Hi,
As I did create the plugins (TW 5.1.15), the core tabs macro didn't use buttonTemplates, as in TW V5.1.19. Those button templates are intended for users and plugin authors to extend the core tabs macro. ...
Those core extension are not enough, for the functionality link-to-tabs and/or edit-tabs need. ...
That's why both plugins do replace the $:/core/macros/tabs macro, which is not optimal! The same is true for Mat's TabLinks plugin.
The core tab macros form 5.1.19 has the same problem as may other elements in the core UI. I can't deal with tiddler titles, that contain special chars. eg:: xxx]
If you use this title the tabs macro will fail. ...
We can fix this, in a similar way as the TOC macro. ... BUT this will increase the overall complexity of the macro. ... I'm not sure, if Jeremy will merge PRs, that fix severe problems and make macros more complex.
I do have an idea, how we can design the core tabs macro in a way, that plugin authors are not forced to overwrite them. .. So it should be possible to install edit-tabs, link-to-tabs and Mats tablink plugin at the same time. ... It wouldn't make sense, but they shouldn't kill each other, as they do atm.
-mario