Progress report on the powder actuated tool:
I did one test shot into a concrete beam in the wood shop. I was shooting a 1-1/2" nail with a washer to fix a slotted angle bracket into the ceiling to attach wire hangers. Result was a spalling the concrete in a 1 inch radius all around the nail. The nail only penetrated about 1/2" and bent.
I have no experience with this tool, so I don't know if this is a total fail or if adjusting the charge would work. Because I'm fixing an angle bracket, there is no room to attach the spall guard to the end of the tool, so concrete chips fly everywhere. I resorted to hammer drilling to anchor the minimum I needed to hang the ductwork, but still need to install about 2X the anchor points to give us some safety margin.
I'm willing to do more tests with this tool on this concrete if someone with experience thinks it's worthwhile and gives me some guidance. Let me know by reply to this thread.
BTW: I researched the strength of different concrete anchors. Here's the ultimate pullout strength of various anchors in 4000 psi concrete:
Blue Hawk 1/4" lag shield ..................................................550 lb
1/4" Tapcon screw, 1-1/4" deep ..........................................720 lb
Shot-fired nail, 0.145" shank, 1-1/2" deep .........................1,357 lb
3/16" Tapcon screw, 2-1/2" deep ......................................1,460 lb
1/4" wedge anchor, 1-1/8" deep ........................................1,771 lb
Red Head A7 adhesive, 3/8" threaded rod, 3-3/8" deep .... 10,980 lb