Re: [HasiruUsiru] Re: (theaccomodatingcity) More school children dying in road accidents in India

6 views
Skip to first unread message

Sujit Patwardhan

unread,
Oct 19, 2014, 7:03:28 AM10/19/14
to Deepa Mandrekar Rao, PTTF General, mumbaitran...@googlegroups.com, theaccomo...@googlegroups.com, Hasire Usiru


Though in a slightly different context, here is a video on "How the Dutch Got Their Cycle Paths".



I think it is relevant because the spark that ignited the massive demand for safe roads - particularly safe cycling facilities was the shocking reality of hundreds of children being the victims of road accidents.

I think we are at a stage where roads and traffic are killing a massive number of adults as well as children. This was also brought home in an episode of "Satyamev Jayate" last Sunday.

However the discussion so far has focused mainly on bad roads, bad/defective vehicles and driver error. These are no doubt very important but I think we are missing out on the overall viewpoint which recognizes that there is something wrong in the direction of Traffic Planning we are pursuing. We are all clamouring for safety but at the same time also demanding:-

Bigger/wider roads, 
Signal-free junctions (so auto vehicles need not stop),
Increased vehicle speeds (all road widening and flyover proposals include this as a key requirement)
Wider roads (every time there is congestion the first demand is to widen the road and when that is physically difficult - a flyover) 
More infrastructure for accommodating more personal auto vehicles which naturally leads to -- wide roads, more parking lots which enables more personal vehicles to come on the roads, and everything that gives priority to personal auto vehicles over the pedestrian, the cyclist and the public transport user.

If we start giving highest priority to Pedestrians, Cyclists and Public Transport users even at the cost of the personal automobile users, we will get safer footpaths (needed by those who walk as well as those who want to catch the bus) safer cycle paths (even if it means making the auto vehicle lanes narrower) and stop pampering the personal automobile (by introducing tight speed limits) the traffic will become safer. The Netherlands in the nineteen seventies not only reduced the auto vehicles lane widths to 2 in each direction by turning rest of the lanes into pedestrian and cycle paths but also brought in force car restraint measures (making parking more expensive, making car-free zones and hiking levies on cars). Simultaneously they improved Public Transport.

We need to do a combination of such measures - appropriate to our conditions but aimed at the twin objective of: - 
a) encouraging Walking, Cycling and Public Transport. Actually majority of people already use these modes anyway,  and 
b) discouraging the use of personal auto vehicles

Unless this is the broader vision, just crying about road accidents and mourning the death of our children will achieve very little.

Do watch the video. The lessons of The Netherlands in 1970s are very relevant to the India of today.

--
Sujit









On Sun, Oct 19, 2014 at 10:04 AM, Deepa Mandrekar Rao deepama...@gmail.com [HasiruUsiru] <HasiruUsi...@yahoogroups.com> wrote:
 

We feel this everyday. It is so tragic that life is "cheap" in India. 

As architects, we insist on safety first, in design and on site, - but it is an uphill battle. From clients to contractors and contract and migrant labour workers, we find it a hard task to get through everyone. Statutory requirements do not exist - implementation is distant. 

If we know our rights as citizens and people on the street, we would insist on good design and practices. The biggest battle is against NOT knowing basic rights.

Best,

Deepa


On Sat, Oct 18, 2014 at 7:30 PM, Vinay Baindur <yani...@gmail.com> wrote:







More school children dying in road accidents in India

 IANS   ¦     Jul 25, 2014

New Delhi: India not only has the dubious distinction of having one of the worst road accident records in the world, but that these are taking more and more young lives, particularly of school children.

Road accidents have left nearly 70 children dead and many injured since the start of 2013, a NGO has said. More than 60 students were also injured in 11 accidents spread over seven states since January 2013 till July this year. In all instances, the victims were travelling in school buses which were either hit by other vehicles or trains or rolled down mountain slopes.

According to NGO Save Life Foundation, which works for road safety, the accidents took place in Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan, Maharashtra and Telangana.

In one of the worst disasters, 19 students were killed and some 20 injured when their school bus was smashed by a speeding train at an unmanned rail-road crossing in Telangana Thursday. The dead included the school bus driver.

Although the number of school children is a miniscule part of the total number of Indians dying daily on the roads, activists say most accidents are avoidable.

Piyush Tewari, founder and president of Save Life Foundation, said holding an adult "accountable for safety of children while on the move" and having child safety laws would act as deterrents.

Two accidents this year injured 12 school students. The first took place May 12 in Greater Noida in Uttar Pradesh, injuring two students. Ten students were injured in adjoining Noida April 29 when their school bus was hit by a state-run bus.

Three children died when their school bus collided with a truck at Malkapur in Maharashtra Jan 10 this year.

According to the foundation, all the accidents involving school buses in 2013 led to deaths.

Six students lost their lives on the Solapur-Dhule highway while on an excursion in Maharashtra Dec 7, 2013.

In an accident in Tamil Nadu's Pudukottai district in June 2013, a mini van collided with a bus, killing seven school children.

Another seven children died when their bus fell into a gorge in Jammu and Kashmir's Anantnag district in April 2013.

In July last year, 11 students were killed and 20 injured when their bus hit a truck in Rajasthan's Hanumangarh district.

Another school bus-truck collision in Jalandhar in Punjab March 4, 2013, left 11 children dead.

These figures indicate how grave the issue of child safety was in India, said Tewari.

According to the National Crime Records Bureau, 20 children under the age of 14 years die daily in road accidents in India. The nearly 70 deaths between January 2013 and July 2014 are of school students.

Still, India has no child safety laws, Tewari said. Under child safety laws, children should be provided helmets and seat belts, and an adult should be posted on all school buses to supervise them and check errant drivers.

A RTI-based study by the foundation found that deaths while going to schools rose in 2012 by 39.25 percent.

School buses should be put in a special class of vehicles, like an ambulance, said Tewari. "School buses are commercial vehicles, which means a truck driver can drive a school bus," Tewari told IANS.

Special category would bring in three distinct benefits.

"First, it will ensure that there is a strong procedure to check on the licensing," Tewari said.

"Second, the drivers will be required to undergo training and will have to renew their licence each year.

"Third, there will be certain safety standards such as seat belts, low floor buses in place," he said.

Tewari wants those neglecting the safety of children while commuting to be subjected to severe penalties.
India has only about one percent of the world's vehicles but accounts for 10 percent of the world's road accidents. According to Save Life Foundation, there is a road accident death in India every four minutes and about 380 deaths occur every day, equivalent to a jumbo jet crashing daily.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "theaccomodatingcity" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to theaccomodating...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.



--
Deepa Mandrekar

monsoon design
12/2, banaswadi main road,
cooke town,
bangalore 560005

tel: +91 80 41621740/ +91 80 25806139
pers.: +91 9880400477

__._,_.___

Posted by: Deepa Mandrekar Rao <deepama...@gmail.com>




--
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Parisar
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sujit Patwardhan
patwardh...@gmail.com
su...@parisar.org
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yamuna, ICS Colony, Ganeshkhind Road, Pune 411 007, India
Tel: +91 20 25537955
Cell: +91 98220 26627
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Parisar: www.parisar.org
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages