On Tuesday, December 1, 2015 at 5:46:28 PM UTC-8, Velvet Glove wrote:
> There goes my goal of actually getting to this *in* November.
>
> I have to admit I'm a little bummed that you guys disliked this so much, but in retrospect, I shouldn't be that surprised.
I like the series, just not this episode.
> I'm approaching this from a very different angle, because my son was the perfect age for Rescue Bots when it first aired, and having seen a lot of shows for the pre-school to kindergarten set, I can confirm that this is a solid one.
Here, I am really curious, do you mean this episode, or the series? The things that bothered me about the episode were things that would have either gone over the head of the target audience (mild misogyny) or actually appeal to them (pirate jokes).
> I don't like the animation either, but I've got used to it, the cast is great and overall, production values are high, even if it does feel like the redheaded stepchild of Transformers Prime.
I neither like nor dislike the animation. It's just kind of there. It's better than the woefully incompetent hand-drawn animation from TF:Animated. And, it doesn't bother me the way that TF:PrimeRID's animation does -- I might just have lower standards for the kiddie show.
> I intended it to be an introduction to Transformers for my kids, but without Decepticons (there are recurring villains, but most episodes do without) it doesn't really feel like a Transformers show. Instead it's an introduction to sci-fi.
I never understood why we didn't have G1 Autobots dealing with a natural disaster, or something other than Decepticons in the first two seasons. It would have made perfect sense for them as characters, and provide a different drama.
> They've covered all the usual plotlines and made some up of their own, and while it might not be apparent in this episode, there are some good female characters: both action heroes and scientists. Sadly, they're not as prevalent as the men, and let's not even get into which characters have made it into the toyline ahead of the two female members of the main cast.
I really found the mayor's treatment of his wife in the first scene to be bothersome. Somewhere between offensive and lame. And a lot of the humor after that was in the same vein.
And Graham could have been the butt of the fishing-boot joke as well as Dani. After the opening, and the lame jealous-wife scene at the pageant, I may have been looking for something to take offense to.
> I didn't really watch the show at first, but the kids had it on and the characters started growing on me.
Graham and Boulder are my favorites, but there isn't enough of a character focus to really pull me in.
> I picked this episode because this was the one when I realized that I actually liked this show--because I have a soft spot for Jaws and appreciated the little homages thrown in there and because Blades is one of my favourite characters (second only to Chase, who as the series goes on, gets all the best lines, IMHO.)
Blades is probably my least favorite -- he's too much like Wreck-Gar from TF:Animated, absorbing everything and just spitting it out again. And playing a pirate didn't make him better.
> I figured that there were more Jaws and Moby Dick gags than in-jokes, and I assumed you'd rather get to know the bots than the humans (though Boulder gets less screentime than I thought... then again, of all the episodes I've seen, I've yet to see the writers figure out what to do with Boulder.) There are definitely episodes I like better, but they tend to be of the kind that subvert the status quo, and if you're unfamiliar with the canon, you won't appreciate the subversion.
It's Flobsters, isn't it? Of course it's Flobsters...
I don't think the show is so revolutionary that you really need to know the canon to be aware of when it is subverted. Everything is drawn with big, wide brushes -- which is fine for a show like this -- but the structure is a bit of a well-trodden path.
> Anyway, I'm very fond of Rescue Bots even if my kids are outgrowing it. It came along at exactly the right time for us and was a great introduction for all kinds of sci fi tropes.
>
> Velvet Glove (who also never met a pirate joke she didn't like.)
Not sure I've met a pirate joke that I did like...
It's not a bad show, generally, but this episode felt like it was hand-crafted to irritate me. I work in software, and it appalls me to see how women get treated in the industry, even on a day to day basis, so belittling the female characters just got under my skin. That, and pirate jokes.
And no resolution. It wasn't an episode, it was the beginning of a story arc.