A dear friend recently gifted me with this CD, and I'm happy to report
that I too find the sound excellent on this disc. It's a superb record
of Lanza in top form, and I hope it gets the widest-possible attention
from critics and customers alike. This is certainly one Lanza CD that
can be recommended from start to finish!
Is it the best reproduction to date of that fantastic concert in 1947?
I guess that depends on personal taste. If you're distracted by
surface noise, then this reproduction will be a revelation, as, for
the first time, it's virtually clean as a whistle in terms of hiss
reduction. Mario's high notes are also generally brighter and more
exciting than they've ever sounded (to my ears) before on these
recordings. The only downside is the trade-off incurred in achieving
that brighter, more vibrant sound: there's a slight loss of warmth or
richness at times compared with the sound quality we hear on the CD
that accompanies the second edition of Armando's book. The one
exception is O Soave Fanciulla (remastered by Vince on Armando's CD),
on which Lanza is actually more vibrantly captured -- especially at
the beginning -- on the book CD rather than on the Andromeda disc.
(Vince: Since you have the second edition, I suggest you compare the
two reproductions of this duet; you may well find yourself preferring
your own efforts to those of Andromeda's engineers!)
But I definitely prefer the sound on the Andromeda CD to that of the
1989 Melodram Hollywood Bowl CD, which is the only other disc to have
appeared that contains the entire concert. I also wholeheartedly agree
with Muriel that it's historically important (not to mention immensely
satisfying) to hear Lanza's contributions in their original context.
For that reason alone, the CD is a must-have for anyone who doesn't
already own the Melodram disc. Lanza was certainly in great company
that night, and my only quibble is that Andromeda has repeated the
misspelling of Frances Yeend's name that first appeared on the
Melodram CD, masculinizing poor old Frances into "Francis" :-)
Cheers
Derek