On Fri, 23 Dec 2011 06:31:24 -0800 (PST), "
tra...@optonline.net"
<
tra...@optonline.net> wrote:
>
>CFL's are simply not suited to all applications, despite what
>you may think, that's what's wrong with them.
And that is one reason incandescent will never be eliminated, nor is
anyone trying.
Some of
>the obvious issues and where they don't work:
>
>A - The light is not even close to the same color quality
>
>Areas used for reading or fine work where you need
>to focus. Some decorative fixtures that simply don't
>look good with a CFL.
Some CFLs are actually better. Yes, I hated those green things of the
early days and refused to use them, however, the new ones are quite
nice in our regular lamps in the house.
>
>B - They take a significant amount of time to warm up
>to even a reasonable brightness and it's worse at low
>temps.
>
>Light outside the door. Think I want to wait 3 mins to
>see who's there in winter? Or my kitchen, where I
>want to turn the light on, grab something and leave
>in 20 secs. Put in a CFL and then what do you do
>to fix that: Leave them on for hours.
Outside the door it takes a few seconds, but again, the new ones are
plenty bright when first turned on.
As for the kitchen, they are plenty bright enough to "grab something"
and leave in 20 seconds. Be realistic, a 7 watt bulb would do for
most things like that. If you are going to eat a meal or cook dinner,
they are warmed up in 20 seconds or so and you will never lack for
light.
>
>C - You can't tell before buying them how long any
>particular one takes when turned on to put out a
>reasonable amount of light because the skunk manufacturers don't spec
>it.
Reliable brands have been pretty good.
>
>D - In my experience, they don't last very long.
I put them in place at work where we have night lights. We went from
changing bulbs every few months to changing CFLs every few years.
These are also in cold and damp locations too. Saves us a lot of time
and money and aggravation from having lights burn out. PITA to drag a
big ladder into stairwells.
>
>E - They can't be dimmed much, they are not
>dimmable along a wide range like regular bulbs.
>And the ones that are partially dimmable cost a
>lot more. See D above.
If I have a dimmable situation I'm still using the old bulbs. It has
not been an issue, nor is anyone trying to take my decorative bulbs
away.
>
>
>CFLs are fine for many general lighting areas,
>but that doesn't mean they fit all applications.
I don't think anyone is. Nor do I think anyone ever will. You have
your mind made up based on what the old bulbs were like. At some
point if you (and the many others like you) open your minds a bit
you'll find technology has improved and you can save a few bucks on
electricity.