On Tue, 14 Jun 2016 19:58:51 -0700 (PDT), Uncle Monster
<
uncl...@gmail.com> wrote:
But someone else posted this originally, I think:
>> > Our rights were not given to us by our Constitution and Bill of Rights. Americans already have those rights when we're born. Those documents affirm our rights. ^_^
This version of this saying doesn't mention God, but the other ones
I've seen do. They say that God gave us rights, but for those whose
major holy book is the Bible, if you look in the Bible, I don't think
there is anywhere where it gives any person a right or asserts that a
person has a right. Maybe I'm wrong. Let me know.
What it does do is give man duties. Duties with regard to God and
with regard to his fellow man. But duties are not rights.
The closest thing in the Bible to a right is indirect. If other
people have a duty not to murder you, then you sort of have a right to
live. Well, it's like you have a right to live. If others have a
duty not to steal, then it's like you have a right to your own
property. But there is no stated right to either of these things.
You can see this in criminal trials now. People are tried for their
own act of murder, not for violating the right to live of someone
else. They are tried for their acts of stealing, not for violating
the right of someone else to own property. The only trials involving
rights are related to recent laws, civil rights laws, voting rights
laws. But even most recent laws are not like those. People are sued
for violating their duty not to pollute the water or air, for their
acts, not for violating some right that other people might want to
have to drink clean water or breathe clean air.
In the version of the saying given at the top, it claims people have
rights when they are born, but it doesn't mention God and it gives no
other reason that would be true. It's an assertion with no evidence
and no apparent basis.
But even assuming for the sake of argument that it is true, how are
those rights of any value?
In fact, it's hard to distinguish having a right from not having one
by watching what happens. In most of the world for most of time, at
least Europe which I know more about, most people had few if any legal
rights and no absolute legal rights. Their tribal leaders, their
kings, their feudal lords had rights and the power to force their
underlings to do whatever the lord wanted them to do. A king or the
head of the Visigoths, for example, could even have someone killed at
his whim, no trial needed, and no crime even need be asserted.
And this was all true regardless of what rights people supposedly had
from God or when they were born. Now what good are rights when one
is treated as if he had none? Ask a slave being whipped in pre-Civil
War America if he has the rights he was born with or that God gave
him. Who knows? Who can tell? That's just one category of 100's of
millions of examples.
What separates our society from those earlier ones and others in other
parts of the world now is in fact the Constitution, mostly the Bill of
Rights, which provides *enforceable* rights. There are times when
those rights are violated, and when their implementation is delayed
for months, years, or forever, but in practice we have the benefit of
far, far more rights than most people did in most of the world for
most of time. And it's because of the Constitution and the fair laws
passed under it.