My streak of 100% survival is over. It was only a matter of time and this winter has been much harsher than the previous two.
Of my full size production hives (>3 deep) 7/9 are still alive. Of the two that died one very few bees and the other looked like they started rearing brood and then half bees moved off the brood and half stayed. Both had plenty of honey left.
Of my late start hives (<3 deep) 3 of 5 are alive. One was a Styrofoam hive that had an untouched full super of honey on top and a ton of dead bees on the bottom board.
Of my multiple deep nucs (~2 deep equivalent) 3/5 are alive. Those that died still had food.
I also tried experimenting with some single deep nucs that were pushed together, insulated, and given sugar on top. Unfortunately only 1/9 are still alive. Some ran out of stores but most still had sugar. It looks like mice got into a few. If the one survives the winter I'm definitely grafting queens from it. Going forward I'll stick to trying to overwinter multiple deep nucs; single deep just isn't enough even if they are insulated and pushed together.
My take home lesson so far is bigger the better. My big hives are still going strong.
Dale,
how do you feed sugar syrup at this time?
For the longest time I've been told, and read, that bees won't take syrup under 50 degrees. Then 2 years ago a beekeeper with over 30 years of experience said that he feeds sugar water in January and February if needed. Last year I heard the same from another long time beekeeper. They feed in small amounts and replace as needed but it works for them.