One thought which could be totally wrong ;).....
... I dont think your testing the execution speed of the try block at the end so much as the "compilation" speed.
I know js is a scripting language but Im pretty sure its got to atleast read the code in first and convert it to something other than straight text and looks for optimizations.
Like I said at the top I could be totally wrong.
The reason I think this and pointing it out is Ive done some tests before (wish I knew where they are;)) and noticed that minified code can run SLOWER than none minified code.
Minifiers can alter your code to use versions of the same thing that take up less text. These versions arent always as fast as what you wrote.
It was Uglifier (love that code) that I tested against.
I ended up using the compressor on this page....
...because of this once. Smaller delivery, but didnt change my code.