I think this is one of those things where both sides are off. Coates criticisms of Israel, while not exactly unique in the current climate, are extreme, and arguably oversimplify, distort, and minimize both Israel’s position vis a vis its Arab neighbors and the treatment of US Blacks in the Jim Crow south. His views obviously deserved tough examination, and CBS News is leaving and odd impression that tough questioning is inconsistent with its standards.
However, it is also true that Dokoupil went beyond being tough in his questioning, he was insistent, over controlling and out of balance. He has two daughters living in Israel, and while understandable, it did seem like his paternal concern bled into his questioning. This is the part that was inconsistent with CBS News standards, but they have not been clear about explaining that, I guess because their initial reaction was leaked.