Stan Barr wrote:
> Richard Monjure wrote:
>> But keep in mind, that when Marconi put together his practical
>> wireless after the turn of the century 1900, he was using many,
>> many of Nicola Tesla's patents. (And he paid for them.)
>
> I've just finished reading "A History of Wireless Telegraphy 1838-1899"
> by John Joseph Fahie, a most interesting book. Being published in 1899
> it is free from the modernist revisionism that has been a feature of
> many later books! (Re-published by Elibron Classics, 2005)
>
D.J.J. Ring, Jr. suggested I forward the following private email to the
list as it might be of interest to others:
D.J.J. Ring, Jr. wrote:
> So Stan, tell us if what Mr. Monjure said was right or any comments
you might have from the book you have just read, thanks!
Well the book pre-dates Marconi's commercial venture so the question of
patents doesn't really get discussed. But it's quite clear that the
early pioneers freely shared information and often worked together.
For example one of Marconi's early setups consisted of a Righi exciter,
a Ruhmkorff coil and a morse key for the tx and a Branley-Lodge coherer
for the rx. But it took Marconi to bring it all together and make it
work. This was 1897.
In 1893 Tesla proposed a transmitter using vertical aerials connected to
a large conducting body, but: "Owing to press of other work this
experiment was never tried, and so has remained a bare suggestion."
The following year (1894) Lodge succeeded in transmitting a signal 150
yards but never followed it up. In all Lodge, Poppoff, Minchin and
Rutherford all pre-date, more or less, Marconi's successful system, but
in the end it's Marconi who made it into a practical means of
communication. IIRC Marconi himself always regarded Heinrich Hertz as
the father of wireless.
The bulk of the book is taken up with induction systems, aerial, through
the earth and through water.
These early books are fascinating...next on my list is "Examination of
the Telegraphic Apparatus and the Processes in Telegraphy" by Samuel
Finley Breese Morse, 1869.
Also recently read: "Wireless at Sea, The First Fifty Years" a Marconi
publication from 1950. The only advantage to being a bit poorly is
having the time to do all this reading!