, and a total
enrollment of 10-12 k, so it was measurably smaller than the
big state universities. I heard horror stories from transfers
from Enormous State U that all their freshman year classes were
large lecture hall, sink or swim, almost never get to speak to
the instructor experiences. Many interesting oaths were sworn
in the direction of supposedly brilliant TAs whose Ingrish
proficiency was so poor that one could not get an answer, especially
in courses like Calculus or the prerequisites for Calc that not
everybody's high school taught. I had a sub-continental math
professor, who did his computations at the blackboard under
in breath in Hindi or something else from his homeland, but
when he spoke English it was understandable, if accented.
It helped that my HS math teachers had covered all the same stuff!
Some of my midwestern classmates had more of a problem. Back
home on Long Island my family doctor was a Pakistani immigrant.
Prof D didn't sound too strange to me after that!
This was all 35-40ish years or so ago, give or take.
Kevin R