I’ve met Dave in person and I respect his opinions even when I don’t agree with them. Dave’s contrarian takes are based on more than spleen or provocation and I want to see if there’s a discussion to be had.
Last year when I realized I had no need for Disney+ I took 9 days and watched the 9 Star Wars movies just to check them off the list. My take on the original (or ep. 4 for the purists) is that Lucas wanted to make a fun adventure film and didn’t care if the mythology or plot made any sense. Just get the characters into and out of danger and lead up to the big battle scene. And going back to my question to Dave there was something charming about how primitive the effects were.
When the movie first came out the kid who lived across the street from me and was a high school senior told me he saw the film 4 times in its first week. I saw it later and was nowhere near as impressed. I wouldn’t dispute Dave saying it’s not a good movie but I’d like him to back that up. I don’t know of many movies that had that effect on their audiences.