All:
For the record, and for the Massachusetts Butterfly Club record-keeper, Keith's Azure photo does appear to be a spring form Summer Azure (Celastrina neglecta). This is rather unusual for New England, as I have only seen two other spring form records - both from Rhode Island. Why Summer Azure (spring form)?
1) Even "steel gray ground color".
2) Crisp spot pattern.
3) Spots have a distinct gray (near-black) pigment.
4) Summer Azure spring brood tends to be among the very first butterflies to emerge. In Massachusetts, they would emerge right at the beginning of the Spring Azure (Celastrina ladon) flight, or even earlier. I had considered calling this a Cherry Gall Azure, but those are white beneath and won't start to emerge until after May 1, probably even later this spring.
5) The general "look" is just different from either Spring, Northern or Cherry Gall Azures.
Interestingly, this seems to be increasingly happening in the northeast. The Summer Azure spring brood is the predominant "Spring Azure" flight in the Washington D.C. area, and this one matches those very well. And despite this unusually cold winter.
Harry Pavulaan